Aldred v. SylvesterAldred v. Sylvester
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Morris
“Item III. I further order and direct, that at the death of said Margaret McDaniel (above named) that the said 80-acres tract of land above described be sold at private or public sale as may be most advisable, and for the best price that can be procured for the same, and that the proceeds of such sale be equally divided among my brothers and sister to wit: Lorinda Smith (wife of Thomas Smith), Thomas Castor and Conrad Castor. But if any or either of said brothers and sisters last named shall die previous to the termination of such life estate, and the sale of said 80-acre tract, then in that case, the descendants of such de*545ceased devisees are to have the same share- as their ancestors would have had if then living.”
Item five reads as follows:
“Item Y. The balance and residue of my property * * * I give and devise to the said Lorinda Smith, Thomas Castor and Conrad Castor (or their descendants) to be equally divided between thepi share and share alike.”
The testator died in 1880, the owner of the land in question. When he died, his sister and brothers were living. Margaret McDaniel still survives. Lorinda Smith died intestate previous to 1891, leaving children and heirs, who were made defendants in this action and who were defaulted. Thomas Castor also died intestate previous to 1891, leaving children and heirs, who were parties to this suit, and defaulted. In August, 1891, Margaret McDaniel, life tenant, Conrad Castor, and the heirs of Lorinda Smith and Thomas Castor executed their warranty deeds to the 80-acre tract to named grantees, who at once took possession of the land, and held the same, and afterwards conveyed it to appellant, who has since been in possession under claim of absolute ownership. Conrad Castor, after the execution of his deeds, died intestate, leaving appellees as his descendants and heirs at law.
If, as appellant contends, Conrad Castor took a fee simple absolute, which vested on testator’s death, the’ court erred in sustaining the demurrer to the third paragraph. Appellees contend that at the death of testator the fee vested in Conrad Castor and his brother and sister, but that such fee was a base or determinable one that divested as to each on his death during the life of Margaret McDaniel: that on the death of Conrad Castor his title deter*546mined, and Ms descendants, appellees here, on the happening of the contingency took the absolute fee by executory devise, subject only to the life estate of Margaret McDaniel. Appellees further say that it was not intended by the testator that the title to the 80-acre tract should be affected by item five containing the residuary provision. In support of their theory appellees rely especially on Jones v. Miller (1859), 13 Ind. 337; Smith v. Hunter (1864), 23 Ind. 580; and Corey v. Springer (1894), 138 Ind. 506, 37 N. E. 322.
*549estate, rather than to.its vesting; (3) words of survivorship are presumed to relate to the death of testator, rather than that of the first taker, if they are fairly capable of such interpretation. Aspey v. Lewis (1899), 152 Ind. 493, 52 N. E. 756; Myers v. Carney (1908), 171 Ind. 379, 84 N. E. 400; Fowler v. Duhme (1896), 143 Ind. 248, 42 N. E. 623; Campbell v. Bradford (1906), 166 Ind. 451, 77 N. E. 849; Taylor v. Stephens, supra; Moores v. Hare (1896), 144 Ind. 573, 43 N. E. 870; Tindall v. Miller (1896), 143 Ind. 337, 41 N. E. 535.; Borgner v. Brown (1893), 133 Ind. 391, 33 N. E. 92; Wright v. Charley (1891), 129 Ind. 257, 28 N. E. 706; Heilman v. Heilman (1891), 129 Ind. 59, 28 N. E. 310; Bruce v. Bissell (1889), 119 Ind. 525, 22 N. E. 4, 12 Am. St. 436; Amos v. Amos (1889), 117 Ind. 19, 19 N. E. 539; Hoover v. Hoover (1888), 116 Ind. 498, 19 N. E. 468; Harris v. Carpenter (1887), 109 Ind. 540, 10 N. E. 422; Davidson v. Koehler (1881), 76 Ind. 398; Rumsey v. Durham (1854), 5 Ind. 71. It is also well settled by our decisions that courts will, not construe a limitation into an executory devise when it can take effect as a remainder nor a remainder to be contingent where it can be taken as vested. Fowler v. Duhme, supra, 267; Carnahan v. Freeman (1915), 183 Ind. 271, 108 N. E. 955; Moore v. Lyons (1840), 25 Wend. 119.
