Best Van Lines, Inc. v. Tim Walker, Docket No. 04-3924-CvBest Van Lines, Inc. v. Tim Walker, Docket No. 04-3924-Cv
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Sack
The defendant, Tim Walker, a resident of Waverly, Iowa, is the proprietor of a not-for-profit internet website that provides information and opinions about household movers. In August 2003, Walker posted derogatory comments about the plaintiff, Best Van Lines, Inc. (“BVL”), a New York-based moving company. Walker asserted, at two different locations on his website, that BVL was performing household moves without legal authorization and without insurance that is required by law. Less than a month later, BVL brought suit against Walker in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York alleging that the statements about it on the website were false, defamatory, and made with an intent to harm BVL. Compl. ¶¶ 21-30. BVL sought injunctive and monetary relief.
On May 4, 2004, the district court (Gerard E. Lynch, Judge) granted Walker’s motion to dismiss pursuant to
We affirm.
BACKGROUND
The defendant, Tim Walker, is the proprietor of a website, “MovingScam.com” (the “Website”). He operates it from his home in Wavérly, Iowa. As its name suggests, the Website provides consumer-related comments, most of them derogatory, about household movers in the United States. On or about August 5, 2003, Walker posted statements about BVL in the section of the Website called “The Black List Report.” Under the heading “Editor’s Comments,” Walker wrote that “as of 8/5/2003 [BVL] was performing interstate moving services without legal authority from the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, and did not carry Cargo insurance as required by law.” Compl. ¶ 8. Walker made similar factual assertions in response to a question about BVL that was posted on the message-board section of the Website by a person whose whereabouts are not disclosed in the record. 2
On August 26, 2003, BVL instituted this lawsuit against Walker by filing a complaint in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York. In it, BVL alleges that the statements about it on the Website were false, defamatory, and made with an intention to harm it. Compl. ¶¶ 21-30. We assume at this stage of the proceedings that BVL’s allegations are correct and can be proved. BVL seeks to have Walker enjoined from publishing further defamatory statements about BVL. It also seeks compensatory and punitive damages totaling $1.5 million.
Walker moved to transfer the action to the United States District Court for the Southern District of Iowa. BVL opposed the motion, but also treated it as a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction pursuant to
The district court granted what was construed to be Walker’s motion to dismiss. The court concluded that BVL had failed to allege facts sufficient to show that Walker had transacted business for purposes of
BVL appeals.
I. Standard of Review
We review a district court’s dismissal of an action for lack of personal jurisdiction de novo. Sole Resort, S.A. de C.V. v. Allure Resorts Mgmt., LLC, 450 F.3d 100, 102 (2d Cir.2006). “In order to survive a motion to dismiss for lack of personal jurisdiction, a plaintiff must make a prima facie showing that jurisdiction exists.” Thomas v. Ashcroft, 470 F.3d 491, 495 (2d Cir.2006).
II. Personal Jurisdiction in New York
A. The Issue on Appeal
This appeal raises a single question: whether the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York had personal jurisdiction over Walker for purposes of entertaining this lawsuit. To answer that question, we look first to the law of the State of New York, in which the district court sits. Kronisch v. United States, 150 F.3d 112, 130 (2d Cir.1998). If, but only if, our answer is in the affirmative, we must then determine whether asserting jurisdiction under that provision would be compatible with requirements of due process established under the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. See Int’l Shoe Co. v. Washington, 326 U.S. 310, 315, 66 S.Ct. 154, 90 L.Ed. 95 (1945).
Agreeing with the district court, we conclude that while New York appellate courts have not decided this precise issue, under well-settled principles of New York law, the district court did not have such jurisdiction. We therefore need not address the second question: whether, if New York law conferred it, asserting such jurisdiction would be permissible under the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution. 3 Still, because the analysis of the state statutory and federal constitutional limitations have become somewhat entangled in New York jurisprudence, we think it advisable to explore the relationship between the two in some detail.
