Armstrong v. ObucinoArmstrong v. Obucino
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Cartwright
delivered the opinion of the court:
The question in this case is whether a sale made contrary to the provisions of the statute but in conformity with the directions of the decree under which it was made, and a deed executed in pursuance of such sale and the provisions of the decree, are null and void and therefore subject to collateral attack, or merely irregular and erroneous, to be set aside only in a direct proceeding. The question arose in this way: On November 16, 1918, Clyde D. Armstrong filed in the circuit court of Cook county his bill of complaint, asking the court to declare a mechanic’s lien in his favor on property of Katie Obucino for improvements made thereon under a contract entered into July 26, 1918, and completed September 21, 1918. Katie Obucino was served with process and answered the bill, and a replication having been filed, the issues were referred to a master in chancery. On his report a decree was entered establishing a lien for $511.48, fixing the master’s fees on the reference at $100.30, and providing that in default of payment of the amount of the lien and costs of suit within five days the master in chancery should sell the property. The sale was to be made subject to redemption, and the decree stated in detail the particulars as to sale and rights of redemption according to the statute existing prior to July 1, 1917. The sale was made to Charles E. Guenberg, a stranger to the record, and a certificate of purchase was issued to him. The master reported the sale and it was confirmed by the court. Guenberg assigned the certificate to the appellant, Earle L. Fiske, and there being no redemption he received a master’s deed at the expiration of fifteen months. Possession was refused to Eiske, and on
Where a court of general jurisdiction, having jurisdiction of the parties and the subject matter, enters a decree within the authority granted to it by the law, the decree, however erroneous, cannot be questioned collaterally, and a stranger to the record, such as Charles Guenberg, purchasing at a sale under, such decree, cannot be divested of his title. All that Guenberg was required to do was to look to the question of the jurisdiction of the court rendering the decree, and if the court had jurisdiction to order the sale as made he would be protected, however erroneous the decree. (Guiteau v. Wisely, 47 Ill. 433; Wadhams v. Gay, 73 id. 415; Montanye v. Wallahan, 84 id. 355; Thompson v. Frew, 107 id. 478; Crawford v. Thomson, 161 id. 161; Ure v. Ure, 223 id. 454; Thompson v. Davis, 297 id. 11.) The circuit court having jurisdiction of the class of cases to which this case belonged, acquired jurisdiction of the subject matter by the filing of the bill and obtained jurisdiction of the defendant by service of process and her appearance, and so far as the bill prayed for the establishment of a mechanic’s lien the decree was within the jurisdiction and not subject to collateral attack.
The statement has very frequently been made that where a court has jurisdiction of the parties and the subject matter, its decree, however erroneous, can only be attacked on appeal or error; but the rule is subject to an exception equally well settled,—that a decree may be void because the court has exceeded its jurisdiction. The bill prayed for the enforcement of the lien by a sale beyond and contrary to the powers given by the statute for enforcing mechanics’ liens, and it does
One of the essentials of a valid judgment is that the court have jurisdiction to render that particular judgment. (Russell v. Shurtleff, 28 Colo. 414.) A law authorized the confiscation of the property of confederate officers by a proceeding in court. The confiscation was to be for the life of the officer, and the United States district court having jurisdiction decreed a sale of the property of the confederate officer” Forrest but ordered the full title sold. The sale was made and the heir brought ejectment. It was held the court had no jurisdiction to order the sale beyond the lifetime of the officer and the decree and sale were void to that extent. Bigelow v. Forrest, 9 Wall. 339.
The sale and deed being null and void, the order quashing the writ of assistance and ordering a restoration of the premises to Katie Obucino was correct, and it is affirmed.
Order affirmed.