58 Iowa 689 | Iowa | 1882
Lead Opinion
The provisions regarding stay of execution are general, the same periods being applicable to justice’s courts and to courts of record. See Code, § 3061. The enforcement of a judgment can be delayed just as long by taking a stay in the court of a justice of the peace, as in the District or Circuit Court. Section 3102 of the Code is also general in its provisions. It declares that “In no action where the defendant has * * * * * * stayed execution on the judgment, shall he be entitled to redeem. We know of no authority for limiting the application of this section to judgments recovered in courts of record. Immediately upon the rendition of a judgment in a justice’s court the defendant may stay execution. The plaintiff is not required to wait until the stay expires before he files a transcript of the judgment in the office of the clerk of the court. Suppose he files such transcript as soon as the stay is taken, what becomes of the stay ? The filing of a transcript cannot defeat the stay. Upon the contrary it remains in force and during its continuance prevents the enforcement of the judgment notwithstanding the filing of the transcript. Can we say then that because the stay was taken in the justice’s court section 3102 does not apply in so far as it denies redemption, and that the defendant shall be allowed to redeem notwith
Upon the plaintiff’s appeal the judgment is affirmed. Upon the defendants’.appeal
Reversed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissentmg. — The foregoing opinion holds that Section 3102 of the Code applies to judgments rendered by a justice of the peace. I think this construction of the statute is erroneous. The statute provides that “in no action where the defendant has taken an appeal from the Circuit or District Court, or stayed execution on the judgment, shall he be entitled to redeem.” The appeal must have been taken from a judgment rendered by a court of record, then follow the words “or stayed execution.” This evidently means a stay of execution may be issued on the same class of judgments as those from which the appeal must be taken. That this is the proper construction is strengthened by the consideration that
The judgment of the Circuit Court should be affirmed.