DuBay v. KingDuBay v. King
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Branch, Newsom
BRANCH, Circuit Judge:
In this copyright infringement action, Benjamin DuBay appeals the district court’s grant of summary judgment to Stephen King, Media Rights Capital, Imagine Entertainment, Sony Pictures Entertainment, Marvel Entertainment, and Simon & Schuster (collectively, “King“). DuBay owns the copyright for a comic book series called The Rook, which recounted the adventures of Restin Dane. King is the author of The Dark Tower novel series, which features the character Roland Deschain as its protagonist. DuBay sued King for copyright infringement, alleging that Roland Deschain is a copy of Restin Dane. DuBay also sued the other defendants for contributory and vicarious copyright infringement for their respective roles in publishing King’s novel series and adapting the book series into graphic novels and a motion picture. After careful consideration and with the benefit of oral argument, we affirm.
I. BACKGROUND
Because the parties are familiar with the facts of this case, we recount only those facts that are necessary to the disposition of this appeal.
As the evidence presented in the underlying proceeding established, Restin Dane is a wealthy scientist/inventor who lives in Arizona in a house shaped like a rook chess piece, which is known both as “Rook Castle” and “Rook Manor.” Dane is a time traveler. He invents his own time machines (two resemble rook chess pieces) and “will go anywhere—any time—in search of adventure!” During his time-traveling adventures, Dane battles a variety of villains. Dane shares numerous attributes with other traditional heroes from comic books. He is handsome, masculine, courageous, and honorable. Dane is selfless and can always be counted on to “do the right thing.” Dane does not engage in much introspection; his character arc remains constant throughout The Rook series. In short, Dane is a traditional comic book hero.
Stephen King is one of the best-known authors of the last half-century. Although King has written more than 50 works of fiction, this case involves what he describes as his “magnum opus“—The Dark Tower series. The Dark Tower is
Throughout The Dark Tower series, Roland Deschain pursues an elusive structure called the Dark Tower—the linchpin of the space/time continuum—and a sorcerer called The Man in Black who serves The Crimson King.
Deschain is a complex character. He is courageous and skilled with a gun, yet he lacks the idealism and morality of the traditional hero. Deschain is a loner who does not value the lives of others and is, thus, willing to sacrifice those who get in his way. Sometimes he appears heartless and uncompassionate; other times he displays an emotional and romantic side that allows him to engage in introspection and—ultimately—change his behavior. Deschain’s character arc throughout The Dark Tower series is marked by his search for self-knowledge and redemption. Thus, Deschain’s journey is not only external—chasing the Dark Tower and its sorcerer—but also internal. Deschain’s personal journey is difficult.
Approximately 35 years after the first publication of The Gunslinger, Benjamin DuBay—the nephew of William DuBay1—sued King for copyright infringement. DuBay brought one count of copyright infringement against all defendants; one count of contributory copyright infringement against Media Rights Capital and Imagine Entertainment; and one count of vicarious copyright infringement against King, Sony Pictures Entertainment, Marvel Entertainment, and Simon & Schuster. DuBay alleged that the similarities between Deschain and Dane were so “shocking and extraordinary” that King must have copied DuBay’s artistic expression.
During discovery, DuBay moved to compel the production of King’s private journals from January to May 1977. King objected and argued that the journals were irrelevant, such production would invade his privacy, and that the request for the journals was overbroad. After conducting an in camera review of the relevant
King eventually moved for summary judgment. He submitted a copy of the first novel, The Gunslinger; The Dark Tower motion picture; and excerpts from The Dark Tower graphic novels. Given the volume of the works at issue (totaling approximately 4,200 pages), King supported his motion with an expert report written by Michael Gale, which analyzed the issue of substantial similarity.2 King also engaged Robin Furth to write character and plot summaries and analyze quotations from the works at issue.3
In his opposition to the motion for summary judgment, DuBay did not enter any additional works into the record. DuBay argued that King had access to The Rook and that the characters were substantially similar because they shared similar literary and visual elements. DuBay also argued that the “overall look and feel” of the characters was substantially similar.
DuBay then moved for relief from judgment under
II. DISCUSSION
DuBay raises two issues on appeal. First, DuBay contends that the district court abused its discretion by failing to exclude Furth’s character and plot summaries and Gale’s expert report. Second, he contends that the district court erred when it found that the characters were not substantially similar.4 We address each issue in turn.
