A. R. Barnes & Co. v. Chicago Typographical Union No. 16A. R. Barnes & Co. v. Chicago Typographical Union No. 16
- Reporters:
- ,
- Before:
- Cartwright
Lead Opinion
delivered the opinion of the court:
The superior court of Cook county overruled the demurrer of appellants to the bill of complaint filed against them by the appellees in said court seeking an injunction restraining appellants from interfering with the business of appellees or with their employees, and picketing appellees’ premises. The defendants elected to stand by their demurrer and the court entered a decree in accordance with the prayer of the bill, perpetually enjoining defendants “from in any manner interfering with, hindering, obstructing or stopping the business of said complainants, or any of them, or of their agents, servants or employees, in the. operation of the business of said complainants, respectively; from picketing or maintaining at or near the premises of said complainants, or any of them, any picket or pickets; from assaulting or
The demurrer admitted the existence of the facts stated in the bill, and the question to be determined is whether such facts authorized the decree. Briefly stated, the facts so alleged and admitted are as follows:
At the time of filing the bill the complainants were, and for several years had been, engaged in the printing business and each had a valuable plant and an extensive business, in the conduct of which they had made contracts for printing for future delivery which would afford a substantial profit. They were and had been members of a voluntary association known as the Chicago Typothetze, which was organized for the purpose of advancing and improving the printing and binding business and for the purpose of employing skilled mechanics whose services might be required by the members of the association. The defendants were Typographical Union No. 16 and its officers, a labor union existing in the city of Chicago whose members are typesetters and compositors, one of the rules of which was that its members should not work with those who did not belong to that union, and said members were bound, at the command of the union and its officers, to strike and leave the employment of anyone who insisted upon employing non-union men. The plant or shop from which all employees not belonging to this union were excluded was called a closed shop, while one in which the employer exercised his right of employing whom he pleased was called an open shop. In July, 1905, the Typographical Union announced that after January 1, 1906, eight hours should constitute a day’s work; that no workman should be allowed to work more than that time and that no employer should be allowed to employ workmen who worked more than eight hours. Some of the complainants employed compositors who were not
The argument that the court erred in overruling the demurrer is upon the two grounds that the bill did not state definite facts but only conclusions and generalities and that all the facts alleged did not authorize any relief or injunction. It is also contended that if the decree is not reversed as a whole, it should be modified so as not to enjoin the defendants from doing certain acts which they claim to be within their lawful and constitutional rights.
It was not necessary that the bill should contain the evidence which would support its general statements, or the circumstances, in detail, which would prove the ultimate facts alleged. It distinctly and clearly averred the essential facts forming the basis of the prayer for relief, so .as to be readily understood and to apprise the defendants of what they were required to meet. It alleged that the defendants were acting in combination and by agreement in an endeavor to coerce the complainants as to whom they should employ and what policy they should adopt in the conduct of their business; that defendants had proposed the contract by which the complainants were to comply with the demands of the union with reference to the hours of labor, the scale of wages, and should join in boycotts by refusing to do any work for shops having difficulty with the union; that complainants refused to accede to such demands and insisted upon the right to conduct their business in their own way, and that the defendants, for the purpose of coercing the complainants into submitting to the demands of the union, established a picket system around complainants’ shops, enticed away their
It is not claimed that an injunction was not the proper remedy if the acts of the defendants were without lawful right, but it is argued that there was nothing unlawful, about what was done, because it was done in the course of labor competition for the promotion of welfare of union laborers. The controversies between labor unions and employers have occasionally developed some curious and unusual notions of what constitutes competition, but they have never been generally adopted and have not been approved by the courts. It is true that competition in business justifies action for the benefit of one of the competing parties which results in injury to the other, and a reason frequently given is that the general public benefits outweigh occasional individual losses. One who is seeking employment for himself may offer to work on any terms that he may choose, and the exercise of his legal right may result in the discharge of another laborer. But that rule does not apply to this case. It is not very clear what is meant by competition for the purpose of promoting the welfare of the union and its members, but it is clear that the union and its members were not in competition with the complainants in respect to labor or anything else. The members of the union had left service of the complainants, and their only purpose was to prevent the complainants from carrying on their business. They were endeavoring to compel the complainants to submit to their dictation by depriving the complainants of their legal right to .employ such laborers as they might choose. If there is a combination to injure a person because he refuses to comply with some demand where he has a legal right to refuse, there is no way
