Brooks and Gregory v. StateBrooks and Gregory v. State
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- McCulloch
Appellants were convicted of the crime of night riding, the charging part of the indictment being as follows:
“The said Logan Bowers, Joe Brooks and Lee Gregory in the county and State aforesaid, on the 13th day of April, A. D. 1925, being more than two persons, did wilfully, unlawfully and feloniously unite, confederate and band themselves together for the wilful and unlawful purpose of doing an unlawful act in the night time by then and there, wilfully, unlawfully, maliciously and feloniously injuring and destroying the dipping vat known as the Graham vat, situated in Crawford County, Arkansas, and against the peace and dignity of the State of Arkansas.”
There was a demurrer to the indictment, which was overruled, and the ruling of the court in that regard is the basis of the first assignment of error presented on this appeal. It is contended that the indictment is defective in failing to allege that, pursuant to the act of banding together, the persons named went forth in the night time and then and there destroyed the vat. This was ruled against the contention of appellants in the case of Scott v. State, 114 Ark. 38, where the statute was analyzed, and it was held that the first section thereof (Crawford & Moses’ Digest, § 2795) made it unlawful for two or more persons to unite, confederate or band themselves together for the purpose of “doing an unlawful act in the night time. ’ ’ We held that this constituted an offense, even though there was no consummation of the conspiratorial act.
It is next contended that there was no testimony corroborating that of the accomplice who testified in the case, and that for this reason the evidence is not sufficient to sustain the verdict. According to the testimony in the case,
It is contended that the instruction of the court on the subject of corroboration of the accomplice was erroneous in reading the statute with reference to misdemeanors, but we think that there was no prejudicial error for the reason that the court stated to the jury that that part of the statute had no application.
The court gave the following instruction-,’ which was objected to, and the ruling of the court is assigned as error:
“3. The court tells you that as a matter of law the witness Logan Bowers is an accomplice. Now, it is not necessary that the corroborating testimony be sufficient to convict the defendants or either of them without the testimony of an accomplice or of some circumstantial evidence, or both. But, if you find that there is enough corroboration, either by direct proof or circumstantial evidence, to convince you beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendants or either of them is guilty, you should convict. Otherwise you should acquit. ’ ’
There are other objections to the instructions, which we do not consider of sufficient importance to discuss. We are of the opinion that the evidence was legally sufficient, and that there was no error in the court’s charge.
Judgment affirmed.