B. Constitutional Limits on Personal Jurisdiction
In 1945, the Supreme Court held that states’ power to exercise personal jurisdiction over defendants consistent with the federal Constitution was not contingent on those defendants’ physical presence within the states’ borders. Int’l Shoe, 326 U.S. at 316, 66 S.Ct. 154. Instead, in order to exercise personal jurisdiction over out-of-state defendants, the Due Process Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment requires only that the defendants have “certain minimum contacts with [the forum state] such that the maintenance of the suit does not offend ‘traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice.’ ” Id. (citation omitted).
A court deciding whether it has jurisdiction over an out-of-state defendant under the Due Process Clause must evaluate the “quality and nature,”
Burger King Corp. v. Rudzewicz,
471 U.S. 462, 475, 105 S.Ct. 2174, 85 L.Ed.2d 528 (1985), of the defendant’s contacts with the forum state under a totality of the circumstances test,
id.
at 485-86, 105 S.Ct. 2174. The crucial question is whether the defendant has “purposefully availfed] itself of the privilege of conducting activities within the forum State, thus invoking the benefits and protections of its laws,”
id.
at 475, 105 S.Ct. 2174 (quoting
Hanson v. Denckla,
357 U.S.
Applying these principles, in Keeton v. Hustler Magazine Inc., 465 U.S. 770, 104 S.Ct. 1473, 79 L.Ed.2d 790 (1984), the Supreme Court concluded that a New Hampshire federal district court had jurisdiction over the defendant magazine-publisher, an Ohio corporation with its principal place of business in California, id. at 772, 104 S.Ct. 1473. The Court based its conclusion on the fact that the defendant’s magazine in which the alleged libel appeared had a monthly circulation in New Hampshire of 10,000 to 15,000. This established that the defendant “continuously and deliberately exploited the New Hampshire market,” creating in the defendant a reasonable expectation that it might be haled into court there in an action based on the contents of the magazine. Id. at 781, 104 S.Ct. 1473.
Also invoking the minimum contacts rubric, in Calder v. Jones, 465 U.S. 783, 104 S.Ct. 1482, 79 L.Ed.2d 804 (1984) — decided the same day as Keeton — the Court concluded that a California state court had personal jurisdiction over The National Enquirer, a nationally distributed weekly with editorial offices in Florida, and a reporter and an editor, both Florida residents, in a lawsuit based on an allegedly libelous story about the California activities of a California resident. Id. at 786, 788, 104 S.Ct. 1482. Employing what has since come to be called the “effects test,” the Court reasoned that because “California is the focal point both of the story and of the harm suffered,” jurisdiction over the defendants was “proper in California based on the ‘effects’ of their Florida conduct in California.” Id. at 789, 104 S.Ct. 1482. In the language of minimum contacts, when the defendants committed “their intentional, and allegedly tortious, actions ... expressly aimed at California,” they “must [have] ‘reasonably anticipate^] being haled into court there’ to answer for the truth of the statements made in their article.” Id. at 789-90, 104 S.Ct. 1482 (citations omitted).
Although Calder and Keeton were handed down simultaneously on similar subjects, they relied on independent, if conceptually overlapping, methods of demonstrating minimum contacts — Keeton on the defendant’s overall activity within the forum state; Calder on the in-state effects of out-of-state activity.
C. Long-Arm Statutes and
Relying on
International Shoe,
state legislatures began enacting laws, known as
The reach of New York’s long-arm statute, by contrast, does not coincide with the limits of the Due Process Clause. Analysis under it therefore may involve two separate inquiries, one statutory and one constitutional. If jurisdiction is statutorily impermissible, of course, we need not reach the question of its constitutionality.
The New York long-arm statute provides:
As to a cause of action arising from any of the acts enumerated in this section, a court may exercise personal jurisdiction over any non-domiciliary, or his executor or administrator, who in person or through an agent:
1. transacts any business within the state or contracts anywhere to supply goods or services in the state; or
2. commits a tortious act within the state, except as to a cause of action for defamation of character arising from the act; or
3. commits a tortious act without the state causing injury to person or property within the state, except as to a cause of action for defamation of character arising from the act, if he
(i) regularly does or solicits business, or engages in any other persistent course of conduct, or derives substantial revenue from goods used or consumed or services rendered, in the state, or
(ii) expects or should reasonably expect the act to have consequences in the state and derives substantial revenue from interstate or international commerce; or
4. owns, uses or possesses any real property situated within the state.