In London Guarantee and Accident Co. v. Horn, supra, the court quoted from Bowen v. Hall, 6 Q. B. D. 333, as follows: “If the persuasion be used for the indirect purpose of injuring the plaintiff or of benefiting the defendant at the expense of the plaintiff it is a malicious act, which is in law and in fact a wrong act, and therefore a wrongful act, and therefore an actionable act if injury ensues from it.” The court also there re-affirmed the doctrines of Doremus v. Hennessy by quoting therefrom, as follows: “No persons, individually or by combination, have the right to directly or indirectly interfere or disturb another in his lawful business or
In the case of O’Brein v. People, 216 Ill. 354, the court again quoted at length from Dor emus v. Hennessy, and also said: “The law is well settled that every person shall be protected in the right to enter into contracts or in refusing to do so, as he shall deem best for the advancement of his own interests, without interference by others. No person or combination of persons can legally, by direct or indirect means, obstruct or interfere with another in the conduct of his lawful business, and any attempt to compel an individual, firm or corporation to execute an agreement to conduct his or its business through certain agencies or by a particular class of employees is not only unlawful and actionable, but is an interference with the exercise of the highest civil right.”
In Purington v. Hinchliff, 219 Ill. 159, the court said: “No person or combination of persons can legally, by direct or indirect means, obstruct or interfere with another in the conduct of his lawful business, and any loss willfully caused by such interference will give the party injured a right of action for all damages sustained. All parties to a conspiracy to ruin the business of another because of his refusal to do some act against his will or judgment are liable for
The facts stated in the bill authorized an injunction to prevent carrying out the scheme of the defendants.
It is next contended that if any injunction was authorized, the injunction granted was too broad in enjoining appellants from peaceful picketing of complainants’ premises and from congregating about or near their places of business for the purpose of inducing or soliciting employees to leave the employment. It is contended that a peaceful picket line around a shop is entirely lawful. But this court has held otherwise in Franklin Union v. People, supra where endorsement was given to the doctrine of Beck v. Railway Teamsters’ Protective Union, 118 Mich. 497, by quoting therefrom, as follows: “To picket complainants’ premises in order to intercept their teamsters or persons going there to trade is unlawful. It, itself, is an act of intimidation and an unwarrantable interference with the right of free trade. The highways and public streets must be free to all for the purposes of trade, commerce and labor. The law protects the buyer, the seller, the merchant, the manufacturer and the laborer in the right to walk the streets unmolested. It is no respecter of persons, and it makes no difference, in effect, whether the picketing is done ten or ten hundred feet away.” The court also gave its approval to the decision in Vegelahn v. Guntner, 167 Mass. 92. In that case a patrol of two men in front of the plaintiff’s factory, maintained as one of the means of carrying out the defendants’ plan, was held to be an unlawful interference with the rights of the employer and the employed. The patroling or picketing of the premises was considered to have elements of intimidation, and the court decided that the motive of obtaining better wages for themselves on the part of the defendants did not justify maintaining a patrol in front of the complainant’s
Another supposed right of the defendants asserted by counsel is the exercise of the power of persuasion, and it must be conceded that argument and persuasion are lawful if not directed to the accomplishment of an illegal and unlawful purpose. The object of the defendants as set forth in the bill was illegal, and if there is a malevolent intent to produce an illegal result, and it is produced, it makes no difference whether it is accomplished by mere persuasion or by physical violences -(Curran v. Galen, 152 N. Y. 33.) An act which is naturally innocent, when done with actual malice for the purpose of injuring another, and followed by such injury, is not excused because the act might be innocent under other conditions. It would be ho excuse, in law, for a defendant to say: “It is true, I have interfered with
The principles declared by this court in the cases referred to and stated in this opinion have the support of practically all the courts of the country. Inasmuch as this court has plainly declared the law upon the subject, it would be useless to cite the very numerous decisions to the same effect. Among them are Martin v. McFall, 65 N. J. Eq. 91; Martel v. White, 185 Mass. 255; Ertz v. Produce Exchange, 79 Minn. 140; Jensen v. Cooks’ and Waiters’ Union of Seattle, 81 Pac. Rep. 1069; Loewe v. California State Federation of Labor, 139 Fed. Rep. 71; Berry v. Donovan, 188 Mass. 353; Casey v. Cincinnati Typographical Union, 45 Fed. Rep. 135; In re Debs, 158 U. S. 564.
