Anthony Coons, Sr. v. Steven F. CasabellaAnthony Coons, Sr. v. Steven F. Casabella
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Walker
Defendant-appellant Steven F. Casabella appeals from that part of the October 19, 2000 order of the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York (David N. Hurd,
District
Judge) that denied his motion for summary judgment on plaintiff-appellee Anthony Coons, Sr.’s claim, brought pursuant to
BACKGROUND
Although some facts are disputed as will be noted, the undisputed facts are as follows. At about 1:15 A.M. on January 27, 1997, Coons drove his pickup truck off the road and into a telephone pole. Leaving his truck partially on the road, Coons walked to his brother’s house. His brother drove him to the hospital, where his injuries were treated. After Coons was released from the hospital, still in the early morning hours of January 27, he was questioned by Casabella, a New York state trooper. Coons told the officer that he had driven his pickup truck off the road and into a telephone pole, and admitted that prior to the accident he had consumed “three beers, maybe three, three and a half’ and that he had not consumed any alcohol after the accident. Casabella administered several field sobriety tests to Coons in the emergency room waiting area. The parties dispute Coons’s performance on these tests.
After administering the tests, Casabella issued Coons a desk appearance ticket for driving while intoxicated, in violation of
Coons brought this action under
On appeal, Casabella urges reversal of the district court’s denial of summary judgment on the basis of qualified immunity for false arrest. Casabella claims that under New York law and under either the undisputed or plaintiffs version of the facts, he had probable cause to charge Coons with driving under the influence or, at the least, that he had arguable probable cause because reasonably competent police officers could disagree on this point. Because we find that Casabella had arguable probable cause and, moreover, believe that the district court further erred by imposing on Casabella a heightened duty of investigation, we reverse.
DISCUSSION
I. Appellate Jurisdiction
As an initial matter, we are unpersuaded by Coons’s claim that this court lacks jurisdiction. Specifically, Coons claims that the denial of summary judgment is not immediately appealable because the district court found that there were disputed issues of fact. Although Coons is correct that a denial of summary judgment on the basis of qualified immunity may not be immediately appealable where factual issues as opposed to legal issues remain,
Johnson v. Jones,
515 U.S. 304, 313-18, 115 S.Ct. 2151, 132 L.Ed.2d 238 (1995);
Golino v. City of New Haven,
950 F.2d 864, 868 (2d Cir.1991);
Kaminsky v. Rosenblum,
929 F.2d 922, 926 (2d Cir.1991), the fact that the district court has found certain factual issues in dispute does not foreclose the appeal. “Even where the lower court rules that material disputes of fact preclude summary judgment on qualified immunity, we may still exercise interlocutory jurisdiction if the defendant . . . contends that he is entitled to qualified immunity even under plaintiffs version of the facts.”
Tierney v. Davidson,
133 F.3d 189, 194 (2d Cir.1998);
accord Martinez v. Simonetti,
202 F.3d 625, 632 (2d Cir.2000);
Behrens v. Pelletier,
516 U.S. 299, 313, 116 S.Ct. 834, 133 L.Ed.2d 773 (1996)
(“Johnson
permits [a defendant in a
II. Qualified Immunity
We review
de novo
the district court’s denial of summary judgment on the ground of qualified immunity.
Cerrone v. Brown,
246 F.3d 194, 198 (2d Cir.2001). A police officer is entitled to qualified immunity in making arrests where “(1) his conduct does not violate clearly established statutory or constitutional rights of which a reasonable person would have known, or (2) it was ‘objectively reasonable’ for him to believe that his actions were lawful at the time of the challenged act.”
Id.
at 199 (citations and internal quotation marks omitted). Because the right to be free of arrests made without probable cause was clearly established at the time the appearance ticket was issued to Coons,
Martinez,
202 F.3d at 634 (collecting cases), this appeal turns on whether Casabella’s probable
In the instant case, Casabella’s determination that probable cause existed easily meets the objectively-reasonable test. Based on the plaintiffs own version of the facts, at the time Casabella issued the tickets, he knew the following: that Coons had been involved in a single-car accident in which he drove his pickup truck off the road and into a telephone pole in the early morning hours; that Coons had consumed at least three beers that evening; and that Coons had consumed no alcohol after the accident. As Casabella points out, the New York Court of Appeals and several lower state courts have found in similar circumstances that probable cause existed to make an arrest for driving while intoxicated. See, e.g., People v. Ladd, 89 N.Y.2d 893, 653 N.Y.S.2d 259, 675 N.E.2d 1211, 1213 (N.Y.1996) (finding “reasonable grounds” to believe defendant had been driving while intoxicated where a driver had consumed alcohol, had driven across the center lane in fog at a high speed, and had collided head-on with another car); People v. McClaney, 135 A.D.2d 901, 902-08, 521 N.Y.S.2d 894, 895-96 (3d Dep’t 1987) (finding that “the record clearly indicates that defendant’s arrest was based upon probable cause” where he drove his car off the road and into a cornfield and then admitted to the arresting officer that he had been drinking); People v. Hall, 91 A.D.2d 1002, 1002-03, 457 N.Y.S.2d 580, 580-81 (2d Dep’t 1983) (per curiam) (finding that the police had probable cause for arrest where a car was driven off the road and into a tree, the driver smelled of alcohol, and an empty bottle of vodka was found in the car), aff‘d, 61 N.Y.2d 834, 473 N.Y.S.2d 959, 462 N.E.2d 136 (N.Y.1984). Given the circumstances of this case, “a rational jury could not find that the officer‘s] judgment was so flawed that no reasonable officer would have made a similar choice.” Lennon, 66 F.3d at 424-25 (emphasis in original). Thus it was error for the district court to deny Casabella’s motion for summary judgment on qualified immunity grounds.
Coons argues that material facts concerning the circumstances of his arrest warranted the district court’s denial of summary judgment. We disagree. First, the district court faulted Casabella for failing to ask medical personnel about Coons’s condition and the extent of his injuries, and to otherwise investigate the circumstances of the accident, because he could have uncovered facts that might have affected Coons’s performance on the field sobriety tests or his appearance. However, as we have emphasized on more than one occasion, police officers are “not required to explore and eliminate every theoretically plausible claim of innocence before making an arrest.” Cerrone, 246 F.3d at 203 (quoting Martinez, 202 F.3d at 635) (internal quotation marks omitted). Insisting on such a heightened duty of investigation would defeat the purpose of qualified immunity, which is “to protect police from liability and suit when they are required to make on-the-spot judgments in tense circumstances.” Lennon, 66 F.3d at 424.
Second, despite the district court’s acknowledgment that the relevant analysis entails an inquiry into the facts known to the officer at the time of the arrest,
see Ricciuti v. New York City Transit Auth.,
124 F.3d 123, 128 (2d Cir.
Because Casabella had arguable probable cause and thus was entitled to summary judgment on the basis of qualified immunity, we need not reach his claim that he had actual probable cause to issue the appearance ticket.
CONCLUSION
The judgment of the district court is reversed.