Slip Opinion
N.D.N.Y.2018Background
- Frederick Velez, an inmate at Oneida Correctional Facility, was stabbed by fellow inmate Jose Rodriguez on April 24–25, 2009 and later died; Rodriguez allegedly had a known history of violence and access to a homemade shank.
- Plaintiffs (estate administratrix and family members) allege DOCCS officials and corrections officers were deliberately indifferent: failed to separate Rodriguez, failed to supervise/perform rounds, failed to disarm or intervene, and maintained policies/practices that permitted violence and weapons.
- Second Amended Complaint asserts nine § 1983 counts: Counts 1–3 (estate) allege Eighth Amendment failure-to-protect/failure-to-intervene and supervisory liability; Counts 4–9 (mother and children) plead Fourteenth Amendment claims for loss of intimate association and related supervisory/failure-to-intervene theories.
- Defendants moved to dismiss under Rule 12(b)(6), arguing (among other things) claims are pleaded in conclusory/shotgun fashion, fail to show personal involvement of specific defendants, and family members lack a cognizable Fourteenth Amendment claim here.
- The Court denied dismissal as to the estate’s Eighth Amendment claims (both guards and supervisors) as plausibly pleaded, but dismissed family members’ Fourteenth Amendment intimate-association claims and any substantive due-process theory subsumed by the Eighth Amendment.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the complaint plausibly states an Eighth Amendment failure-to-protect / failure-to-intervene claim on behalf of the estate | Velez faced a known, substantial risk from Rodriguez; guards observed prolonged threats/assaults and did nothing | Allegations are conclusory and do not tie particular defendants to the misconduct | Denied as to estate: factual allegations (knowledge of risk, visible/ongoing threats, inaction) are sufficient at pleading stage to state plausible Eighth Amendment claims against guards and supervisors |
| Whether supervisory defendants may be liable under § 1983 for policies/practices leading to Velez’s death | Supervisors created/ratified policies allowing violent inmates to be housed in dorms, failed to staff/train/search, and acquiesced in unsafe practices | Allegations are generalized, conclusory, and fail to show personal involvement in specific policies or failures | Denied: complaint sufficiently alleges supervisory personal involvement via allegations about policies/practices, ratification, and failures to act to make a § 1983 claim plausible |
| Whether individual corrections officers were plausibly alleged to have personal involvement in the failure to intervene | Officers were on G-Dorm, witnessed/should have witnessed prolonged fighting/threats, failed to make rounds or intercede | Pleading is shotgun/speculative as to individual officers; lacks specificity | Denied: allegations that specified officers were present, failed to make rounds, and did not intervene are sufficient at this stage to allege deliberate indifference |
| Whether non-inmate family members may assert Fourteenth Amendment claims for loss of intimate association | Family members lost companionship because defendants’ conduct led to Velez’s death and thereby deprived them of intimate association | No constitutional claim: interference was not directed at familial relationships; injuries are collateral to the decedent’s Eighth Amendment injury | Granted: family members’ Fourteenth Amendment associational claims (Counts 4–9) are dismissed because the complained-of conduct was not aimed at disrupting family relationships and the harms are collateral |
Key Cases Cited
- Blyden v. Mancusi, 186 F.3d 252 (2d Cir.) (deliberate indifference standard for prisoner safety)
- Helling v. McKinney, 509 U.S. 25 (Sup. Ct.) (state’s duty to inmate safety once in custody)
- Farmer v. Brennan, 511 U.S. 825 (Sup. Ct.) (deliberate indifference requires knowledge of substantial risk)
- Morales v. New York State Dep’t of Corrections, 842 F.2d 27 (2d Cir.) (failure-to-intervene may support § 1983 liability)
- Hayes v. New York City Dep’t of Corrections, 84 F.3d 614 (2d Cir.) (Eighth Amendment requires reasonable measures to guarantee inmate safety)
- Iqbal v. Ashcroft, 556 U.S. 662 (Sup. Ct.) (pleading standard; courts disregard conclusory allegations)
- Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (Sup. Ct.) (plausibility pleading standard)
- Patel v. Searles, 305 F.3d 130 (2d Cir.) (familial association protected in some circumstances)
- Lee v. City of Los Angeles, 250 F.3d 668 (9th Cir.) (case recognizing associational claim where governmental acts directly impaired family relationship)
- Pizzuto v. County of Nassau, 240 F. Supp. 2d 203 (E.D.N.Y.) (declining Fourteenth Amendment associational claim where interference was collateral to injury of decedent)