Beacham v. GurneyBeacham v. Gurney
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Kinne
I. This is an action for judgment on two promissory notes executed by the defendant Grurney, and for the foreclosure of two mortgages securing them, on lands in Adams county, Iowa. Defendant James L. Lombard claims to be the owner of said land’ by virtue of two tax deeds executed to him by the treasurer of Adams county on September -30, 1889, and recorded October 4, 1889. Defendant appellees, Waterman and others, in their answer and cross-bill, claim to be the owners of certain judgments aggregating about five hundred dollars, and which were rendered on or between October 18, 1886, and March *6233, 1888, being subsequent to the date of plaintiff’s mortgages and the tax sale, and prior to the execution of the treasurer’s deeds on said sales, and claim that, as against Lombard, their judgments are first liens, because Lombard’s acquisition of the tax title was in fact a redemption from the tax sales, and claim, as against Beacham, that their judgments are-first liens upon the land, because his mortgage lien had been lost by reason of his or his assignees having taken title to the land under an agreement to discharge and release the mortgage debt. Appellees ask to have their judgments decreed a first lien upon the land, that the mortgages be decreed paid, that the transaction between Lombard and the holders of the tax certificates be decreed a payment of taxes or redemption, and that appellees be permitted to redeem. Lombard denied the material parts of the cross bill, and plaintiff denied all of the allegations of defendant appellees’ answer. By agreement, Lombard and others, trustees were substituted as plaintiffs. Defendants G-urney, James L. Lombard, and the Alliance Trust Company were defaulted for want of answer to the petition. The court entered a decree dismissing plaintiff’s petition, and in favor of defendant appellees, and permitting them to redeem.
*625
As the result we have reached is favorable to appellees, we need not pass upon the question made in their motion to dismiss. The decree of the district court is not only in harmony with the views we have expressed, but also effectuates justice between the parties. Affirmed.