Brand v. BakerBrand v. Baker
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Bean
after stating the facts, delivered the opinion of the court.
The court approaches the examination of the questions involved on this appeal unembarrassed by the consideration that its decision will affect the title to the land sold «under the execution issued on the judgment in favor of the defendants and against the plaintiff. The redemption, on December 31, 1901, by Murdock, for and on behalf of the plaintiff, operated as a termination of the effect of the sale or a payment and satisfaction of the judgment (B. & C. Comp. § 250), so that, whatever conclusion we may reach, it will not result in the title to real property of the value of $30,000 passing to a purchaser at an execution sale for $42. The possibility of such a result, however, under the law, without the knowledge of the owner of the property, would seem to suggest the advisability of legislative action.
If, however, Murdock was not Brand’s attorney, but was acting wholly without authority, as now seems to be contended, then his agents in Portland were inexcusably negligent in not ascertaining what steps, if any, had been taken to enforce the judgment, and therefore the order of confirmation was not taken against the plaintiff through his excusable neglect. They *435knew that the judgment had been rendered, and was not paid, and they were chargeable with knowledge that, under the law, an execution could be issued thereon, the property of the judgment debtor seized and sold, and such sale confirmed, without notice to them or their principal, unless objections thereto were filed within a certain time. The law does not require notice to a judgment debtor of a proposed effort to collect the judgment against him, nor of the levy and sale of his property under an execution issued thereon, except by the filing of the sheriff’s certificate in the county clerk’s office, and the publication and posting of notices of sale. While it would no doubt have been an act of courtesy on the part of the sheriff or the defendants’ attorney to notify Maemaster & Birrell, the plaintiff’s agents and sureties on the attachment bond, of the issuing of execution and the purpose to levy upon the property, they were under no legal obligation to do so. It was the duty of the court, if the proceedings were regular, to confirm the sale on January 24, 1902, as there had been no objections filed thereto, and the time for filing the same had long since expired; so that this oi’der cannot be said to have been taken against the plaintiff through his excusable neglect, simply because he had no personal knowledge thereof. Mr. Justice Corliss, in speaking of the duty of a judgment debtor who sought to set aside a sale on the ground of inadequacy of price, and that he had no knowledge thereof until after the time for redemption had expired, said: “Under ordinary circumstances he should not be heard to plead that he was ignorant of the fact of sale. Knowing that there is a judgment lien against his land, and that the creditor is under no legal obligation to notify him of a single step connected with the sale of his land under the judgment, he must be on the alert to ascertain whether his land has been or is about, to be sold. Certainly, it is not a harsh rule which exacts of him such diligence, such measure of business prudence, in looking after his own interests, as is involved in the not difficult task of discovering within a year of the day of sale that his property has been sold under the judgment, which he knows.is a lien against it. He can always absolutely protect himself by *436paying the judgment; and, if he does not pay it, he at least knows that a sale may at any time take place, without his being personally notified of such fact. It is customary for the sheriff to malee report of the sale, and the law contemplates that an order confirming such sale may be entered. These papers are ordinarily made matters of record about the time of the sale, and it is an almost invariable custom to record the certificate of sale issued at the time the sale is made. For these reasons we do not think that the owner may couple with mere inadequacy of price his own inattention to his personal affairs, resulting in the loss of the right to redeem, and on this basis build up an exception to the rule that inadequacy of price affords no ground for relief, because the debtor might have redeemed. He cannot lose this right of redemption through his own want of diligence, and then urge its loss as a reason for taking his case out of the rule: Warren v. Stinson, 6 N. D. 293, 299 (70 N. W. 279).
So, in this case, the plaintiff and his agents, through their inattention or want of diligence, could not let the time go by without any effort to learn of the sale of the property under the execution, or the confirmation thereof, and then urge their want of notice as a reason for applying a year and a half after the sale for relief therefrom, or from the order of confirmation. It does not appear that they made an examination of the record, or inquiry of any officer or person who would likely possess knowledge on the subject, but they seem to have relied entirely upon Murdock, and therefore it is no legal excuse that they did not know of such proceedings. If objections had been filed to the confirmation of the sale, or if the plaintiff had known of the sale, and intended to file such objections, but was prevented from doing so by accident, surprise, or excusable neglect, or perhaps, even, if he had been so prevented from learning of the sale or of the confirmation thereof, there would be some ground for the argument that he should be entitled to relief under the statute, if his application was made within time. The statute, however, confines the relief to a party against whom a judgment, order, or other proceeding has been *437taken through his mistake, inadvertence, surprise, or excusable , neglect, and a judgment or order is not so taken simply because ’ the party did not know of it, unless the law requires him to be notified, when the means of knowledge were accessible, and he simply failed or neglected to avail himself thereof.
Reversed.