35
New York’s Appellate Division, First Department, 9 has reflected on the reasons for the defamation exception.
[T]he Advisory Committee intended to avoid unnecessary inhibitions on freedom of speech or the press. These important civil liberties are entitled to special protections lest procedural burdens shackle them. It did not wish New York to force newspapers published in other states to defend themselves in states where they had no substantial interests, as the New York Times was forced to do in Alabama.
Legros v. Irving, 38 A.D.2d 53, 55, 327 N.Y.S.2d 371, 373 (1st Dep’t 1971) (referring to N.Y. Times Co. v. Sullivan, 376 U.S. 254, 84 S.Ct. 710, 11 L.Ed.2d 686 (1964), which reversed a large Alabama libel judgment against the New York Times based on a pro civil-rights advertisement that it published where jurisdiction was based on limited daily circulation of the New York Times within Alabama).
In light of these intentions, one might think that the New York State legislature meant for
no
provision of the long-arm statute to grant jurisdiction over an out-of-state defendant with respect to a cause of action for defamation.
See Vardinoyannis v. Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc.,
89 Civ. 2475, 1990 WL 124338, at *6 n. 3, 1990 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 10881, at *9 n. 3 (S.D.N.Y. Aug.20, 1990) (Leval, J.) (“Because
Legros
itself relied on
There is a clear distinction between a situation where the only act which occurred in New York was the mere utterance of the libelous material and on the other hand, a situation where purposeful business transactions have taken place in New York giving rise to the cause of action. Where purposeful transactions of business have taken place in New York, it may not be said that subjecting the defendant to this State’s jurisdiction is an “unnecessary inhibition on freedom of speech or the press.”
Legros, 38 A.D.2d at 55-56, 327 N.Y.S.2d at 373. Because “virtually all the work attendant upon publication of the book [containing the alleged libel] occurred in New York,” jurisdiction over the defendant under subsection (1) was proper. Id. at 56, 327 N.Y.S.2d at 373.
D. Defamation Cases under
New York courts evaluating specific jurisdiction under
1. Transacting Business
With respect to the first part of the test for jurisdiction under
It may be that the meaning of “transacting] business” for the purposes of
New York courts do not interpret “transacting] business” to include mere defamatory utterances sent into the state. Although
Consistent with this analysis, in cases where the plaintiff has brought a defamation action based on letters the defendant sent into New York from outside the state, New York courts have concluded that the act of sending the letters into the state does not alone amount to a transaction of business within the state under
To be sure, New York courts have found jurisdiction in cases where the defendants’ out-of-state conduct involved defamatory statements projected into New York and targeting New Yorkers, but only where the conduct also included something more. In
Sovik v. Healing Network,
244 A.D.2d 985, 665 N.Y.S.2d 997 (4th Dep’t 1997), for example, the Appellate Division, Fourth Department, concluded that one allegedly defamatory letter sent by the defendants could provide a basis for jurisdiction where the defendants had “drafted the letter and either distributed or authorized the distribution of the letter in the Buffalo area,” thereby demonstrating the defendants’ “active involvement and personal control [in New York] over the writing and distribution of the allegedly defamatory statement.”
Id.
at 987, 665 N.Y.S.2d at 999 (affirming district court’s decision that plaintiffs were entitled to jurisdictional discovery);
cf. Legros,
38 A.D.2d at 55-56, 327 N.Y.S.2d at 373 (concluding that the publication of an allegedly defamatory book for which “virtually all the work attendant upon publication” had occurred in New York, including the research for it and the negotiations and execution of the contract with the publisher, constituted “transactions of business” for the purposes of
2. “Arising from” a Transaction of Business
If the defendant is transacting business in New York, the second half of the
Under the “arises from” prong, New York courts have also concluded that they
E.
