Barendregt v. Walla Walla School District No. 140Barendregt v. Walla Walla School District No. 140
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Utter
This court granted plaintiff Barendregt’s petition to review a decision of the Court of Appeals affirming a Superior Court judgment upholding the nonrenewal of petitioner’s teacher’s contract with respondent school district. Both courts below concluded that petitioner was not an employee of the district and hence not entitled to the protections of the continuing contract law,
In 1967 the school district entered into a written agreement with the Washington State Penitentiary to provide
On January 30, 1973, the superintendent of the school district notified petitioner by letter that his contract would not be renewed due to the elimination of his position at the penitentiary. Pursuant to the continuing contract law, 1 petitioner requested a hearing before respondent board of directors of the district. The board’s president responded by letter stating “the Board of Education has scheduled a hearing” for February 20. Subsequently, the district notified petitioner that the February 20 hearing would not deal with petitioner’s contract status, but would only consider whether probable cause for nonrenewal existed. At that hearing, the district’s board of directors resolved that such probable cause existed by virtue of the elimination of some penitentiary teaching positions.
Petitioner filed a second civil suit alleging further errors by the respondents. The actions were consolidated and a trial was held in Superior Court without a jury. The court held,
inter alia,
that petitioner was an employee of the Washington State Penitentiary and had no cause of action against respondents in connection with the termination of his employment. The Court of Appeals affirmed, 13 Wn. App. 448, 534 P.2d 1404 (1975), holding that petitioner was not an employee of School District No. 140 because the trial court’s finding that the district had no control over petitioner’s teaching activity was determinative and supported by substantial evidence. The court, therefore, concluded petitioner was not entitled to avail himself of the nonrenewal provisions of
The continuing contract law extends its procedural protections to any “employee” which is defined as a “teacher ... or other certificated employee, holding a position as such with a school district . . .”
We have construed the pertinent language of
We have recognized that “[t]he general relationship . . . between the school authorities and teachers in the public schools of our state is created by contract and governed by general principles of contract law.”
Kirk v. Miller, supra
at 781. Each of the three 1-year contracts under which petitioner was employed stated “It Is Hereby Agreed, by and between the Board of Directors of School District No. 140, Walla Walla County, Washington and Rob
Furthermore, performance by the parties under the contract (see
Stender v. Twin City Foods, Inc.,
82 Wn.2d 250, 254, 510 P.2d 221 (1973);
Henry v. Lind,
76 Wn.2d 199, 204, 455 P.2d 927 (1969)), demonstrates that petitioner was considered by School District No. 140 to be an employee. Petitioner was compensated by the district, was subject to the same withholding provisions as other teachers in the district, and received the same administrative notices as the other teachers. Significantly, respondents also attempted to nonrenew petitioner’s contract as if he were an employee subject to the continuing contract law. In reply to the superintendent’s letter of January 30, petitioner expressly referred to
In recent cases arising under the continuing con
Accordingly, because no sufficient notice of probable cause to nonrenew was given prior to April 15, 1973, as
Judgment reversed.
Stafford, C.J., and Rosellini, Hunter, Hamilton, Wright, Brachtenbach, and Horowitz, JJ., concur.
Notes
“Every board of directors determining that there is probable cause or causes that the employment contract of an employee should not be renewed by the district for the next ensuing term shall notify that employee in writing on or before April 15th preceding the commencement of such term of that determination of the board of directors, which notification shall specify the cause or causes for nonrenewal of contract. Such notice shall be served upon the employee personally, or by certified or registered mail, or by leaving a copy of the notice at the house of his or her usual abode with some person of suitable age and discretion then resident therein. Every such employee so notified, at his or her request made in writing and filed with the chairman or secretary of the board of directors of the district within ten days after receiving such notice, shall be granted opportunity for hearing to determine whether or not the facts constitute sufficient cause or causes for nonrenewal of contract.”