Ball v. Revised Retirement Plan for Salaried Employees of Johns-Manville Corp.Ball v. Revised Retirement Plan for Salaried Employees of Johns-Manville Corp.
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Kane
ORDER
KANE, District Judge.
This is an action arising under the Employee Retirement- Income Security Act (ERISA),
1. The non-alienation provision in ER-ISA,29 U.S.C. § 1056(d)(1) , does not prevent the defendant-pension plan from recognizing alienation and assignment of pension benefits pursuant to domestic relations decrees.
2. The New York law of trusts continues to apply to the plan for limited purposes even after the effective date of ERISA, January 1, 1975.
3. The New York law of domestic relations continues to apply to the plan for limited purposes even after the effective date of ERISA.
4. The domestic relations laws of other states also continue to apply to the plan for limited purposes, even after the effective date of ERISA.
For the reasons stated herein, the motion for partial summary judgment is granted as to the plaintiff’s first request and denied as to his second request. I reach no decision on the third and fourth requests.
The defendants, The Revised Retirement Plan for Salaried Employees of the JohnsManville Corporation and Subsidiaries, hereinafter referred to as “the Plan” or “the Johns-Manville plan,” is an employee benefit plan within the meaning of ERISA,
In 1979, his wife, who was working, filed for divorce in Arapahoe County, Colorado. The plaintiff and his wife signed a settlement agreement under which the plaintiff’s wife was released from any further obligation to support her husband, in exchange for assigning to him, her present and future rights to receive any benefits in the pension plan. The parties contemplated that the plaintiff’s benefits would be raised by 45% to the amount that he would have received under a sole annuity. This settlement agreement was incorporated by reference into a divorce decree issued in August 1977.
Shortly after issuance of the decree, the plaintiff requested the defendant-plan to give full legal effect to the assignment and
*720
to pay him, from the date of divorce, the additional 45% that he should receive under a sole annuity. The Plan refused to recognize the assignment on the ground that ERISA,
Judicial interpretations of ERISA, congressional intent and interpretations of similar statutes all support the plaintiff’s contention. While courts in the tenth circuit have not yet addressed the issue, virtually every other federal court presented with this question has found that assignments pursuant to domestic relations decrees are implied exemptions from ERISA’s pre-emption and rion-alienation provisions. 1 See Operating Engineers Local No. 428 Pension Fund v. Zamborsky, 470 F.Supp. 1174 (D.Ariz.1979), aff’d 650 F.2d 196 (9th Cir. 1981); American Telephone & Telegraph v. Merry, 592 F.2d 118 (2d Cir. 1979); Cody v. Riecker, 454 F.Supp. 22 (E.D.N.Y.1978) aff’d 594 F.2d 314 (2d Cir. 1979); Central States Southeast & Southwest Areas Pension Fund v. Parr, 480 F.Supp. 924 (E.D. Mich.1979); Senco of Florida, Inc. v. Clark, 473 F.Supp. 902 (M.D.Fla.1979); Cartledge v. Miller, 457 F.Supp. 1146 (S.D.N.Y.1979).
These courts reason that the purpose of ERISA’s proscription against assignment and alienation is “to protect a person and those dependent upon him from the claim of creditors, not to insulate a bread winner from the valid support claims of spouse and offspring.” Cartledge v. Miller, supra, at 1156. See American Telephone & Telegraph v. Merry, supra, at 124; Cody v. Riecker, supra, 454 F.Supp. at 25; Operating Engineers Local No. 428 Pension Fund v. Zamborsky, supra, 470 F.Supp. at 1175.
Moreover, both congress and the courts have long recognized that “the whole subject of domestic relations, of husband and wife, parent and child, belongs to the laws of the states, not to the laws of the United States.” Hisquierdo v. Hisquierdo, 439 U.S. 572, 581, 99 S.Ct. 802, 808, 59 L.Ed.2d 1 (1979); Operating Engineers Local No. 428 Pension Fund v. Samborsky, supra, 650 F.2d at 199 citing In Re Burrus, 136 U.S. 586, 593-594, 10 S.Ct. 850, 852-853, 34 L.Ed. 500 (1890). Consequently, the supreme court has held that unless positively required by direct enactment, the courts should not presume a design on the part of congress to relieve the unfortunate debtor from familial support obligations. Wetmore v. Markoe, 196 U.S. 68, 77, 25 S.Ct. 172, 176, 49 L.Ed. 390 (1904). Nothing in the legislative history of ERISA suggests that the proscription against assignment and alienation was intended to include family support payments. 2
Further, judicial interpretations of anti-assignment and exemption clauses in other *721 federal statutes evince an overall congressional purpose not to interfere with the state’s power to enforce family support obligations. See Cartledge v. Miller, supra, at 1155 and cases collected at nn. 45-48 construing these provisions.
Accordingly, I hold that valid domestic relations decrees authorizing the transfer of pension benefits in satisfaction of support obligations are implied exemptions to ERISA
The plaintiff also contends that New York trust law continues to apply to the Johns-Manville plan for limited purposes relating to domestic relations decrees, despite enactment of ERISA. The plaintiff notes that the Johns-Manville plan is a New York trust and under New York trust law, transfers of trust income in satisfaction of support obligations are exempt from spendthrift or non-assignment clauses,
The plaintiff also contends that New York domestic relations laws and the domestic relations laws of other states continues to apply to the Johns-Manville plan, after ERISA’s enactment. I decline to decide these issues since neither the validity of the plaintiff’s divorce decree nor the domestic relations law applied by the state court is in issue. It is hereby
ORDERED that the plaintiff’s motion for partial summary judgment is granted as to the plaintiff’s first request and denied as to his second request. I reach no decision on his third and fourth requests. It is further
ORDERED that this action is returned to Magistrate Sickler so that he can conduct a status conference to limit the issues remaining for adjudication in accordance with the rulings contained herein and bring the case to readiness for trial.
Notes
. The only case to reach a contrary result is General Motors Corp. v. Townsend, 468 F.Supp. 466 (E.D.Mich.1976). However the reasoning and result in Townsend were subsequently rejected by another decision in the same district. See Central States Southeast & Southwest Areas Pension Fund v. Parr, supra.
. In Cartledge v. Miller, supra, at id. n.44, the court analyzed ERISA’s legislative history stating:
“ERISA’s anti-assignment or alienation provisions speak only in general terms. Neither H.R. 2 nor H.R. 4200 contained such provisions. Only in 1974 were they added. Thus the only legislative history is a short paragraph in H.R.Conf.Rep.No. 93-1280, 93d Cong., 2d Sess. (1974), reprinted in [1974] U.S.Code Cong. & Admin.News 5038, 5060.”
. The plaintiff claims that New York cases have held that the New York Estates, Powers and Trusts law “prevailed” over ERISA’s non-alienation provision, citing
Wanamaker v. Wanamaker,
93 Misc.2d 784, 401 N.Y.S.2d 702 (1978);
Cogollos v. Cogollos,
93 Misc.2d 406, 402 N.Y.S.2d 929 (1978);
M. H. v. J. H.,
93 Misc.2d 1016, 403 N.Y.S.2d 411 (1978). However, these New York courts did not reach their decisions on state trust law grounds but rather on the ground that congress did not intend that ERISA