Aholtz v. DurfeeAholtz v. Durfee
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Craig
delivered the opinion of the Court:
This was a bül in chancery to review a former decree of the circuit court of Macon county, rendered in a certain cause between the same parties. The defendants interposed a demurrer to the bill, which the court sustained, and the bül was dismissed. The complainant appealed, and the question to be determined is as to the sufficiency of the bill.
The hill contains other allegations, hut enough have been set out to show its scope and object. The bill contains a prayer for process, and for an injunction to restrain the execution of the writ of possession, for a new trial in the action of ejectment, that the tax title he set aside, and that the court find the amount complainant should pay Durfee, that he be-permitted to take the evidence of Coon, and for general relief-
It is plain, from the bill, that the same question presented by this bill was litigated between the same parties in a former chancery proceeding. In the former case, there was a bill,, answer, replication, proofs, a hearing, and a final decree against the complainant. It is not alleged in the bill that there are-errors in the record of the former proceeding, or that the decree was obtained by fraud, but the gist of the bill is, that, since the former decree the complainant has found a new witness, by whom
There are several fatal objections to the bill. A bill of review may be filed, in a proper case, upon newly discovered evidence, and this bill is pretended to be predicated upon that ground; but a brief reference to a few elementary principles will suffice to show that the allegations of the bill are not sufficient.
Where a bill is brought to review a former decree, it is necessary to set out the bill, answer and decree in the former proceeding. A mere skeleton of the record to be reviewed will not suffice. In Story’s Eq. PI. sec. 420, in speaking of the form of a bill of review, the author says: “In a bill of this nature, it is necessary to state the former bill and the proceedings therein, the decree, and the point in which the party exhibiting the bill of review conceives himself aggrieved by it.”’ This court has announced substantially the same rule in a number of cases. Gardner v. Emerson, 40 Ill. 297; Judson v. Stephens, 75 id. 259; Goodrich v. Thompson, 88 id. 207; Turner v. Berry, 3 Gilm. 544. In the case last cited it is said: “From the very nature of the proceedings it is manifestly necessary to state all the proceedings in the original cause, except the evidence on which the court found the facts on which it proceeded to render the decree.” In the Emerson ease the same doctrine is declared, and it is also held, that where the bill is brought on newly discovered evidence, the
There is, however, another fatal defect in the bill. In order to sustain a bill of review for newly discovered evidence, the evidence must be of an important and decisive character, and must not be cumulative. In Griggs v. Gear, 3 Gilm. 10, in discussing this question, it is said: “The bill must set forth the newly discovered matter. The evidence must not be cumulative, and.must be of an‘important and decisive character.” From the allegations of complainant’s bill, it is plain that the evidence of Coon is cumulative, and it is not of a decisive character.
The letter of the proposed witness, Coon, in regard to what his testimony might be as to complainant’s efforts to pay the costs, is made an exhibit in the bill. In the letter is the following : “What was said by Fred to the clerk about this matter, or what the “clerk said to Fred about it, I can not state. In a short time after this, Fred came into the office alone, and had some talk with the clerk about these costs; but what was said by Fred, or whether he offered to make the payment, I am unable to state.” This evidence can not be regarded as decisive. Had it been introduced on the former trial it could add but little weight to that of the complainant, and in addition it is merely cumulative.
There are other objections to the bill, but we have pointed out enough to show that the demurrer was properly sustained.
The judgment of the Appellate Court will be affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.,