620 B.R. 456
S.D.N.Y.2020Background:
- The Zohar Funds (three CLO special-purpose vehicles created by Lynn Tilton) sued Patriarch Parties in SDNY in 2017 alleging widespread misconduct; Patriarch filed counterclaims and third‑party claims.
- This Court dismissed Zohar’s RICO claim and declined supplemental jurisdiction over remaining claims in a prior decision.
- Zohar III filed Chapter 11 in the Delaware Bankruptcy Court on March 11, 2018; the parties entered a settlement that expired September 30, 2019.
- After the settlement lapsed, an equitable‑subordination complaint was filed in the Delaware Bankruptcy Court; Zohar moved to transfer the SDNY action to the District of Delaware (for referral to the Delaware Bankruptcy Court) under 28 U.S.C. § 1412 or § 1404(a).
- Third‑party defendants joined the transfer motion; Patriarch Parties opposed. The SDNY Court analyzed whether § 1412 applies (i.e., whether the action arises under Title 11) and, if not, whether transfer under § 1404(a) is warranted.
- Holding: The Court ruled the action does not “arise under” Title 11 so § 1412 was inapplicable, and denied transfer under § 1404(a) because Zohar failed to meet the clear‑and‑convincing showing required for transfer.
Issues:
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether § 1412 authorizes transfer (i.e., whether the action "arises under" Title 11) | Zohar: The SDNY action is core/closely tied to the bankruptcy because claims overlap with the Delaware subordination complaint and affect estate administration. | Patriarch: Claims are common‑law contract/tort claims predating the bankruptcy and do not arise under Title 11. | Held: § 1412 is limited to matters that arise under Title 11; this action does not, so § 1412 does not authorize transfer. |
| Whether the Patriarch Parties’ claims are "core" under § 157(b) | Zohar: Factual and legal overlap, declaratory/ownership claims over portfolio entities (estate property), and potential impact on creditor priorities make the case core. | Patriarch: Claims predate the bankruptcy, are ordinary contract/tort claims, and many parties are outside the bankruptcy estate. | Held: Claims are not core; prepetition contract/tort nature and lack of dependence on bankruptcy law weigh against core status. |
| Whether Delaware had venue and personal jurisdiction such that transfer under § 1404(a) would be possible | Zohar: Delaware bankruptcy presence and Delaware incorporation of entities support venue; Tilton’s Delaware contacts suffice for personal jurisdiction. | Patriarch: Tilton would not be subject to Delaware personal jurisdiction; venue improper. | Held: Delaware district could have heard the case (venue and jurisdiction could be established), so § 1404(a) transfer was procedurally possible. |
| Whether transfer under § 1404(a) is warranted (convenience and interest of justice) | Zohar: Centralizing related proceedings in Delaware Bankruptcy promotes efficiency and convenience. | Patriarch: Forum‑selection clauses, majority of operative facts and witnesses in New York, and most parties located in NY favor keeping case in SDNY. | Held: Zohar failed to meet the clear‑and‑convincing burden; forum‑selection clauses, plaintiff’s prior selection, locus of operative facts, and party convenience weigh against transfer. |
Key Cases Cited
- Zohar CDO 2003-1, Ltd. v. Patriarch Partners, LLC, 286 F. Supp. 3d 634 (S.D.N.Y. 2017) (prior SDNY decision dismissing RICO claim and addressing related issues)
- N.Y. Marine & Gen. Ins. Co. v. Lafarge N. Am., Inc., 599 F.3d 102 (2d Cir. 2010) (movant under § 1404(a) must meet a clear‑and‑convincing standard)
- In re Manville Forest Prod. Corp., 896 F.2d 1384 (2d Cir. 1990) (presumption that venue is proper in district where bankruptcy pending for transfer under bankruptcy rules)
- In re U.S. Lines, Inc., 197 F.3d 631 (2d Cir. 1999) (core proceedings should be construed broadly but within constitutional limits)
- In re Orion Pictures Corp., 4 F.3d 1095 (2d Cir. 1993) (impact on estate alone does not convert ordinary contract claims into core bankruptcy matters)
- In re CBI Holding Co., Inc., 529 F.3d 432 (2d Cir. 2008) (contract/tort claims can be core when they respond to a proof of claim; distinguishing factor was filing in response to a proof of claim)
- Atl. Marine Constr. Co. v. U.S. Dist. Court for W. Dist. of Texas, 571 U.S. 49 (2013) (forum‑selection clauses are entitled to controlling weight in § 1404(a) analysis absent exceptional circumstances)
- Parmalat Capital Fin. Ltd. v. Bank of Am. Corp., 639 F.3d 572 (2d Cir. 2011) (defining the scope of "related to" bankruptcy jurisdiction and its conceivable effect test)