661 F. App'x 750
2d Cir.2016Background
- Plaintiff Alvin Wilson, a pro se prisoner, sued Corrections Officer Brooke McKenna under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 for deliberate indifference to medical needs based on an alleged September 16, 2012 incident.
- The Connecticut DOC grievance procedure (AD 9.6) requires informal resolution, an Inmate Request Form, then a timely Level 1 grievance (with the Request Form attached or explanation why not) and permits correction if a form is returned without disposition.
- Wilson submitted an Inmate Administrative Remedy Form on September 20, 2012 checked as a "Grievance" but was treated as a Health Services Review and denied; he submitted other forms mentioning medical care and, later, the guard, but did not file a timely Level 1 grievance against McKenna.
- The district court granted summary judgment for McKenna, concluding Wilson failed to properly exhaust administrative remedies under the PLRA; the court also found some of Wilson’s later forms were not received by DOC.
- On appeal, Wilson did not challenge the exhaustion ruling; the Second Circuit reviewed de novo and affirmed, holding Wilson failed to demonstrate proper exhaustion and abandoning any appellate challenge to exhaustion.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Wilson exhausted administrative remedies under the PLRA | Wilson argued he used the DOC forms and pursued appeals; grievance process was effectively used | McKenna argued Wilson failed to file a timely Level 1 grievance and did not comply with AD 9.6 procedural requirements | Court held Wilson failed to properly exhaust; summary judgment for McKenna affirmed |
| Whether the grievance process was "available" to Wilson | (not raised on appeal) Wilson could argue misclassification of his form made process unavailable | McKenna/ DOC maintained the process was available and properly applied | Court declined to consider availability because Wilson did not raise it below or on appeal |
| Whether summary judgment standard was correctly applied | Wilson disputed factual record and/or receipt of forms | McKenna argued no genuine dispute of material fact on exhaustion | Court applied de novo review of summary judgment and found exhaustion failure as a matter of law |
| Whether premature appeals or returned forms excuse exhaustion | Wilson implied his appeals and filings should suffice despite timing/errors | McKenna argued premature appeals and failure to refile after return do not satisfy PLRA | Court held premature appeals and failure to file a timely Level 1 grievance do not satisfy PLRA exhaustion requirements |
Key Cases Cited
- LoSacco v. City of Middletown, 71 F.3d 88 (2d Cir. 1995) (failure to brief an issue on appeal constitutes abandonment)
- Garcia v. Hartford Police Dep’t, 706 F.3d 120 (2d Cir. 2013) (standard of review for summary judgment)
- Woodford v. Ngo, 548 U.S. 81 (2006) (PLRA requires "proper exhaustion" complying with an agency's procedural rules)
- Ross v. Blake, 136 S. Ct. 1850 (2016) (administrative remedies must be "available"; outlines categories of unavailability)
- Williams v. Priatno, 829 F.3d 118 (2d Cir. 2016) (applying Ross to identify when grievance procedures are unavailable)
- Guzman v. Local 32B-32J, Serv. Emps. Int’l Union, 151 F.3d 86 (2d Cir. 1998) (principle that appellate courts generally do not consider issues not raised below)