Bruce v. Fiss

56 N.Y.S. 234 | N.Y. Sup. Ct. | 1899

Gaynor, J.:

I think on reflection that the damages for injury to person and property are recoverable in this action, and not confined to an action of tort. Many cases may be cited where like damage was recovered, but in actions of tort, viz., on an allegation and proof of deceit or fraud in making the warranty. But to say that such damage may be recovered in an action for deceit does not hold it not recoverable if there be no deceit, but only a breach of the contract of warranty. The damages recoverable in the latter case are such as must have been in the minds of both of the contracting parties as likely to occur if the warranty should not prove true. In Smith v. Green (L. R. 1 C. P. Div. 92) the case was the warranty of a cow free from the foot and mouth disease. She was in fact infected with the disease, and gave it to the purchaser’s herd. He sued for damages, claiming not only for the cow warranted but for the loss to Ms herd. There was a count for breach of the warranty and another for fraud in the maMng of it. The jury found the warranty, but that there was no fraud. On motion to reduce the damages to the loss of the cow, and on appeal, it was contended for the defendant that for a mere breach of the warranty he was not responsible for the loss of the other cows, though he would have been if he had been guilty of a false representation. It was held that the measure of damage was the same without the fraud, as the result if the cow was infected must have been in the minds of both parties. So must the result of driving a McMng and run-away horse to a light wagon be in the minds of both parties when the horse is being bought and warranted kind and gentle for that purpose. The cases Allen v. Truesdell (135 Mass. 75) and Case v. Stevens (137 Mass. 551) are in tort, the latter not being easy to understand. I think the law is with the plaintiff, unless it may be avoided by some subtle distinction which is without foundation in reason (Short v. Matteson, 81 Iowa, 638; Swain v. Schieffelin, 134 N. Y. 471; United States Trust Co. v. O’Brien, 143 N. Y. 284; Walker v. Milner, 4 F. & F. 745).

The motion is derned.