Anderson v. FosterAnderson v. Foster
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Cobb
Anderson as administrator of A. W. Foster brought ¡suit against F. C. Foster and E. W. Butler, making in his petition .substantially the ^following allegations: F. C. Foster was the executor of A. G. Foster,‘E. W. Butler was the executor of Joshua Hill, and the plaintiff’s intestate was a son and legatee of A. G. Foster. After the death of plaintiff’s intestate, F. C. Foster as executor collected a sum of money belonging to the estate of his testator, to a specified part of which plaintiff’s intestate was entitled. Butler, as executor of Hill, had obtained a judgment against F. C. Foster and A. W. Foster, and F. C. Foster, instead of paying to the plaintiff as administrator of A. W. Foster the amount due his estate, paid the same to E. W. Butler to be applied as a credit upon the judgment held by him as executor of Hill against A. W. Foster, and Butler, with full knowledge of the fact that there was a duly appointed administrator upon the estate of A. W. Foster and that jF. C. Foster had no right to appropriate the sum in his hands to the payment of the ‘debts of A. W. Foster, received the same and applied it‘as a. credit on the judgment above referred to. At the time this was done the estate of A. W. Foster was insolvent, and there were debts •due by the estate of higher dignity than the debt due to Butler as executor of Hill. It is alleged that the money was collected by Foster in January, 1895, but the date on which the share of A. W. Foster was paid over to Butler is not distinctly alleged. It was charged that F. C. Foster and Butler were joint tort-feasors and as .such liable to the plaintiff for the amount paid by F. C. Foster to Butler, with interest thereon from the date the same was paid. By ¡an amendment to the petition it was alleged that the first intima*272tion the plaintiff had that F. C. Foster had in his hands the fund in question was about November 15, 1895; that the plaintiff was a non-resident of Morgan county, being a resident of Fulton county; and that immediately upon receiving this intimation he wrote to F. C. Foster, requesting information on the subject. Having failed to receive a reply, he wrote again, but this letter elicited no response. In April, 1896, plaintiff wrote to Butler, who at the time was the law partner of F. C. Foster, asking information of him on the same subject, the plaintiff having heard that F. C. Foster had paid over to Butler A. W. Foster’s .share in the fund collected. Butler immediately replied in a letter dated April 24, 1896, stating that the money had been paid over to him as executor of Hill; and this was the first positive information that the plaintiff had on the subject. It was alleged that the plaintiff was diligent to discover the fact that the money had been fraudulently paid over to Butler by F. C. Foster, and that he could not have discovered it sooner by the exercise of ordinary diligence. The defendant Butler filed a demurrer to the declaration, upon the following grounds: (1) There is a misjoinder of causes of action and parties. (2) Plaintiff’s remedy, if any he has, is against F. C. Foster, as there is no illegal or tortious act alleged against this defendant as an individual, and no allegation of the insolvency of Foster. (3) There is no cause of action set forth against this defendant. (4) It appears from the allegations that if there is any liability to plaintiff, it is on the part of the estate of Joshua Hill. The demurrer was sustained, and to this ruling the plaintiff excepted. The case proceeded to trial as against F. C. Foster upon the issues raised by his answer, one of which was that the cause of action set forth was barred by the statute of limitations. It appeared from the evidence that the money alleged to have been misappropriated was paid by F. C. Foster to E. W. Butler as executor of Hill, in January, 1895. There was testimony by the plaintiff which established substantially the allegations of the petition as to diligence in ascertaining about the alleged misappropriation of F. C. Foster of the funds belonging to plaintiff’s intestate. The court directed a verdict ■ in favor of the defendant, and to this ruling the plaintiff excepted.
Judgment affirmed in fart, and in fart reversed.
All the Ju,stices concurring, exceft Lewis, J., absent.