Burnwell Coal Co. v. SetzerBurnwell Coal Co. v. Setzer
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- McClellan
Plaintiff’s intestate, a boy about 15 years of age, was killed on March 21, 1911, while in the employ and service of the defendant (appellant) in its operation of a coal mine. The cause of his death was a trip of coal cars, which, while being hauled up the slope, got loose and ran back down the slope upon him. The counts passing to the jury were those numbered 1, 11, and 15, and one lettered A. The first count ascribed intestate’s wrongful death to negligence in respect of the safety of the place in which he worked. The eleventh count was framed under the first subdivision of the Liability Act (Code, § 3910), and charged that the defect in the condition of the ways, etc., consisted in the negligent failure to provide or maintain a dead latch or derailing switch to derail cars when becoming loóse on the incline in the mine. The fifteenth count was framed under the first subdivision of that statute,‘and alleged the defect to have consisted in the absence of a drag, attached to a car or cars, which while ascending a slope in said mine became detached and ran back down the slope, causing intestate’s death. Count A was framed under the second subdivision of the statute, ascribed the negligence to. Superintendent Wooten, and described his dereliction to have been that he allowed the work of the defendant, therein described, *403to be performed in a manner dangerous to the safety of plaintiff’s intestate.
Count A was not subject to the demurrer.
The report of the appeal will contain a statement, in substlance, of pleas 2, 4, 5, and 6. According to the recitals of the minute entry, demurrers to these pleas were overruled, a ruling in favor, of course, of the de*404fendant appellant. To these pleas, plaintiff replied by replications 1 to 5, inclusive. Replication 1 was a joinder in issue on plea 1, which plea was the general issue. By reference, replications 1 and 2 were interposed to pleas 4 and 5, thus joining issue on pleas 4 and 5, as well as replying specially with the matter averred in replication 2, which was that it was not the duty of intestate to remedy the defect complained of in any count in the complaint. Replication 5 asserted, in avoidance of pleas 2, 4, 5, and 6, that the only means of egress afforded for him to leave the mine in which he was employed was the slopeway, in which he was killed when leaving the place of his employment. Demurrer to special replication 2 was overruled.
The only effect of the addition (italicized) to the statute was to remove as a basis of assumption of risk and of contributory negligence on.the part of an employee, in respect of a defective condition within the purview of the first subdivision of the Liability Act (section 3910), the remaining in service after knowledge by the employee, injured in consequence of the defect in condition to which the complaint or a count thereof attributed the injury for proximate cause, of the defect in condition of the ways, works, machinery, or plant of the master, except in cases where the employee injured was under the duty to remedy the defect causing his injury, or where the employee injured committed the negligent act causing the injury complained of. There is no general legislative purpose expressed, or necessarily impliable, to deny the existence or the defensive effect of contributory negligence or as-. sumption of’risk in all cases.
Here replication 2 asserted in assumed avoidance of the defense interposed by plea 2, which was a plea of contributory negligence, the mere fact that no duty rested on the intestate to remedy the defects in conditions described in the complaint. It does not appear from the plea that any such duty Avas imposed on intestate under his contract of employment. The plea avers that intestate, with knowledge that a loaded car was likely or liable to break loose on the slope and injure the intestate, nevertheless negligently, without as*406certaining whether loaded cars were being drawn np the slope, took the thus known dangerous course, and loaded cars then being pulled up the slope became loose and ran back down the slope, injuring him. If the plea had undertaken to exonerate the defendant (master) because of intestate’s remaming in the service after knowledge of the defective condition counted on, then the replication (2) would have been apt and effective to avoid the defense so asserted. There was error, therefore, in overruling the demurrer to replication 2. Like considerations lead to the conclusion that replications 3 and 4 were similarly faulty in so far as these replications adopt, in reference, replication 2 to pleas 4 and 5.
*407
The judgment is reversed, and the cause is remanded.
Reversed and remanded.
Anderson, C. J., and Mayfield and Somerville, JJ., concur.