Batick v. SeymourBatick v. Seymour
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Shea
The plaintiff has appealed from a judgment rendered for the defendant in accordance with a jury verdict upon the first count of his complaint, which sounded in nuisance, and from the decision of the court granting summary judgment for the defendants on the second count, which alleged a fraudulent conveyance. 1
Viewing the evidence most favorably toward sustaining the verdict, the jury may reasonably have found the following facts: The plaintiff was driving north along route 8 in his pick-up truck on the night of May 13, 1972, when he collided with the defendant driver’s vehicle which had also been traveling north on route 8. The plaintiff, who alleged that the defendant’s Karman Grhia was proceeding with no lights on, did not see it in his path until it was too late. Although he turned to the left hoping to avoid a collision, his truck hit the left rear of the defendant’s car and veered to the left side of the highway where it rolled over. The plaintiff sustained severe injuries as a result of the accident and was confined to a wheel chair throughout the trial. The plaintiff had consumed one can of beer and part of another can during the evening of May 13, and a moderate odor of alcohol from him was noticed at thé scene of the accident. The lights of the defendant’s vehicle were working approximately one hour before the accident and the rear marker light was observed by the investigating officer to be lighted when he came to the accident scene.
With respect to the nuisance count, the plaintiff claims error in the court’s failure to excuse three jurors for cause, to limit both defendants to the same number of peremptory challenges allowed to him, to comply with several of his requests to charge, and to admit certain evidence as admissions of the defendant.
Because it is dispositive, we shall first consider the ruling which kept from the jury evidence of the defendant’s post-collision transfer of real property to his wife. In excepting to the exclusion of this evidence the plaintiff claimed that it was admissible to show the defendant’s consciousness of liability. The rule is well established that evidence is admissible that a person after the happening of an accident, or the occurrence of some other event which might render him liable, disposed of his property, on the ground that such evidence tends to show a consciousness of liability and a purpose to evade satisfaction of it. 29 Am. Jur. 2d, Evidence § 274, p. 322; see, e.g.,
Poston
v.
Gaddis,
372 So. 2d 1099, 1102 (Ala. 1.979);
Bush
v.
Jackson,
552 P.2d 509 (Colo. 1976);
Portland Gas Light Co.
v.
Ruud,
242 Mass. 272, 136 N.E. 75 (1922);
Cox
v.
Wright-Hennepin Cooperative Electric Assn.,
281 Minn. 228, 161 N.W.2d 294 (1968).
2
While it is true
“Subsequent conduct may, in many cases, be given in evidence to affect or to show the character of prior acts or intentions.”
Elwell
v.
Russell,
71 Conn. 462, 465, 42 A. 862 (1899). Conduct of a litigant which is plainly reprehensible, such as the intimidation of a witness or flight from the scene of an accident, has commonly been admitted to show consciousness of a doubtful cause.
Gaul
v.
Noiva,
155 Conn. 218, 224, 230 A.2d 591 (1967);
Kotler
v.
Lalley,
112 Conn. 86, 88, 151 A. 433 (1930);
In re Durant,
80 Conn. 140, 151, 67 A. 497 (1907). In
Banach
v.
Bohinski,
107 Conn. 156, 139 A. 688 (1927), a negligence action, error was claimed in the exclusion of a deed by which the defendant had transferred property to his wife after the accident had occurred in which the plaintiff was injured. This court acknowledged the rule allowing such evidence of consciousness of liability, but held that the court had not abused its discretion because the conveyance was not made until nine months after the accident. “In the few civil cases in which such conveyances have been admitted for this purpose, the transfer was made at a time in such close proximity to the occurrence upon which the claim of liability was based that, in view of its character and the surrounding circumstances, an inference
The collision in the present case happened on May 13, 1972. On August 4, 1972, the defendant driver, for “love and affection,” conveyed a one-half interest in real estate to his wife. Since less than three months elapsed between the accident and the conveyance in the present case, remoteness does not provide a sustainable ground for exclusion.
In this case the court, in ruling on the defendant’s objection, specifically relied not on the remoteness of the evidence but on its conclusion that the proffered evidence was more prejudicial than probative. That a court has discretion to exclude relevant evidence on this ground is clear. Tait & LaPlante, Handbook of Conn. Evid. § 8.1 (b); see
State
v.
