99 Misc. 550 | N.Y. Sup. Ct. | 1917
In this, an uncontested action for divorce, service of the summons was attempted to be made upon the defendant by publication. The order of publication named two newspapers, one of which is published in the Italian language. The proof of publication before the court shows the summons and notice to have been printed entirely in Italian. The court intimated on the taking of proofs affecting the merits of the plaintiff’s charges that the publication in question was insufficient. Counsel for plaintiff insists that, as the parties are Italians, such publication ‘ ‘ most likely ’ ’ gave notice to the defendant, as
As well might it be claimed that personal service of a summons written in a foreign language is good service, for due publication is due service, and the error in the one case is equally obvious in the other.
It may be that the justice in making the order of publication had the discretion to designate this foreign language newspaper as one ‘1 most likely to give notice to the defendant,” but the publication should have been in English. This was the ruling in a Wisconsin case (Wakeley v. Nicholas, 16 Wis. 588), where publica
The application for judgment must be denied, and the complaint dismissed.
Application denied.