Anderson v. ArgravesAnderson v. Argraves
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Daly
The plaintiffs brought this action against the state highway commissioner to recover for damage alleged to have been occasioned to their respective properties. They averred in their substituted complaint as amended, hereinafter referred to as the complaint, that “the defendant was in control of a certain culvert and embankment over the West Branch of the Shepaug River and under a part of the main State Highway, known as Route #25”; that the “culvert and embankment were erected and maintained by the defendant and his predecessors, for the purpose of directing, controlling and diverting the watercourse, known as the Shepaug River, and to prevent said waters from flowing upon the highway, Route #25, and to drain off the water therefrom, by causing said waters to flow through said culvert under said highway and into said Shepaug River”; that the “culvert was constructed above the lands of the plaintiffs much narrower than the bed of the stream and wholly in
The law is firmly established that the state cannot be sued except with its consent.
Somers
v.
Hill,
143 Conn. 476, 479, 123 A.2d 468;
Scranton
v.
L. G. DeFelice & Son, Inc.,
137 Conn. 580, 585, 79 A.2d 600;
Anselmo
v.
Cox,
135 Conn. 78, 80, 60 A.2d 767. Whether a particular action is one against the state is not determined solely by referring to the parties of record. The fact that the state is not named as a defendant does not conclusively establish that the action is not within the principle which
There is no error.
In this opinion the other judges concurred.
Notes
“Sec. 2134. HIGHWAYS MAY BE DRAINED INTO PRIVATE LANDS. Persons authorized to construct or to repair highways may make or clear any watercourse or place for draining off the water therefrom into or through any person’s land so far as necessary to drain off such water; and, when it shall be necessary to make any drain upon or through any person’s land for the purpose named in this section, it shall be done in such way as to do the least damage to such land; provided nothing in this section shall be so construed as to allow the
“Sec. 2194. ALTERING OF HIGHWAYS; ENTRY UPON PRIVATE PROPERTY. The highway commissioner shall have power to lay out, alter, construct or reconstruct, maintain or repair, widen or grade any highway whenever, in his judgment, the interest of the state shall so require. Said commissioner or his agent may enter upon private property for the purpose of surveying or examining such property for the location or relocation of any highway, or for the determination of the boundary line of any highway under his control. He shall use care so that no unnecessary damage shall result, and the state shall be liable to the owner of any property for any damage he may cause such owner.”
“Demurrer
The defendant in the above entitled matters [demurs] to the allegations of the plaintiffs’ complaint and sets forth as the ground of said demurrer the following:
1. A civil action brought against the defendant in his capacity as Highway Commissioner of the State of Connecticut is equivalent to a claimed cause of action against the State of Connecticut, and the defendant in his capacity as Highway Commissioner is immune from any such civil action, and the plaintiffs are barred from the bringing of the same except insofar as the State of Connecticut has
2. Said complaint by its allegations purports to charge the defendant with a breach of his statutory duty under Section 2134 of the Connecticut General Statutes [Rev. 1949] for causing a water course to be directed and cleared into and through the properties of the plaintiffs. It appears affirmatively from the plaintiffs’ complaint that this water course was in reality the Shepaug River which merely flowed through a culvert under Route 25 and was not a water course for draining the water off of the highway. The defendant, if he is liable for a breach of duty insofar as Section 2134 is concerned, is only liable for that unnecessary damage which he has caused by directing a watercourse or a place for the draining of water into or through the plaintiffs’ land for surface water from the highway itself.”