While no New York appellate court has yet explicitly analyzed a case of website defamation under the “transact[ing] business” provision of
F. Internet Defamation, and Analysis under Zippo Manufacturing Company
In analyzing personal jurisdiction in the internet context, many courts have turned to the standards set out more than ten years ago by a judge of the Western District of Pennsylvania in
Zippo Manufacturing Company v. Zippo Dot Com, Inc.,
952 F.Supp. 1119 (W.D.Pa.1997)
(cited by, e.g., Toys “R” Us, Inc. v. Step Two, S.A.,
318 F.3d 446, 452 (3d Cir.2003) (calling
Zippo
the “seminal authority regarding personal jurisdiction based upon the operation of an Internet web site”);
ALS Scan, Inc. v. Digital Serv. Consultants, Inc.,
293 F.3d 707, 713-14 (4th Cir.2002) (adopting the
Zippo
model);
Cybersell, Inc. v. Cybersell, Inc.,
130 F.3d 414, 418 (9th Cir.1997);
Citigroup Inc. v. City Holding Co.,
97 F.Supp.2d 549, 565 (S.D.N.Y.2000)). We think that the opinion therefore warrants separate mention here. In
Zippo,
the court applied traditional due process “minimum contacts” principles to determine whether jurisdiction over the out-of-state website proprietor was constitutionally permissible.
Zippo,
952 F.Supp. at 1122 (citing Pennsylvania’s long-arm statute,
At one end of the spectrum are situations where a defendant clearly does business over the Internet. If the defendant enters into contracts with residents of a foreign jurisdiction that involve the knowing and repeated transmission of computer files over the Internet, personal jurisdiction is proper. At the opposite end are situations where a defendant has simply posted information on an Internet Web site which is accessible to users in foreign jurisdictions. A passive Web site that does little more than make information available to those who are interested in it is not grounds for the exercise [of] personal jurisdiction. The middle ground is occupied by interactive Web sites where a user can exchange information with the host computer. In these cases, the exercise of jurisdiction is determined by examining the level of interactivity and commercial nature of the exchange of information that occurs on the Web site.
Id. at 1124 (citations omitted). 12
Several federal district courts in New York have applied the
Zippo
formulation
While analyzing a defendant’s conduct under the
Zippo
sliding scale of interactivity may help frame the jurisdictional inquiry in some cases, as the district court here pointed out, “it does not amount to a separate framework for analyzing internet-based jurisdiction.”
Best Van Lines,
2004 WL 964009, at *3, 2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 7830, at *9. Instead, “traditional statutory and constitutional principles remain the touchstone of the inquiry.”
Id.
As the
Zippo
court itself noted, personal jurisdiction analysis applies traditional principles to new situations.
Zippo,
952 F.Supp. at 1123 (“[A]s technological progress has increased the flow of commerce between States, the need for jurisdiction has undergone a similar increase.” (quoting
Hanson,
357 U.S. at 250-51, 78 S.Ct. 1228) (internal quotation marks omitted)). We think that a website’s interactivity may be useful for analyzing personal jurisdiction under
To decide this appeal, then, we must determine whether the conduct out of which BVL’s claim arose was a “transaction of] business” under
A The “Black List Report”
BVL first asserts that Walker’s inclusion of a report on BVL in his “Black List Report” contained false and defamatory statements about BVL. Compl. ¶ 7. As we have seen, New York case law establishes that making defamatory statements outside of New York about New York residents does not, without more, provide a basis for jurisdiction, even when those statements are published in media accessible to New York readers. Walker’s “Black List Report” seems to be exactly that — allegedly defamatory statements posted on a website accessible to readers in New York. As with the column in Rea-luyo, Walker’s listing of BVL on his Black List arises “solely from the aspect of the website from which anyone — in New York or throughout the world — could view and download the allegedly defamatory article.” Realuyo, 2003 WL 21537754, at *7,-2003 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 11529, at *21; see also McBee v. Delica Co., Ltd,., 417 F.3d 107, 124 (1st Cir.2005) (“[T]he mere existence of a website that is visible in a forum and that gives information about a company and its products is not enough, by itself, to subject a defendant to personal jurisdiction in that forum.”); Jennings v. AC Hydraulic A/S, 383 F.3d 546, 549-50 (7th Cir.2004) (similar); ALS Scan, Inc. v. Digital Serv. Consultants, Inc., 293 F.3d 707, 713-15 (4th Cir.2002) (similar); Competitive Techs., Inc. v. Pross, 14 Misc.3d 1224(A), 2007 WL 283075, at *3, 2007 N.Y. Misc. LEXIS 217, at *9 (Sup.Ct. Suffolk County, Jan. 26, 2007) (“[I]n order to exercise personal jurisdiction over a non-resident defendant, something more than the mere posting of information on a passive web site is required to indicate that the defendant purposefully directed his activities at the forum state.” (citation omitted)).