In Hoover v. Hoover, supra, Daniel Hoover devised a life estate to his widow, “and, at her death, *552said real estate to pass in fee simple, in equal portions, to my son, Andrew Hoover and my daughter, Hattie Hoover. The east half of said farm to go to * * . * Andrew, if he be living, and if he be dead, then to his widow until her death or marriage, and at her death or marriage then, to go to his heirs, and if there be no heirs living, then said land shall pass to the heirs of Daniel Hoover.” The widow survived testator, and afterwards conveyed her life, estate to Andrew. At testator’s death Andrew had a wife and two children. In an action by Andrew to quiet title against his children, wife and mother, and others, it was contended by appellants that the devise to Andrew was a contingent remainder vesting only in the event that he survived his mother, or, if the estate devised vested at. testator’s death it was a determinable fee which would divest on his death before that of his mother. In a learned opinion by Mitchell, J., it was first held that the contention relating to .a determinable fee was untenable, and in the discussion relating to the other contention it was said: “Accepting the position as established, that words of survivorship in a will, unless there is a manifest intent to the contrary, always relate to the death of the testator, and that, in the absence of a contrary intent, a will always speaks as from the date of the testator’s death, there can be no doubt but that Andrew P. Hoover took an estate in fee simple in remainder, which vested immediately upon the death of his father, but which he could only enjoy, in possession, after the termination of the life estate of his mother. An estate in remainder is not rendered contingent by the uncertainty of the time of enjoyment. The right and capacity of the remainderman to take possession of the estate, if the possession were to become vacant, and the certainty that the event, upon which the *553vacancy depends, must happen sometime, and not the certainty that it will happen in the lifetime of the remainderman, determine whether or not the estate is vested or contingent. Croxall v. Shererd [1866], 5 Wall. 268; Tiedeman, Real Prop. § 401. Having taken a conveyance from the life tenant, thus terminating her estate in a portion of the farm, there can be no doubt of the appellee’s right to maintain an action now, as to that part of the land, at least.”
In Aspey v. Lewis, supra, after devising a widow’s life estate the will provided “And I direct further that the above estate that is bequeathed to my wife shall be in the full possession of my only daughter, Maria Louisa, at the death or marriage of my wife, provided she shall be living; and if she is not living, at the death or marriage of my wife then the estate to go to the use of my brothers and sisters or their heirs.” The widow, daughter, and several brothers and sisters survived testator. The daughter married, and had children, but died before the death of her mother. In a suit to quiet title, by the widower and children of Maria Louisa (appellants), against testator’s brothers and sisters, on the theory that a fee simple absolute vested in the daughter on the testator’s death, it was held by this court that appellant’s theory was correct. In the opinion by Hadley, J., it was said: “If it may be said from the words used that the time of survivorship of the daughter is doubtful, the well-established rules of construction require us to construe the words referring to the death of the daughter to relate to the death of the testator, and the clause, ‘at the death or marriage of my wife then the estate to go to the use of my brothers and sisters or their heirs’ to relate to. the vesting of the remainder in the brothers and sisters at the death of the testator, contingent upon *554the death of Maria Louisa prior to that time. Such a construction accords with legal principles.” In Myers v. Carney, supra, the testator devised, by the first item, an estate to his wife during widowhood or life. Item two provided that “when my said wife shall cease to be my widow either by marriage or death, it is my will that my real estate shall be sold and the proceeds thereof distributed as follows, to wit: To * * * Elizabeth Myers (and five other children) each the undivided one-eighth of the proceeds of the sale of said real estate.” Item five provided that “If * * * either one of my living children shall die before the distribution of my estate as hereinbefore provided, his or her portion shall descend as provided by law where a person dies intestate.” At testator’s death his widow and children survived. Elizabeth Myers was then married and had a child, which died before the death of Elizabeth. Elizabeth died leaving her husband as sole heir. Testator’s widow died nearly eleven years later. It was held that the interest of Elizabeth vested absolutely on testator’s death, and that her husband took it as her sole heir.
