Alweis v. WagnerAlweis v. Wagner
- Reporters:
- , , ,
- Before:
- Fuld
Dissenting Opinion
(dissenting). The court at Special Term and a unanimous Appellate Division, agreeing with the position taken by the petitioners, granted them an order in the nature of mandamus. Although this court recognizes, as of course it must, a “legal right” in the petitioners to the relief which they seek, it is directing a reversal of that order on the ground that “No such manifest right to insist on [that] legal right * * * is shown as to entitle petitioners to mandamus ”. I cannot subscribe to either the majority’s reasoning or conclusion. The order herein was granted by both courts below and, since consideration of the facts demonstrates that their determination is neither wrong in law nor an abuse of discretion as *925a matter of law, this court may not properly upset the grant of mandamus. (See, e.g., Matter of Pruzan v. Valentine, 282 N. Y. 498, 501; Matter of Durr v. Paragon Trading Corp., 270 N. Y. 464.) The cases cited by the majority to support its reversal are manifestly distinguishable on their facts.
There can be no doubt that, when in January, 1962, the salaries here involved were voted by the Board of Justices of Kings County and submitted to the Board of Estimate for inclusion in the city’s budget, the Justices had the mandatory right and power to fix such salaries and to require the Board of Estimate to provide for them in the budget. (See Matter of Moskowitz v. La Guardia, 294 N. Y. 830, affg. 268 App. Div. 918, affg. 183 Misc. 33; Matter of Henderson v. La Guardia, 294 N. Y. 728, affg. 268 App. Div. 892, affg. 182 Misc. 1071; Matter of Wingate v. McGoldrick, 279 N. Y. 246.) More specifically, the only law in effect both then and in May of 1962, when the Board of Estimate adopted the budget, was section 315 of the Judiciary Law and that statute imposed on the Board of Estimate the duty of including in the budget—which had to be approved by July 1, 1962 (New York City Charter, § 114, now § 112) —the salaries set by the Justices.
The constitutional provision which changed the method of fixing the salaries of court employees paid by the city did not take effect, by its terms, until September 1, 1962 (
Chief Judge Desmond and Judges Dye, Burke and Bergan concur in Memorandum; Judge Fuld dissents and votes to affirm in an opinion in which Judges Van Voorhis and Scileppi concur.
Order reversed, etc.
Lead Opinion
Memorandum. Order granting relief in the nature of mandamus against the Board of Estimate reversed and petition dismissed, with costs. The statute under which the Supreme Court Justices of Kings County in January, 1962 fixed at substantial increases the salaries of petitioners for the fiscal year 1962-1963 (
The order should be reversed and the petition dismissed, with costs in this court and in the Appellate Division.