midpage
951 N.W.2d 187
N.D.
2020

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Oden was injured in Missouri in May 2010; WSI originally awarded ND workers’ compensation benefits but later suspended benefits after Oden pursued a Missouri claim.
  • In Feb 2016 Oden settled his Missouri claim for $30,000; in March 2016 WSI reversed its award and demanded reimbursement of $62,452.91 under N.D.C.C. § 65‑05‑05.
  • WSI mailed a March 2016 Notice of Decision (stating a 30‑day right to request reconsideration); Oden did not file reconsideration personally or through a North Dakota‑licensed attorney.
  • WSI sued Oden in July 2018 to recover the overpayment; process was served in Missouri on Oden’s adult daughter at a Raymore address that Oden says he subleased.
  • The district court denied Oden’s Rule 12(b)(5) motion to dismiss for insufficient service (finding WSI made a prima facie showing and Oden failed to rebut) and granted WSI summary judgment; Oden appealed.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument (WSI) Defendant's Argument (Oden) Held
Sufficiency of service of process Return and process‑server affidavit show service at defendant’s usual abode; prima facie valid Service was on daughter at a residence Oden subleased and did not occupy; server’s affidavit equivocal Denial of dismissal affirmed — WSI made prima facie showing; Oden failed to rebut; no abuse in denying further discovery
Finality for failure to seek reconsideration WSI mailed notice by regular mail; no timely ND‑licensed counsel requested reconsideration; decision became final and is enforceable Oden didn’t receive notice or Missouri counsel’s response sufficed as reconsideration SJ for WSI affirmed — presumption of mail delivery not rebutted; out‑of‑state counsel’s request inadequate under Carlson
Accord and satisfaction (Missouri settlement binding WSI) WSI not a party to Missouri stipulation; no evidence WSI authorized counsel to bind it Settlement names an insurer and attorney; constitutes accord and satisfaction extinguishing WSI’s claim Denied — no genuine issue: no proof of agency/ostensible authority; WSI not bound by Missouri settlement
Judicial notice / Full Faith & Credit of later Missouri judgment N/A (WSI opposed) Oden asked court to take judicial notice of a 2019 Missouri judgment entered after district decision and assert preclusive effect Request denied — Court refused to take mandatory judicial notice of subsequent judgment on appeal

Key Cases Cited

  • Monster Heavy Haulers, LLC v. Goliath Energy Servs., LLC, 883 N.W.2d 917 (N.D. 2016) (returns of service create prima facie evidence for jurisdiction/service)
  • Franciere v. City of Mandan, 945 N.W.2d 251 (N.D. 2020) (standard for reviewing personal jurisdiction and prima facie burden on plaintiff)
  • Blair v. City of Worcester, 522 F.3d 105 (1st Cir. 2008) (district court abused discretion by denying discovery/evidentiary hearing where agency for service was plausibly shown)
  • Messier v. Bushman, 197 A.3d 882 (Vt. 2018) (where affidavits conflict on service, an evidentiary hearing is preferable)
  • Carlson v. Workforce Safety & Ins., 765 N.W.2d 69 (N.D. 2009) (requests for reconsideration by nonresident attorneys who fail pro hac vice requirements are void)
  • Plains Trucking, LLC v. Cresap, 932 N.W.2d 541 (N.D. 2019) (administrative decisions become final if statutory remedies are not timely pursued)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: WSI v. Oden
Court Name: North Dakota Supreme Court
Date Published: Nov 19, 2020
Citations: 951 N.W.2d 187; 2020 ND 243; 20190242
Docket Number: 20190242
Court Abbreviation: N.D.
Log In