A. Expert Evidence5
First, DuBay contends that the district court abused its discretion by failing to apply the Daubert standard to the evidence provided by Furth and Gale. See
Expert testimony is admissible if: (1) “the expert’s scientific, technical, or other specialized knowledge will help the trier of fact to understand the evidence or to determine a fact in issue;” (2) “the testimony is based on sufficient facts or data;” (3) “the testimony is the product of reliable principles and methods;” and (4) “the expert has reliably applied the principles and methods to the facts of the case.”
The Federal Rules of Evidence separately permit a party to introduce “a summary, chart, or calculation to prove the content of voluminous writings, recordings, or photographs that cannot be conveniently examined in court.”
In its summary judgment decision, the district court addressed Dubay’s objections to the evidence submitted by Furth and Gale. As to Furth’s summaries, the district court noted that the summaries were admissible under Rule 1006 given the sheer volume of the works at issue. Furthermore, the district court did not limit its review to the summaries, stating that it would “compare the characters for the purpose of the substantial similarity analysis using Furth’s summaries[;] Eerie, volumes 82–85, 87–88 in their entirety[;] and the other materials lodged with the court.” As to Gale’s expert report, the district court emphasized that it “[was] not left to rely on expert opinion alone to determine whether the protected expressions
As an initial matter, DuBay misapprehends the purposes of Daubert and Rule 1006. Daubert requires the district court “to act as a gatekeeper to insure that speculative and unreliable [expert] opinions do not reach the jury.” McClain v. Metabolife Int’l, Inc., 401 F.3d 1233, 1237 (11th Cir. 2005). Similarly, “Rule 1006 allows the district court to admit . . . summaries as evidence [when], in the court’s discretion, it would be inconvenient or unnecessarily time-consuming to [present all the evidence to] the jury.” Francis, 131 F.3d at 1457. The purpose of both rules is to assist the ultimate fact finder. Here, however, the district court personally examined the works at issue that the parties submitted and determined that the case could not proceed to a jury because King was entitled to summary judgment. And because the case would not reach trial, there was no need for the district court to exercise its gatekeeping function.
In any event, DuBay’s arguments are meritless. DuBay argues that Furth’s summaries were unreliable and irrelevant and thus inadmissible under Rule 702 and Daubert. But Furth’s summaries were independently admissible under Rule 1006. See WWP, Inc. v. Wounded Warriors Family Support, Inc., 628 F.3d 1032, 1039–40 & n.7 (8th Cir. 2011) (explaining that evidence was admissible either as
DuBay’s attempt to undermine Gale’s expert report is similarly unpersuasive. DuBay maintains that Gale’s expert report was not admissible under Daubert and Rule 702 because Gale conceded the unreliability of his own report. However, Gale made no such concession. DuBay’s counsel asked Gale a hypothetical question: “If Roland Deschain is a time traveler in the traditional sense, then wouldn’t that undermine the entire basis of your opinion?” Gale never entertained the hypothetical and repeatedly insisted that Deschain was “not a
B. Substantial Similarity7
Next, DuBay argues that the district court erred when it granted summary judgment to King because a reasonable jury could conclude that the characters of Dane and Deschain are substantially similar. As DuBay sees it, the characters are substantially similar because they (1) have similar names, (2) interact with towers that are integral to time travel, (3) have bird companions, (4) are marked by knightly characteristics, (5) travel back in time to save a young boy who becomes a gunslinger, (6) wear Western garb, (7) survive a fictionalized Alamo, and (8) use
The Copyright Act protects “original works of authorship fixed in any tangible medium of expression, now known or later developed, from which they can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either directly or with the aid of a machine or device.”
To establish a copyright infringement claim, a plaintiff must show two elements: “(1) ownership of a valid copyright, and (2) copying of constituent elements of the work that are original.” Feist Publ’ns, 499 U.S. at 361. When, as is the case here, there is no “direct evidence” of copyright infringement, a plaintiff must prove that: (1) “the defendant had access to the plaintiff’s work[,]” and
Like the district court, we assume that DuBay has proved that King had access to The Rook, and we will focus our analysis on substantial similarity.8 Substantial similarity exists when “an average lay observer would recognize the alleged copy as having been appropriated from the copyrighted work.” Oravec v. Sunny Isles Luxury Ventures, L.C., 527 F.3d 1218, 1224 (11th Cir. 2008) (quotation omitted). But because a work may contain uncopyrightable elements, our task is to “determine[] both whether the similarities between the works are substantial from the point of view of the lay observer and whether those similarities involve copyrightable material.” Id. (quotation omitted) (alteration adopted).
