830 N.W.2d 488
Neb.2013Background
- Skavdahl Land LLC sues owners of severed mineral interests to reacquire allegedly abandoned interests under Nebraska's dormant mineral statutes.
- Record owner for purposes of §57-229 may be determined from more than the county register of deeds, including public records; the issue is whether probate/public records can identify the record owner.
- Sandra Elliott, personal representative of Evelyn Elliott's estate, died in 1999; Evelyn's probate records had not listed mineral interests.
- The register of deeds listed Evelyn as owner; Evelyn's will devised property to cotrustees of the S&G Living Trust, of which Sandra was the last surviving trustee.
- The district court held Evelyn was the record owner and that Sandra, as trustee, did not publicly exercise ownership; it concluded ownership transferred by operation of law, not by Evelyn’s action.
- On appeal, the key question is whether the record owner under §57-229 includes individuals identified by probate records in the county where the interests are located.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the record owner includes probate records. | Skavdahl argues record owner includes probate records identifying owners. | Elliott argues record owner is the person listed in the register of deeds. | Yes; the record owner includes probate records identifying the owner. |
Key Cases Cited
- Gibbs Cattle Co. v. Bixler, Ante p. 952, N.W.2d (2013) (Nebraska 2013) (defines record owner scope for dormant minerals governing)