Paoletto,
181 Conn. 172, 186, 434 A.2d 954 (1980);
State
v.
Marquez,
160 Conn. 47, 51-52, 273 A.2d 689 (1970);
Thibodeau
v.
Connecticut Co.,
139 Conn. 9, 14, 89 A.2d 223 (1952); 3 Wigmore, Evidence (3d Ed.) § 792 (2). This discretion, however, has often been invoked and discussed in the context of criminal trials where the stakes are higher and prejudice may have the consequence of confinement.
State
v.
Paoletto,
supra;
State
v.
Marquez,
supra;
State
v.
Holliday,
159 Conn. 169, 173, 268 A.2d 368 (1970). As grounds for excluding the proffered evidence the trial court mentioned that the plaintiff made no claim against the defendant until more than two years after the conveyance and that only a one-half interest in the property had been transferred. Those factors, of course, affected the weight of the evidence but not its admissibility. During the offer of proof heard in the absence of the jury, the defendant testified that he knew at the time of the
Our conclusion of error relates only to the issue of nuisance as alleged in the complaint and would not ordinarily require a reversal of the judgment for the defendant on the first count, because the general verdict of the jury imports that the special defense raised by the defendant was also decided in his favor.
3
No interrogatories having been requested by the parties or presented in accordance with
The plaintiff, however, claims error in the jury instructions upon the special defense because of a reference to it at one point as “contributory negligence” rather than wilful misconduct, a misstatement which he called to the attention of the trial court in excepting to the charge. Contributory negligence is no defense to an absolute nuisance.
Sheeler
v.
Waterbury,
138 Conn. 111, 116, 82 A.2d 359 (1951);
DeLahunta
v.
Waterbury,
134 Conn. 630, 640, 59 A.2d 800 (1948);
Beckwith
v.
Stratford,
The trial court, although recalling “no evidence of intoxication,” nevertheless submitted to the jury the issue of whether the plaintiff had “intentionally caused his intoxication.” Under the unusual cir
Some of the remaining claims of error are likely to arise again at a new trial and we shall discuss them. One such claim is that the defendant wife was not entitled to any peremptory challenges for the selection of the jury at the trial of the first count of the complaint which was directed against only the defendant husband. The court ruled that each
Another issue which may recur is the exclusion of a question claimed to show a tacit admission by the defendant that his lights were not in operation at the time of the accident. The plaintiff in responding to the motion of the defendants for a summary judgment on both counts of the complaint had stated in his counter-affidavit
7
that there were no lights on the car which he struck. The plaintiff sought to inquire of the defendant about his failure to have filed another affidavit denying this assertion. To render such testimony admissible it was essential to establish that the defendant was aware of the statement made by the plaintiff, that he had the opportunity to speak, that the circumstances naturally called for a reply and that he remained silent.
Obermeier
v.
Nielsen,
158 Conn. 8, 12, 255 A.2d 819
The remainder of the plaintiff’s claims involve his numerous requests to charge. The substance of many of them was included in the instructions given to the jury. Some are simply partisan or argumentative phrasings of standard legal principles. Others request simply a charge upon certain statutes without reference to the facts which would make the statute applicable. See
n
The plaintiff claims that his second count, which alleged a fraudulent conveyance, was not suitable for disposition by summary judgment since the issue of the defendant’s intent in transferring his property was genuine, material and not capable of resolution without a trial. See
The plaintiff chose not to file an opposing affidavit, presumably because he had no personal knowledge of the mental state which influenced the defendant to quitclaim a one-half interest in his house to his wife. See
A
We first must consider the effect of the plaintiff’s failure to file an opposing affidavit in the summary judgment proceeding.
B
Our conclusion that the absence of a counter-affidavit from the plaintiff does not under the circumstances of this case justify the granting of a summary judgment does not entirely resolve its propriety. The defendant argues that summary judgment was appropriate since it was designed to dispose of cases involving sham or frivolous issues in a manner which is speedier and less expensive for all concerned than a full trial.
Town Bank & Trust Co.
v.
Benson,
176 Conn. 304, 306-307, 407 A.2d 971 (1978);
United Oil Co.
v.
