Angel v. AngelAngel v. Angel
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Park
This is an appeal from a judgment dissolving the marriage between the petitioner-appellant, Mossie Lee Angel and her husband, Ester Angel, the respondent-appellee. The sole issue raised by this appeal relates to the trial court’s division of the property accumulated by the parties during their marriage.
The parties were married for thirty-four years. At the time of the entry of the decree dissolving the marriage, Mrs. Angel was fifty-four years of age and Mr. Angel was fifty-six years of age. The only child of the marriage, a daughter, is an adult. Both parties worked at various jobs throughout the period of the marriage. In recent years, Mrs. Angel has been the chief wage earner. Because of injuries, Mr. Angel has not been regularly employed other than caring for the operations of the farm which is the chief item of dispute.
In paragraph eight of the trial court’s findings of fact, the “property accumulated during this marriage” was described as a thirty acre farm and various items of personalty including cattle, hay, farming equipment, household goods, and two automobiles. In paragraph three of the trial court’s conclusions of law, the “marital property” of the parties was designated as the property described in paragraph eight of the findings of fact. Although not included in the property described in paragraph eight of the findings of fact, the sum of $1,300.00 was on deposit in a bank account in Mrs. Angel’s name. The trial court found that the parties “were almost even contributors to the accumulation of the marital property consisting of the real estate.” There was a specific finding that Ester Angel contributed $4,500.00 and that
In the judgment, the trial court awarded Mrs. Angel the bank account and all household goods and furniture “in lieu of lump sum alimony.” Each party was awarded the automobile he or she was then driving and those personal items he or she was then using. The trial court directed that the real property, cattle and farming equipment be sold and that the proceeds be equally divided between the parties. Mossie Lee Angel asserts that this division of property is erroneous for two reasons. First, she claims that the trial court failed to assign to her the property she received by inheritance and gift. Second, she contends that the trial court did not give adequate recognition to her contribution to the acquisition of the marital property.
Under
The trial court made no specific finding that any property of the parties constituted nonmarital property. As the bank account did not fall within the property described as being marital property, it would be logical to assume that the trial court considered the bank account to be nonmarital property. However, the bank account is included in the property awarded to Mossie Lee Angel “in lieu of lump sum alimony.” If the bank account constituted her separate nonmarital property, then there was no need to award it to her as maintenance under KRS 403.-200. On the other hand, the award of the bank account to Mrs. Angel may not have been intended as an award of maintenance because the court made no findings of fact as required by
As the thirty acre farm was described as being marital property, it would be logical to assume that the trial court found that no interest in the farm constituted nonmarital property. However, the trial court made a specific finding that Ester Angel contributed $4,500.00 and Mossie Lee Angel contributed approximately $5,000.00 to the acquisition of the farm. It is not clear whether the trial court considered these contributions to be nonmarital property. Consequently, we must consider whether either assumption would be correct.
At the time of their marriage, neither party owned any significant property. The first asset acquired after the marriage was a farm known as the Bethlehem Church farm. This farm was purchased for $1,800.00. Of that sum, $1,400.00 had been inherited by Ester Ai.gel on the death of his father. The parties lived on the Bethlehem Church farm for twelve years. During this time, they built a house, barn, and outbuildings. The Bethlehem Church farm was sold for $4,500.00.
That portion of the proceeds from the sale of the Bethlehem Church farm attributable to the investment of Ester Angel’s $1,400.00 inheritance constituted nonmarital property.
Farmer
v.
Farmer, supra;
Subsequently, the parties built a home on the farm and expended considerable effort in clearing the farm of brush and timber. The evidence did not indicate the particular tract on which the residence is built. Mr. and Mrs. Angel later conveyed a fifteen acre tract to their daughter. Again, the record is silent as to which tract or tracts were conveyed to the daughter.
Ester Angel contends that the proceeds from the sale of the Bethlehem Church farm were used to acquire the tracts from Mrs. Angel’s sisters and brother or were invested in the construction of the residence on the farm. Mossie Lee Angel asserts that the entire farm constitutes her nonmarital property. In addition to the tract which she received in the partition of her father’s real estate, Mrs. Angel testified that she received approximately $5,000.00 in cash upon the settlement of her father’s estate. She claims that this money was used to purchase the two tracts from her sisters and to purchase a Ford tractor, a mower and a turning plow. She also asserts that the last tract acquired was a gift to her from her brother. The trial court made no specific finding with respect to these conflicting contentions. However, this court notes that there was no request for additional findings of fact by either party pursuant to CR 52.04.
The trial court’s findings that Ester Angel contributed $4,500.00 and that Mossie Lee Angel contributed approximately $5,000.00 to the acquisition of the farm are both conflicting and clearly erroneous. Ester Angel did not contribute $4,500.00 to the acquisition of the farm because only $1,400.00 of the proceeds of the Bethlehem Church farm represented his nonmarital property. Mrs. Angel did not contribute the $5,000.00 cash received from her father’s estate because a portion of that money was used to buy farm equipment and the total cash investment was substantially less than $5,000.00.
Both parties have assumed on this appeal that the farm had an approximate value of $30,000.00. However, there is no expert testimony as to the value of the farm. Moreover, there is no testimony in the record to indicate what portion of the present value of the farm is attributable to the improvements made by the parties. Considering the failure of the parties to introduce evidence upon which the court could make a proper division of the marital and nonmarital property, it is not surprising that the trial court decreed an equal division of the property. Nevertheless, the absence of specific findings of fact on crucial issues makes it impossible for this court to afford a meaningful review of the trial court’s division of the property.
The tract received by Mrs. Angel in the partition of her father’s farm clearly constituted nonmarital property.
The tract conveyed without consideration by Mrs. Angel’s brother in 1961 was a gift and not marital property. KRS 403.-190(2)(a). The only question is whether the tract constituted the nonmarital property of Mossie Lee Angel alone or was owned equally by Mossie Lee and Ester Angel. Prior to the repeal of the restoration statutes (
The increased value of the thirty acre farm attributable to the improvements constitutes marital property. Sharp v. Sharp, supra (first appeal). However, the trial court made no finding of fact allocating the value of the farm between marital property and nonmarital property. Because of the erroneous findings of the trial court relating to the contribution of the parties to the acquisition of farm and because of the absence of the specific findings respecting the nonmarital property of the parties, the case must be remanded to the trial court for further proceedings. Robinson v. Robinson, Ky.App., 548 S.W.2d 155 (1977).
The judgment of the circuit court is reversed with the following directions:
(1) The trial judge shall make specific findings with respect to the nonmarital property owned by the parties.
(2) The trial court shall divide the marital property in just proportions in accordance with the standards set forth in
(3) If the trial court concludes that it is impossible to make the necessary findings on the basis of the existing record, the trial court may order the parties to introduce proof on such issues as the trial court may designate.
WHITE, J., concurs in this opinion.
VANCE, J., concurs in the result for the reasons stated in his concurring opinion in Turley v. Turley, Ky.App., 562 S.W.2d 665 (this day decided).