Moreover, the nature of Walker’s comments does not suggest that they were purposefully directed to New Yorkers rather than a nationwide audience. Material on the Website discusses interstate moving companies located in many states for the putative benefit of potential persons in many states who will undergo household moves. Compl. ¶ 2. Walker’s comments therefore do not establish that, for purposes of
We conclude that posting the “Black List Report” did not constitute “transact[ing] business” under
B. Walker’s Answer to a User’s Question
We reach the same conclusion with respect to Walker’s allegedly defamatory statement about BVL posted as a response to a user’s question. We fail to perceive why the fact that a statement was or was not in response to a question from someone somewhere else would, alone, make a difference. Prompted or otherwise, New York courts require more than “the mere utterance of the libelous material,”
Legros,
38 A.D.2d at 55, 327 N.Y.S.2d 371, to constitute “transacting] business” under
C. Website Donations
The final factual basis asserted by BVL for jurisdiction over Walker here is the portion of the Website through which Walker accepts donations. This feature is the most “interactive” on the Website, which may place it at the “clearly do[ing] business” end of the
Zippo
spectrum.
Zippo,
952 F.Supp. at 1124. And particularly if one were to use the
Zippo
framework, it might constitute doing business in New York. But here, even if that were enough to render it “transaetfing] any business within the state” under
BVL asserts that the Website’s “primary function and business is to publish negative information about companies, including a 20 percent New York base, and the Website’s visitors make donations solely because of the overwhelming negative comments and content on the website.” Appellant’s Br. in Response to Br. by Ami-cus Curiae at 22-23 (emphasis omitted). But this nexus — between allegedly tortious conduct and the revenue transactions required to support such conduct — is so attenuated, the relationship between the quest for funds and the lawsuit for which jurisdiction is sought so insubstantial, that the nexus or relationship cannot alone be a sufficient basis upon which to establish
IV. Due Process Analysis
As we have noted, New York law has relied significantly on due process cases in developing its jurisprudence under its long-arm statute. We have therefore discussed them here. But we do so only as a means of understanding New York State long-arm jurisdiction. Nothing in this opinion is intended, or should be read, to indicate our view as to whether jurisdiction in this case would have passed Fourteenth Amendment muster. Neither should anything we have said be interpreted to indicate our position with respect to due process principles recently developed in the internet context by other circuits in decisions such as Revell v. Lidov, 317 F.3d 467 (5th Cir.2002), and Young v. New Haven Advocate, 315 F.3d 256 (4th Cir.2002).