The judgment of the Appellate Court is affirmed.
Judgment affirmed.
Dissenting Opinion
dissenting:
The repeated expression of our dissenting views in cases of this character is justified by firm conviction that the nisi prius courts in such cases brought here for review have persistently exceeded the lawful limits of their power. Under the law as it stands no one can deny that the courts have the power to interfere between employer and employee by injunction, which may issue at the suit of either in proper case. It is the duty of persons enjoined to obey the injunction so long as it continues in force, save in instances where the court has proceeded wholly without jurisdiction, and for a violation of the injunction punishment may be administered. The constitution
Changing conditions in the industrial world constantly require us to make applications of existing laws to situations not before contemplated. Such varying conditions never change the law regulating the property rights of the employer nor the personal rights of the employee, in the absence of legislative action, but such rights continue as before, and may not be, by the judicial department of the government, either increased or diminished. To us the following language from our bill of rights seems apropos: “A frequent recurrence to the fundamental principles of civil government is absolutely necessary to preserve the blessings of liberty.” It amounts to nothing to assert that laborers may organize for the purpose of bettering their condition in life while denying to them the right to do anything as an organization except those acts which could be as well done without organization.
We regard the decree of the’ court below as going a step farther than is warranted even by the latest precedents. Appellants sought to have the period of labor for compositors in
Mere persuasion or like orderly inducement used by one laborer to lead another to quit the common employment, in order that the employer may be compelled to pay a higher wage or make the conditions of employment less irksome, is not unlawful. 18 Am. & Eng. Ency. of Law, (2d ed.) p. 86; A. S. & W. Co. v. W. D. Union, 90 Fed. Rep. 608; C. S. Manf. Co. v. G. B. Ass. 59 N. J. Eq. 49; Krebs v. Rosenstein, 66 N. Y. Sup. 42; Rogers v. Evarts, 17 id. 264; People v. Kostka, 4 N. Y. Crim. 429; Master B. Ass. v. Damascio, 63 Pac. Rep. 782; Reynolds v. Everett, 144 N. Y. 189; Arthur v. Oakes, 63 Fed. Rep. 310; United States v. Kane, 23 id. 748; Union Pacific Railway Co. v. Reuf, 120 id. 102; Allis-Chalmers Co. v. Lodge, 111 id. 264; Levy v. Rosenstein, 66 N. Y. Sup. 101; Beaton v. Tarrant, 102 Ill. App. 124.
In London Guarantee Co. v. Horn, 206 Ill. 493, we held that it is a violation of legal right to interfere with contractual relations recognized by law if there be no sufficient justification for the interference, and that competition in trade, employment or business is to be regarded as a sufficient justification for such interference. While every conflict of temporal interest cannot be regarded as competition, yet in the present instance the purpose of appellants was to secure for themselves or members of their union employment from the appellees and to exclude other persons” from that employment. The competition was, in fact, between union and non-union workmen. The primary purpose of. the appellants was, not to injure appellees, but to secure to themselves, under more favorable conditions, employment in the shops of appellees and to exclude others therefrom.
In London Guarantee Co. v. Horn, supra, the fact that the law as there stated is not applicable to that phase of the present case which we are now considering was pointed out in these words: “If the only object of appellant had been to secure appellee’s discharge for the purpose of obtaining .his position for another, or for the reason that the employment of appellee by Arnold, Schwinn & Co. in some way conflicted with the right of appellant, or some organization to which it belonged, to obtain the same or similar employment, a very different question, and one not now before this court, would be presented, and Allen v. Flood, 67 L. J. Q. B. 119, and other cases of that character cited by the appellant, would then be worthy of greater consideration.”
In our judgment competition such as here existed afforded sufficient justification for the use of persuasion, or other like peaceable method by appellants, to induce employees of appellees to leave their work, in order that better conditions for labor might be brought about in the shops of appellees.
We conclude that the decree herein should not be affirmed.