William S Jenks v. Department of Treasury
332787
| Mich. Ct. App. | Jun 15, 2017Background
- William S. Jenks was assessed personally under MCL 205.27a for unpaid withholding taxes of Jenks Plumbing and Heating Inc.; liens issued for over $70,000.
- Statutory appeal windows existed: 35 days to the Michigan Tax Tribunal (then), 90 days to the Court of Claims under MCL 205.22. Jenks did not file within those windows.
- Jenks paid divisible portions of 16 withholding assessments and filed a refund claim under MCL 205.30 asserting the taxes were “unjustly assessed.”
- The Department of Treasury denied the refund, treating the claim as a collateral attack on final assessments barred by MCL 205.22(4)–(5).
- Jenks appealed to the Michigan Tax Tribunal; the Tribunal granted summary disposition for the Department under MCR 2.116(C)(4), (7), and (10).
Issues
| Issue | Jenks’s Argument | Department’s Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether a refund claim under MCL 205.30 may be used to challenge a final assessment after MCL 205.22 appeal deadlines have passed | Jenks: Paying a divisible portion and filing a refund claim allows him to contest that the assessment was "unjustly assessed" despite missed appeal deadlines | Dept: MCL 205.22(4)–(5) makes unappealed assessments final and bars collateral attacks, so a refund claim that attacks a final assessment is barred | Court: Affirmed—refund claim that collaterally attacks a conclusive assessment is barred by MCL 205.22(4)–(5) |
Key Cases Cited
- Meijer, Inc v. City of Midland, 240 Mich. App. 1 (appellate review limited to legal error; factual findings upheld if supported by substantial evidence)
- Peters v. Department of Corrections, 215 Mich. App. 485 (de novo review of summary disposition)
- PIC Maint, Inc. v. Dep’t of Treasury, 293 Mich. App. 403 (statutory interpretation reviewed de novo)
- People v. Peltola, 489 Mich. 174 (Legislature’s plain statutory language controls)
- Ross v. Modern Mirror & Glass Co., 268 Mich. App. 558 (court must enforce plain meaning of statute)