Urban Redevelopment Commission,
158 Conn. 364, 375-76, 260 A.2d 596 (1969);
Rathkopf
v.
Pearson,
148 Conn. 260, 264, 170 A.2d 135 (1961). There are situations, however, which do not lend themselves to summary disposition. “It is . . . well recognized that summary judgment procedure is particularly inappropriate where the inferences which the parties seek to have
“In passing on the defendant’s motion for summary judgment the trial court was limited to deciding whether an issue of fact existed, but it could not try that issue if it did exist.”
Associates Discount Corporation
v.
Smith’s Lincoln-Mercury Sales, Inc.,
153 Conn. 176, 180, 214 A.2d 909 (1965). The movant must show that it is quite clear what the truth is, and that excludes any real doubt as to the existence of any genuine issue of material fact.
D.H.R. Construction Co.
v.
Donnelly,
180 Conn. 430, 429 A.2d 908 (1980);
Yanow
v.
Teal Industries, Inc.,
178 Conn. 262, 268, 422 A.2d 311 (1979);
Dougherty
v.
Graham,
161 Conn. 248, 250, 287 A.2d 382 (1971). The test is whether a party would be entitled to a directed verdict on the same facts.
United Oil Co.
v.
Urban Redevelopment Commission,
supra, 380. “[A] summary disposition . . . should be on evidence which a jury would not be at liberty to disbelieve and which would require a directed verdict for the moving party.”
Sartor
v.
Arkansas Natural Gas Corporation,
321 U.S. 620, 624, 64 S. Ct. 724, 88 L. Ed. 967 (1944). In the case before us the jurors would not have been compelled to believe the defendant’s declarations that his motivation in executing the deed to his wife was wholly unrelated to any concern about his potential liability to the plaintiff even though no other evidence than that presented in the summary judgment proceeding came before them. “That a fact was testified to and was not directly contradicted by another witness is wholly insufficient.”
Martin
v.
There is error, the judgment upon each count is set aside and the case is remanded to the trial court for a new trial.
In this opinion the other judges, concurred.
Notes
The complaint named the defendant driver Edwin O. Seymour III in the first count and both Seymour and his wife, Patricia, in the second count. Hereinafter our use of the singular defendant will refer to Edwin O. Seymour III.
Kentucky has adopted the minority rule that evidence of a post-occurrence transfer is inadmissible. Givens v. Berkley, 108 Ky. 236, 56 S.W. 158 (1900). Missouri courts have limited the rule, prohibiting a plaintiff’s counsel on examination from asking a defendant simply whether he conveyed property subsequent to the incident. Amsinger v. Najim, 335 Mo. 528, 73 S.W.2d 214 (1934). Counsel may, however, ask the defendant specifically whether he conveyed property in order to avoid the payment of damages he thought he had incurred. Ibid.
The trial court accepted the following verdict: “DEFENDANT’S VERDICT. In this ease the jury finds the issues for the defendant Edwin O. Seymour III, as to liability.”
The defendant pleaded the statute of limitations as a second special defense to claims of negligence or nuisance arising out of negligence. The trial judge, ruling that the plaintiff was limited by his complaint to proof of an absolute nuisance, refused to submit the statute of limitations defense to the jury. See footnote 8, infra.
We construe the latter two claims as alleging only negligent rather than intentional conduct on the part of the plaintiff. The evidence does not support a finding that these acts of the plaintiff were intentional.
The trial court allowed four challenges to the plaintiff and eight to the defendants.
The defendants filed a motion for summary judgment on both counts of the complaint on February 22, 1980, approximately three and one-half months before trial. The plaintiff filed an opposing affidavit and that motion for summary judgment was denied. The defendant also filed a later motion for summary judgment after the verdict on the first count, and this second motion is discussed in part III of the opinion.
The plaintiff’s complaint sounded in nuisance rather than negligence, because service was not made upon the defendant until May 2, 1975; see
Seaboard Burner Corporation
v.
DeLong,
145 Conn. 300, 303, 141 A.2d 642 (1958) ; more than two years after his injuries were sustained and therefore after the statute of limitations on negligence had run. See
The word “shall” was inserted by a 1966 amendment to the former