Burwick v. WoodBurwick v. Wood
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Prewitt
Following hearing on Defendant’s motion, the trial court taxed against Plaintiffs certain deposition costs and charges of the court reporter, the latter in connection with a portion of the transcript in a previous appeal to this District. Appellants contend that the trial court erred in taxing $1,127.34 in costs relating to depositions because Respondent did not personally pay such costs, but they were paid by her insurance company. Appellants also contend that the trial court, under Rule 84.18, did not have jurisdiction to tax costs relating to the appeal.
Appellants’ first point deals -with
As Appellants assert, costs did not exist at common law and their allowance is a creature of statute, thus statutes allowing taxation of costs are strictly construed. Architectural Resources, Inc. v. Rakey, 912 S.W.2d 676, 679 (Mo.App.1995); Parrett v. Integon Life Ins. Co., 590 S.W.2d 411, 413 *952(Mo.App.1979). Here, however, there is nothing to construe, as the plain meaning of the statute controls.
There is no requirement in
Here, the evidence was sufficient for the trial court to have found that Respondent was .liable for the deposition cost and would have been obligated to pay them had her insurance company not done so. Appellants cite Fisher v. Spray Planes, Inc., 814 S.W.2d 628, 633 (Mo.App.1991), but that ease does not change the result in this matter. Fisher dealt with the 1986 version of
Appellants’ second point relates to the costs pertaining to the previous appeal of this matter, and that the trial court erred in taxing the costs of the record on that appeal. Appellants are correct that: “Assessment of cost of the record on appeal is the subject of Rule 84.18 and is not a matter within the jurisdiction of the trial court.” Landis v. Sumner Mfg. Co., Inc., 750 S.W.2d 466, 471 (Mo.App.1988). See also §§ 514.160 and 514.280, RSMo 1994; Walden v. Dudley, 49 Mo. 419, 423 (1872). Appellants’ Point II has merit and is granted.
Respondent asks in her brief that if we find that the trial court erred in taxing the costs pertaining to the appeal, that this Court enter an order taxing certain costs against Appellants. There has been no proceeding instituted in this Court which would support such an order. See Brownlee v. Hewitt, 1 Mo.App. 604 (1876). Respondent’s request is denied.
The portion of the order pertaining to the taxing of $1,127.34 in deposition costs is affirmed, and the order is reversed pertaining to the cost related to the previous appeal. The costs of this appeal are assessed equally as between Appellants and Respondent.
GARRISON, P.J., and CROW, J., concur.