285 Mass. 82 | Mass. | 1933
The plaintiff, a childless widower more than ninety years old, directed the defendant, his nephew, to buy a piece of real estate with money furnished by the plaintiff. The plaintiff expected the title to be taken in his name, and the defendant had no reason to think otherwise. The defendant, however, took title in his own name. As soon as the plaintiff learned the fact, he insisted upon having title.
The defendant held title upon a resulting trust for the plaintiff. The plaintiff had an equitable right to a conveyance of the entire title, and the defendant as trustee had no right to withhold anything. Howe v. Howe, 199 Mass. 598. Davis v. Downer, 210 Mass. 573. Dwyer v. Dwyer, 275 Mass. 490. Cook v. Howe, 280 Mass. 325. The plaintiff’s consent, without any consideration, to accept less than his due, did not extinguish his equitable claim, any more than acceptance of part of an undisputed debt bars an action at law for the rest. Caragulian v. Rudd, 282 Mass. 260.
Decree affirmed with costs.