V. Jurisdictional Discovery
BVL argues that it is entitled to jurisdictional discovery on the issue of personal jurisdiction. We review for abuse of discretion the district court’s decision not to permit jurisdictional discovery because BVL failed to establish a prima facie case of personal jurisdiction. First City, Texas-Houston, N.A. v. Rafidain Bank, 150 F.3d 172, 175 (2d Cir.1998). We conclude that the district court acted well within its discretion in declining to permit discovery because the plaintiff had not made out a prima facie case for jurisdiction. See Jazini v. Nissan Motor Co., 148 F.3d 181, 186 (2d Cir.1998) (finding that the district court did not err in denying jurisdictional discovery where the plaintiffs did not establish a prima facie case that the district court had jurisdiction over the defendant); Lehigh Valley Indus, v. Birenbaum, 527 F.2d 87, 93-94 (2d Cir.1975) (similar). We therefore affirm the district court’s decision declining to order jurisdictional discovery.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, we affirm the judgment of the district court.
Notes
. In response to the query, Walker wrote, “If you are talking about Best Van Lines of Brooklyn, NY, then DO NOT USE THEM! They have only had their DOT license since February, 2003 and have NO interstate authority whatsoever with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administrator. They also have not provided the FMCSA with proof of any Cargo Insurance, and they have a vehicle Out of Service record of 40% and a driver Out of Service record of 100% (national averages are 22.9% and 7.21%, respectively).” Compl. ¶ 11.
. Because we think that we can determine this issue based on well-settled principles of New York law, we have decided not to certify it to the New York Court of Appeals.
See Sole Resort,
450 F.3d at 104 (deciding a question of how to interpret
. Applying this principle, the Court has held that the Due Process Clause forbids the exercise of personal jurisdiction over an out-of-state automobile distributor whose only tie to the forum resulted from a customer‘s decision to drive there, World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson [, 444 U.S. 286, 100 S.Ct. 559, 62 L.Ed.2d 490 (1980) ]; over a divorced husband sued for child-support payments whose only affiliation with the forum was created by his former spouse’s decision to settle there, Kulko v. California Superior Court, 436 U.S. 84 [98 S.Ct. 1690, 56 L.Ed.2d 132] (1978); and over a trustee whose only connection with the forum resulted from the settlor’s decision to exercise her power of appointment there, Hanson v. Denckla, 357 U.S. 235 [78 S.Ct. 1228, 2 L.Ed.2d 1283] (1958). In such instances, the defendant has had no “clear notice that it is subject to suit” in the forum and thus no opportunity to “alleviate the risk of burdensome litigation” there. World-Wide Volkswagen Corp. v. Woodson, [444 U.S.] at 297 [100 S.Ct. 559].
Burger King, 471 U.S. at 475 n. 17, 105 S.Ct. 2174.
. The popular name of these statutes seems likely to have roots in the expression “the long arm of the law.” See, e.g., Charles Dickens, The Old Curiosity Shop, Ch. 73 (1841) (“CT]he failure of a spirited enterprise in the way of their profession ... caused their career to receive a sudden check from the long and strong arm of the law.“); see also Michael Quinion, World Wide Words, http:// www.worldwidewords.org/qa/qa-lonl.htm (last visited June 25, 2007) (tracing the expression back to The Old Curiosity Shop).
.
See, e.g.,
Cal.Civ.Proc.Code § 410.10; 14 M.R.S. § 704-A (Maine);
Good Hope Indus., Inc. v. Ryder Scott Co.,
378 Mass. 1, 6, 389 N.E.2d 76, 79 (1979) (interpreting Massachusetts law); N.J. Ct. R. 4:4-4;
Ricker v. Fraza/Forklifts of Detroit,
160 Ohio App.3d 634, 640, 828 N.E.2d 205, 210 (Ohio Ct.App.2005) (interpreting Ohio law);
. “Defamation” includes the torts of libel (usually written) and slander (usually oral). See, e.g., Marcone v. Penthouse Int’l Magazine for Men, 754 F.2d 1072, 1080 n. 1 (3d Cir.1985); Belli v. Orlando Daily Newspapers, Inc., 389 F.2d 579, 586 (5th Cir.1967); Varian Med. Sys., Inc. v. Delfino, 113 Cal.App.4th 273, 293-95, 6 Cal.Rptr.3d 325, 340-43 (6th Dist.2003), rev’d on other grounds, 35 Cal.4th 180, 25 Cal.Rptr.3d 298, 106 P.3d 958 (2005).
