Adams v. AdamsAdams v. Adams
- Reporters:
- , ,
- Before:
- Traynor
Defendant appeals from an interlocutory judgment of divorce providing for support and maintenance of plaintiff until further order of the court.
Plaintiff and defendant separated. One month later they executed a “Property Settlement Agreement” providing for the division of all their property and for the support and maintenance of plaintiff and their minor child. Support and maintenance were to cease for plaintiff after 18 months but were to continue thereafter for the child. The agreement stated that plaintiff, “in view of her skill and training as an experienced secretary, and by reason of her ability to become gainfully employed, particularly waives any right to support and maintenance other than, or in addition to, that provided herein in view of the premises and in consideration of [defendant’s] agreement to transfer and assign to [her] the major portion of the community property as hereinabove set forth.” Earlier in the agreement it was stated that “except as hereinafter specified, each party hereto is hereby released and absolved from any and all obligations and liabilities for the future acts and duties of the other . . . including all claims of either party upon the other for support and maintenance as wife or husband . . .” it being understood that this instrument is intended to settle the rights of the parties hereto in all respects.”
The trial court, after completion of the testimony of the corroborating witness, inquired whether defendant’s counsel was in the courtroom. Plaintiff’s counsel replied that he did hot think so but “I know we spent some time to get this property settlement. It has been after constant negotiation for two months.” The trial judge replied that defendant should be advised to stipulate to an amendment of the agreement to provide that the $50 per month until further order of the court was for the support and maintenance of plaintiff as well as the child. “If he refuses to stipulate, serve him with an amended complaint in which that is requested in the prayer, and at that time this Court will make that order.”
Defendant refused to stipulate to the change and, about four months later, plaintiff’s motion for leave to file an “Amendment to Complaint to Conform to Proof” was heard. This amendment added the words “of plaintiff and” to the prayer, thereby changing it to read, “. .,. arid then the sum of Fifty Dollars ($50) per month for the support and maintenance of plaintiff and of said minor son, Bryan George Adams.” Defendant’s counsel appeared specially to question the jurisdiction of the court to allow such an amendment, but the motion was granted. The amendment was served on defendant and he defaulted. The trial court approved the property settlement “except as to the limitation therein with reference to the payments of $50.00 per month,” awarded custody of the child to plaintiff, and awarded support and
Defendant contends that the property settlement agreement is valid and, in the absence of a finding that it is inequitable or was procured by fraud or compulsion, should have been approved by the trial court. We agree with his contention.
Property settlement agreements occupy a favored position in the law of this state and are sanctioned by the Civil Code.
(Hill
v.
Hill,
23 Cal.2d 82, 89 [142 P.2d 417] ;
Hensley
v.
Hensley,
179 Cal. 284, 287 [183 P. 445];
The most difficult problems arising from such contracts are those concerning support and maintenance provisions when the agreement is presented to the court in a divorce action. The parties, upon separation, may agree to provide for support and maintenance in a variety of ways, which generally fall into three categories. The first includes contracts in which the support and maintenance provisions are in the nature of alimony, whether in lump sum or monthly payments, and are separable from the provisions that divide the property. The contract may even provide solely for support and maintenance without reference to a division of property. These contracts, if equitable, are enforceable even though not presented, to the court in a divorce action.
(Sanborn
v.
Sanborn,
3 Cal.App.2d 437, 442 [39 P.2d 830].) If presented to a court in an action for divorce the court has the power to modify the pro
The second category includes, among others, contracts in which the “support and maintenance” provisions are not in the nature of alimony but are part of the division of property. This category also includes contracts that provide solely for the payment of monthly or lump sums “in lieu of community property.” Such contracts must be treated like other property settlement agreements dealing solely with divisions of property.
(Ettlinger
v.
Ettlinger,
3 Cal.2d 172, 177-178 [44 P.2d 540].) If the contract was not fraudulent when made, and there was no violation of the confidential relationship, it will be binding on the court and there can be no modification of the payments after the decree without the consent of the parties.
(Puckett
v.
Puckett,
21 Cal.2d 833, 840 [136 P.2d 1].) The court in the divorce action may grant alimony to the wife and approve the agreement as well, since these agreements purport to deal only with the division of the property of the parties. (
The third category includes contracts in which the wife waives all support and maintenance, or all support and maintenance except as provided in the agreement, in consideration of receiving a more favorable division of the community property. The court cannot add a provision for alimony to such contracts without changing basically the agreement of the parties as to the division of their property. We are confronted with such a situation in the present case.
Both parties rely upon
Darsie
v.
Darsie,
49 Cal.App.2d 491 [122 P.2d 64] ;
Peck
v.
Peck,
52 Cal.App.2d 792 [127 P.2d 94]; and
Eddy
v.
Eddy,
64 Cal.App.2d 672 [149 P.2d 187]. These cases were concerned with decrees granting alimony in default actions where there were no requests for alimony in the relief prayed, for. In each case the relief was found to be in excess of that prayed for and the court stated that when the trial court finds that justice requires the payment of support money it should set aside the default and authorize
The rule that a wife may waive alimony in return for a more favorable division of the community property so long as the agreement was valid when made does not deprive her of the protection of the courts. A court in a divorce action will carefully scrutinize the agreements, especially where the parties did not have the advice of counsel. The wife, after being advised of her rights by her attorney, might not wish to sign the agreement; if not, she may request that provisions for alimony and the division of the property be made by the court in the divorce action. If her consent to the agreement was procured through fraud or compulsion, or if circumstances are such that the court finds the agreement inequitable, the court may withhold approval of the agreement. In the present case the wife agreed to waive alimony and accept a major portion of the community property and payments for a period of 18 months. Since nothing was shown to indicate that the agreement was inequitable the parties are bound by the agreement.
Gibson, C. J., Shenk, J., Edmonds, J., Carter, J., Sehauer, J., and Spence, J., concurred.