Bonamy v. ZenoffBonamy v. Zenoff
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- McNamee
OPINION
By the Court,
McNamee, J.:
As a result of the foregoing, appellant commenced the action herein for “wrongfully, falsely, and maliciously” arresting appellant “upon a pretended charge of disorderly conduct.”
The case was tried before a jury. At the close of the case respondent, pursuant to Rule 50 (a) NRCP, moved for a directed verdict. The motion was granted, judgment was entered in favor of respondent, and this appeal is from said judgment.
The only matter to consider on this appeal is whether the lower court erred in granting the motion for a directed verdict.
It is appellant’s theory of the case that the complaint is one for malicious prosecution. Elements of malicious prosecution, aside from termination of the criminal prosecution, are (a) want of probable cause, and (b) malice.
It is conceded that malice may be inferred from proof of want of probable cause. McNamee v. Nesbitt, 24 Nev. 400, 56 P. 37. On the other hand, want of probable cause cannot be inferred from malice. Fenstermaker v. Page, 20 Nev. 290, 21 P. 322.
We, thus, are concerned at this time only with the element of want of probable cause. No evidence tending to show want of probable cause was presented, and the evidence showing probable cause is undisputed. Appellant was committing a trespass, she refused to leave respondent’s premises upon request, and she stated
Because the facts relating to the existence of probable cause are not in dispute, it becomes a question of law whether such facts constitute probable cause. Centers v. Dollar Markets, 99 Cal.App.2d 534, 222 P.2d 136; Short v. Stuyvesant Ins. Co. of New York, 6 Cal.App.2d 309, 43 P.2d 872. The lower court determined this question in favor of respondent and, in our opinion, properly did so. See Mechanics’ Foundry v. Ryall, 62 Cal. 416; 75 Cal. 601, 17 P. 703. Consequently, there was nothing to go to the jury and the motion for a directed verdict was correctly granted.
Affirmed.
Badt, C. J., and Pike, J., concur.