In Heilman v. Heilman, supra, it appears that items 6 and 7 of the will of William Heilman were as follows: “Sixth. To my dear wife, Mary Jenner Heilman, I give and bequeath all the rest of my property, real and personal, to be had and held by her during her natural life, and so long as she remains my unmarried widow. Should my said wife marry again, then she shall receive from my estate the amount and portion allowed her by law, and no more. Seventh. After the death of my dear wife all my estate, excepting the bequests herein made, shall be divided in equal shares among all my children, and should any of my children be dead, and have left children, then they shall be entitled to the distribu*555tive share of their parents.” The testator was survived by his widow, and sons and daughters. His son, George P. Heilman had living children, and, in the widow’s lifetime, sold specific portions of his legacy to the appellee in that case. In a suit by the purchaser, against the children of said George P., to quiet title, it was held that the title to the legacy vested in George P. on the death of testator; that the words of postponement related to the enjoyment of the estate, and not its time of vesting; that the reference to testator’s grandchildren was intended to prevent the lapsing of bequests, though unnecessary under §§ 2567, 2571 R. S. 1881; that appellant’s contention that, since the will there (as here) contained no express language of gift to the secondary devisees, but simply a direction to divide the estate among them after the death of the life tenant it should be held as showing the testator’s intent that the time fixed for distribution determined the period of vesting as well as enjoyment in possession, should not prevail. The opinion in that case has been cited with approval repeatedly, and recently, by this court. See Myers v. Carney, supra. In Davidson v. Koehler, supra, the will of Governor Noah Noble was construed. By the second item of his will he devised a life estate to his widow. The third item provided that “At the death of my wife, if my son shall then be living and of age, or as soon thereafter as he shall become of age, or if he shall then be dead, I direct that my home farm shall then be divided among my children then living, share and share alike, taking into consideration any advancements herein by me made to any such child, so as to make the shares of my estate equal; and in case any of my children shall have died after my decease, and before such division, the heirs or representatives of such deceased child shall be entitled to such share as *556their respective ancestors would have received if then living.” Governor Noble died in 1844, leaving surviving him his widow, and two children,Winston P. Noble and Catherine Davidson, as his only-heirs. Catherine Davidson died in 1857, and left surviving her a husband and five children. The widow of the Governor died in 1874. It was held that the children took at testator’s death a vested estate in the home farm. In Rumsey v. Durham, supra, there was a devise to the widow during widowhood or life, followed by this: “2. After the death or marriage of my wife, my will is that all my property, real as well as personal, shall be sold, and equally divided among my children.” It will be noted that there, as well as here, and in the Heilman case, supra, there was no express gift to the secondary objects of his bounty. The widow and eight children survived testator. Before the widow’s ’ death, some of the eight children died, leaving children. It was held that the shares of the eight children vested at testator’s death. This case was cited with approval on the question of vesting in Thieband v. Sebastian (1858), 10 Ind. 454; Wilson v. Rudd (1862), 19 Ind. 101; Simonds v. Harris (1884), 92 Ind. 505, and later cases.
In Fowler v. Duhme, supra, this court determined the proper construction of the will of Moses Fowler by which he devised a vast landed estate. By item three of the will he devised the residue of his estate to his children, “subject to the following conditions, to wit: (a) In the event of the death of any of my said children without lawful issue living at the time of the death of such child, then the share of such deceased child shall vest in, and become the absolute property in fee simple, in equal portions, of such of my said children as shall then be living, and the living descendants of such, if any, as may then be dead, *557the descendants of any deceased child taking, between them, the share which, if living, would have vested in their father or mother.” One of said children died before testator’s death and by a codicil he devised the deceased child’s share to a grandson, subject to the above conditions. The testator’s widow, the two children and the grandson survived him. One of the children, James M. Fowler, had minor children living at testator’s decease. The daughter, Mrs. Duhme, brought suit against her brother and his children, and other persons who were heirs of testator, to quiet title. She claimed .to be the owner in fee simple absolute of the interest devised to her — that said clause “a” referred only to a death occurring in the lifetime of testator. The defendants contended that the clause referred to death after that of testator and that the estate devised by item three was a determinable fee and, in case of Mrs. Duhme’s death without issue living, the same would determine and in which event the fee simple was limited over by way of. executory devise to the persons designated. In an elaborate opinion,, reviewing the authorities of this and other jurisdictions, it was held that the children took a fee simple which vested absolutely on testator’s death. Appellants there, as do appellees here, relied in part on Jones v. Miller, supra; and Smith v. Hunter, supra. In the course of the opinion, these cases, with others, were discussed, and it was said of each, that in the opinions “the court did not consider the rule which directs an indefinitely éxpressed death to the period of the testator’s life.” After discussing some other cases there cited, it was said of these two and the others on page 275, “If we are in error as to the question properly arising in these cases there is no room to reconcile them with numerous recent cases we have already cited and commented upon from this *558State.” It was further said., in considering the contention that a determinable fee was created, “since a devise of an estate, defeasible on the happening of a contingency, may be so easily expressed, and since such estates stand in disfavor before the law, the intention to create such an estate must be denied unless such intention has been made certain by the language of the whole will.” If the opinion in Fowler v. Duhme, supra, is to stand, Jones v. Miller, supra, and Smith v. Hunter, supra, can not be regarded as binding precedents on the question here presented. That opinion has been followed repeatedly by this court, and as late as Clark v. Thieme (1914), 181 Ind. 163, 103 N. E. 1068, at least, and we are not disposed to question it here.
