144 Minn. 333 | Minn. | 1919
Action for personal injuries. There was a verdict for the plaintiff. The defendant appeals from the order denying its alternative motion for judgment or a new trial.
The plaintiff was a Lutheran minister with a charge at Red Wing. Before assuming his pastorate he was for many years engaged in denominational educational work. He was 57 years old at the time of the injury. There was a comminuted fracture of the right leg a few inches above the ankle and there were other minor injuries. His suffering was very considerable. The leg is one and a half inches shorter than the other. There is evidence that a fallen arch has resulted from the injury. He used crutches in July, 1918, and soon after commenced using two canes. He was attended by the defendant, who was a leading surgeon of the city, and in charge of the city hospital. The treatment was skilful, there was no 'considerable infection, and the result was good, but the injury was in its nature a severe one and is permanent in its consequences. The verdict is not excessive as the result of passion or prejudice.
Order affirmed.