We begin by narrowing down the alleged similarities to elements that are protected by copyright. First, we agree with the district court that character names do not merit copyright protection. CMM Cable Rep, Inc. v. Ocean Coast Prop., Inc., 97 F.3d 1504, 1519 (1st Cir. 1996) (explaining that mere words and short
Second, we agree with the district court that there are certain similarities at issue in this appeal that lack originality. Even assuming that the characters share some similarities concerning their knightly heritage, travel to different times and parallel worlds, Western attire, fictionalized Alamo histories, and knife-wielding, these similarities are scènes à faire that are too general to merit copyright protection. See Peter Letterese, 533 F.3d at 1302; Zalewski v. Cicero Builder Dev., Inc., 754 F.3d 95, 102 (2d Cir. 2014) (“[T]he doctrine of ’scènes-à-faire’ teaches that elements of a work that are ‘indispensable, or at least standard, in the treatment of a given topic‘—like cowboys, bank robbers, and shootouts in stories of the American West—get no protection.” (quotation omitted)).
Finally, we turn to what remains: the alleged similarities between the characters’ relationship to towers and tower imagery, the presence of bird companions, and the fact that both characters save a young boy from a different time. Although these elements are similar in the abstract, they are not substantially similar because the elements are portrayed in different ways. To begin, the towers serve very different functions for each character. Dane resides in a house that resembles a rook chess piece and builds time machines with a similar appearance.
Next, the characters interact with bird companions and imagery in different ways. Dane is associated with bird symbolism because he wears a belt buckle with the image of a rook bird and, on at least one occasion, puts on a pair of rook wings and flies into battle alongside a rook bird. Deschain, on the other hand, encounters a talking crow and briefly allies with a fighting hawk before sacrificing the hawk to serve his own ends. Unlike Dane, who only associates with bird allies, Deschain symbolically becomes the hawk upon its demise.
Finally, the characters’ interactions with young male companions are dramatically different. Dane travels back in time to the Battle of the Alamo and, by chance, saves the life of a young boy who turns out to be Dane’s great-great-grandfather. Deschain also saves and bonds with a young boy, but Deschain later betrays and sacrifices the boy for the sake of his quest. Even if these elements bear some similarity, the portrayals of these elements are distinguishable. Given these distinctive presentations, “no reasonable jury upon proper instruction would find that the two works are substantially similar.” Beal, 20 F.3d at 459.
In addition to asking us to analyze substantial similarity by comparing each element side by side, DuBay urges us to consider whether the characters’
We have recognized the pitfalls of scrutinizing each alleged similarity in isolation. See Beal, 20 F.3d at 460 (“The district court correctly noted that . . . lists [of similarities] are inherently subjective and unreliable, particularly where the list contains random similarities. Many such similarities could be found in very dissimilar works.” (citation and quotation marks omitted)); Leigh v. Warner Bros., 212 F.3d 1210, 1215 (11th Cir. 2000) (“This circuit has noted . . . that lists of similarities between works are inherently subjective and unreliable.“). But by asking us to take a broader view of the characters, DuBay hurts rather than helps his case because this more holistic analysis further highlights the distinctiveness of each character.
Dane possesses many attributes of a traditional comic book hero. He is a courageous gunslinger and an honorable man. He always does the “right thing.” He travels through time and fights a variety of villains. And Dane’s character arc remains constant throughout The Rook series. Deschain, however, is far more complex. He is courageous and skilled with a gun yet lacks the idealism and morality integrity of a traditional hero. He uses and sacrifices others out of self-interest. And Deschain is on an external quest for the Dark Tower and The Man in
For these reasons, and those explained in the district court’s thorough opinion, “no reasonable jury upon proper instruction would find that the two works are substantially similar.” Beal, 20 F.3d at 459. Accordingly, the district court did not err by granting King’s motion for summary judgment.9
III. CONCLUSION
For the reasons explained, we affirm the district court in full.
AFFIRMED.