Bigler v. VernonBigler v. Vernon
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Zimmerman
Plaintiffs Clark Bigler and Utah Taxpayers Association appeal from a summary judgment in favor of defendants Glen K. Vernon and Payson City Corporation. The trial court denied plaintiffs’ request for declaratory judgment, injunctive relief, and attorney fees because plaintiffs failed to
*1391
act within the thirty-day period as required by section 20-11-24(1) of the Code. Plaintiffs now argue, inter alia, that the trial court erred and that their claims are not time-barred by the Utah Constitution and statutes governing direct legislation.
See
The facts are not in dispute. On March 7, 1990, the Payson City Council passed city ordinance 02-21-90A. The ordinance authorized the collection of a tax on the sale and use of the services of telephone, gas, and electric utilities doing business in Payson. On March 26, 1990, plaintiffs and others filed an application for copies of a referendum petition form as the first step in the process of requesting that the ordinance be referred to the Payson City voters for their approval or rejection.
See
On October 17, 1990, plaintiffs filed a complaint in the fourth district court. They requested a declaratory judgment that section 20-11-21 (2)(b) did not prohibit a referendum of an ordinance enacting a new tax scheme. In the alternative, they requested that the court declare the statute unconstitutional under article VI, section 1(2) of the Utah Constitution, which allows public referenda of locally enacted ordinances. In addition, plaintiffs requested injunctive relief and an award of attorney fees and costs under sections 1983 and 1988 of title 42 of the United States Code on the grounds that their federal and state constitutional rights had been violated.
See
Defendants responded with a motion for summary judgment. In support, they argued that plaintiffs’ claims were time-barred under section 20-11-24(1), which requires referendum petitions to be filed within thirty days after enactment of the disputed ordinance.
Because summary judgment resolves only questions of law, we review the trial court’s conclusions for correctness.
Hill v. Seattle First Nat’l Bank,
827 P.2d 241, 246 (Utah 1992);
Clover v. Snowbird Ski Resort,
808 P.2d 1037 (Utah 1991);
Bonham v. Morgan,
788 P.2d 497, 499 (Utah 1989) (per curiam). The dispositive issue before this court is whether the claims are time-barred by the Utah Constitution and statutes governing direct legislation.
See
Before we reach this issue, some background is in order. Article VI, section 1(2) of the Utah Constitution deals with the rights of voters of any legal subdivision of the state to activate the machinery of initiative and referendum. As pertinent here, the provision allows voters to require referral of any ordinance enacted by a local lawmaking body to the voters for approval or rejection before the ordinance takes effect.
The current controversy arises from a dispute as to whether a tax ordinance may be referred. Section 20-ll-21(2)(b) states that the “legal voters ... may not require any budget or tax levy adopted by the governing body ... to be submitted to the voters.”
Despite the clarity of the statutory language and our prior case law, plaintiffs failed to file a petition within the thirty days following enactment of the ordinance. We note that plaintiffs do not challenge the constitutionality of this thirty-day limitation period. Rather, they center their argument on defendants’ decision to deny the petition application on the basis of their belief that section 20-ll-21(2)(b) prohibited referral of the ordinance.
We think that plaintiffs’ failure to take any action to pursue the completion of, or to preserve their right to, the referendum petition process during the thirty-day period following enactment of the ordinance bars relief. Defendants’ actions do not excuse plaintiffs’ failure to comply with the statutory deadline. Although nothing in the statutes governing direct legislation explicitly provides a remedy for denial of an application, we note that plaintiffs could have brought a mandamus action seeking to compel defendants to issue copies of the referendum petition form.
See
*1393
Moreover, plaintiffs could have produced, circulated, and filed their own referendum petitions within the relevant period of time. Statutes governing direct legislation detail the form the referendum petition should follow and provide that “if substantially followed, the petition shall be sufficient.”
Because we conclude that
Notes
. Article VI, section 1 of the Utah Constitution provides:
The Legislative power of the State shall be vested:
*1392 2. In the people of the State of Utah, as hereinafter stated:
The legal voters or such fractional part thereof, of the State of Utah as may be provided by law, under such conditions and in such manner and within such time as may be provided by law, may initiate any desired legislation and cause the same to be submitted to a vote of the people for approval or rejection, or may require any law passed by the Legislature (except those laws passed by a two-thirds vote of the members elected to each house of the Legislature) to be submitted to the voters of the State before such law shall take effect.
The legal voters or such fractional part thereof as may be provided by law, of any legal subdivision of the State, under such conditions and in such manner and within such time as may be provided by law, may initiate any desired legislation and cause the same to be submitted to a vote of the people of said legal subdivision for approval or rejection, or may require any law or ordinance passed by the law making body of said legal subdivision to be submitted to the voters thereof before such law or ordinance shall take effect.