*560
While two wills are rarely, if ever, alike in all respects, it will be observed that a remarkable similarity exists between the seventh item of the will in Heilman v. Heilman, supra, and the italicized portion of the Springer will. The principal difference is *563found in the express language of present gift in the Springer will that is absent in the other. This lacking feature in the Heilman will was unsuccessfully urged there as denoting a contingent remainder, and, in some jurisdictions is accepted as a presumption of intention to postpone the period of vesting to the time of distribution. Notwithstanding, this court held in the Heilman case that the child’s estate vested absolutely on testator’s death. See also Rumsey v. Durham, supra; Taylor v. Stephens, supra; Tindall v. Miller, supra; Harris v. Carpenter, supra; Myers v. Carney, supra. In the Corey v. Springer, supra, opinion the court says: “Here the testator, in language clear and unmistakable as could be employed, fixes the time for ‘such distribution’ or final disposition to occur, viz., ‘at the death of his widow’. Until this event shall happen, he (testator) holds the fee conditional and in abeyance, subject to alteration, and only to ripen and fasten absolutely in his children surviving at the death of his unmarried widow.” This language can not be reconciled with the opinion in the Heilman case, frequently approved since the decision in Corey v. Springer, supra; neither can it be reconciled with the opinions in Fowler v. Duhme, supra; Aspey v. Lewis, supra, nor the many other ones we have herein noted, and we disapprove it. 4 Kent, Comm. 257; 1 Fearne, Remainders 409, 410. Under the authority of our decisions, practically uniform (excepting in Corey v. Springer, supra), and construed in the light of the rules of construction referred to in this opinion, it should have been held that John J. Springer took a remainder that vested absolutely on testator’s death; that the time of “distribution or disposition” was intended as the commencement of the period of enjoyment in possession by testator’s children, and not as the time for *564vesting of their title; that the devise to the grandchildren related to the death of a child before testator’s death, and was intended by the testator as substitutional, or to avoid a lapse of the devise. See Heilman v. Heilman, supra; Taylor v. Stephens, supra; Borgner v. Brown (1893), 133 Ind. 391, 33 N. E. 92; Ballard v. Camplin (1903), 161 Ind. 16, 24, 67 N. E. 505.
The fourth paragraph of complaint proceeds on a theory inconsistent with the conclusion wé have reached and consequently there was no error in sustaining a demurrer to it. Judgment reversed with instructions to overrule appellees’ demurrer to the third paragraph of complaint.
Note. — Reported in 111 N. E. 914. As to the tendency of law to favor the vesting of estates, see, 10 Am. St. 472. As to the time to which words of survivorship refer in a devise or bequest of remainder after life estate, see 14 Ann. Cas. 706. See, also, under (1) 40 Cyc 1664-1678; (2) 40 Cyc 1386; (3, 4) 40 Cyc 1388; (5) 40 Cyc 1650; (6) 40 Cyc 1651; (7) 40 Cyc 1667, 1668; (8) 40 Cyc 1645, 1666; (9) 40 Cyc 1821, 1823; (10) 40 Cyc 1689; (11) 16 Cyc 602; (12) 40 Cyc 1937.