Andrews v. Yellow Freight System, Inc.Andrews v. Yellow Freight System, Inc.
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Hunt
In this appeal we decide the remedy available to Andrews as a result of the trial court’s erroneous pre-trial dismissal of the Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania as a party defendant.
The Insurance Company provided a policy of insurance in lieu of bond covering Yellow Freight System’s tractor-trailer which collided with Andrews’ car. In her suit for damages, Andrews joined Yellow Freight System and its insurance carrier pursuant to
Andrews’ claim against Yellow Freight was tried before a jury and a money judgment was entered in Andrews’ favor. Dissatisfied with the amount of the verdict, Andrews wants the Insurance Company reinstated as a party defendant and seeks a new trial on the issues of liability and damages.
In
Grissom,
we concluded that the provision allowing joinder of the motor carrier’s insurer in an action against the motor carrier was constitutional. Nevertheless, we recognize that under the Motor Carrier Act,
Judgment reversed and remanded.
Clarke, C. J., Bell, P. J., Benham, Fletcher and Sears-Collins, JJ., concur.
Notes
The dismissal of the insurer on equal protection grounds is, nonetheless, erroneous. In light of our opinion in Grissom, it is unlikely that trial courts will make this error. If, however, an insurer is dismissed, contrary to our opinion in Grissom, a party may appeal that dismissal by application for interlocutory appeal. We recently granted such an application, and remedied the trial court’s error by order. Roberts v. Carolina Freight Carriers, Case No. S92A1017, decided October 2, 1992.