. There are other possible “gaps” between the extent of jurisdiction allowed by the New York statute and that permitted by due process.
See, e.g., Banco Ambrosiano, S.p.A. v. Artoc Bank & Trust, Ltd.,
62 N.Y.2d 65, 71-72, 464 N.E.2d 432, 435, 476 N.Y.S.2d 64, 67 (1984) (discussing quasi-in-rem jurisdiction, and noting that “C.P.L.R. [§ ] 302 does not provide for in personam jurisdiction in every case in which due process would permit it,” so that “a ‘gap’ exists in which the necessary minimum contacts, including the presence of defendant‘s property within the State, are present, but personal jurisdiction is not authorized by C.P.L.R. [§ ] 302”).
.“We are bound, as was the district court, to apply [New York] law as interpreted by New York‘s intermediate appellate courts ... unless we find persuasive evidence that the New York Court of Appeals, which has not ruled on [an] issue, would reach a different conclusion.” Pahuta v. Massey-Ferguson, Inc., 170 F.3d 125, 134 (2d Cir.1999) (citations omitted).
.
engaging in active bidding on an open phone line from California, Parke-Bernet[ Galleries v. Franklyn, 26 N.Y.2d 13, 19, 308 N.Y.S.2d 337, 342, 256 N.E.2d 506, 509 (1970) ]; the conducting of proceedings and disciplinary hearings on membership by a private organization, Garofano v. U.S. Trotting Assoc., 78 Misc.2d 33, 355 N.Y.S.2d 702, 705-06 (Sup.Ct.1974); the execution of a separation agreement, Kochenthal v. Kochenthal, 28 A.D.2d 117, 282 N.Y.S.2d 36, 38 (N.Y.App.Div. 1967); the making of a retainer for legal services, Elman v. Belson, 32 A.D.2d 422, 302 N.Y.S.2d 961, 964-65 ([N.Y.App.Div.] 1969); the entry into New York by non-domiciliary defendants to attend a meeting, Parker v. Rog-erson, 33 A.D.2d 284, 307 N.Y.S.2d 986, 994-95 (N.Y.App.Div. 1970), appeal dismissed, 26 N.Y.2d 964, 311 N.Y.S.2d 7, 259 N.E.2d 479 (1970); and the conducting of audits, U.S. Steel Corp. v. Multistate Tax Comm’n, 367 F.Supp. 107, 121 (S.D.N.Y. 1973).
Padilla, 352 F.3d at 709 n. 19.
. Our interpretation of
. Ultimately, the Zippo court did not itself rely on this approach to evaluate the defendant‘s contacts with Pennsylvania. The defendant had sold passwords to its news- services website to 3,000 Pennsylvania subscribers and had contracted with seven Internet access providers in Pennsylvania. Id. at 1126. The court found that such “conduct[ ] of electronic commerce with Pennsylvania residents constitutes the purposeful availment of doing business in Pennsylvania.” Id. at 1125-26.
. The spectrum may also be helpful in analyzing whether jurisdiction is permissible under due process principles. We note that the court in Zippo and most, if not all, of the courts that subsequently adopted the Zippo sliding scale were evaluating whether jurisdiction in those cases comported with due process, under state long-arm statutes that recognized jurisdiction coterminous with the extent allowed by. the federal Constitution. See, e.g., Young, 315 F.3d at 261. We express no view as to the Zippo sliding scale in New York in evaluating whether the exercise of jurisdiction would be consistent with due process.
. We express no view, of course, as to whether the Black List postings might have satisfied the minimum contacts requirement under the constitutional “effects test” employed in
Colder,
465 U.S. at 789-90, 104 S.Ct. 1482, or the analysis in
Keeton,
465 U.S. at 773-74, 781, 104 S.Ct. 1473, based on the defendant’s magazine’s in-state monthly circulation and the defendant‘s accompanying continuous and deliberate exploitation of the in-state market. We think it worth noting nonetheless that the
Keeton
analysis is roughly similar to the inquiry under