midpage
19 A.3d 393
Md.
2011

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Faust, Weichert's Vice President and Bethesda office manager, signed a Manager's Employment Agreement with a non-solicitation clause in Paragraph 22 and a mutual fee-shifting provision in Subsection H.
  • Weichert sued Faust for breach of loyalty and for violation of the non-solicitation clause; Faust counterclaimed MWPL-related damages.
  • Jury found Faust breached the duty of loyalty but did not breach the non-solicitation clause; damages awarded to Weichert for the loyalty breach and to Faust under MWPL for Weichert's violation.
  • Circuit Court awarded Faust attorney's fees under Paragraph 22(H); Court of Special Appeals affirmed; Weichert challenged on appeal to the Maryland Court of Appeals.
  • Key issues: whether loyalty breach forfeits fee rights, whether the fee shift covers the entire contract or only Paragraph 22, and whether Faust incurred the fees personally.
  • Court of Appeals ultimately affirms that Faust is entitled to fees under the non-solicitation fee provision; Faust’s loyalty breach did not forfeit that right.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Does breach of loyalty forfeit fee rights? Faust breached loyalty; forfeit not automatic. Weichert argues breach forfeits fees. No forfeiture; loyalty breach not automatically eliminating fees.
Scope of the fee-shifting provision Hereunder covers entire contract. Hereunder applies only to Paragraph 22 non-solicitation. Hereunder is limited to Paragraph 22; fees awarded for non-solicitation action.
Did Faust incur the fees personally or via indemnification? Indemnification by Long & Foster means no personal incurrence. Incurring can occur on her behalf; no personal payment required. Faust incurred fees on her behalf; she is entitled to recovery.

Key Cases Cited

  • Nova Research, Inc. v. Penske Truck Leasing Co., L.P., 405 Md. 435, 952 A.2d 275 (2008) (Md. 2008) (contract interpretation and de novo review; objective interpretation of unambiguous terms)
  • Tomran, Inc. v. Passano, 391 Md. 1, 891 A.2d 336 (2006) (Md. 2006) (hereunder refers to rights within the document; limits application to specific rights)
  • Regal Savings Bank v. Sachs, 352 Md. 356, 722 A.2d 377 (1999) (Md. 1999) (breach of duty may be material or not; not every breach extinguishes all obligations)
  • Maryland Credit v. Hagerty, 216 Md. 83, 139 A.2d 230 (1958) (Md. 1958) (loyalty treated as a material duty; disloyalty can forfeit contracted compensation)
  • Chai Management v. Leibowitz, 50 Md.App. 504, 439 A.2d 34 (1982) (Md. Ct. App. 1982) (material breach evidence; limitations when seeking to enforce non-breaching party's rights)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Weichert Co. v. Faust
Court Name: Court of Appeals of Maryland
Date Published: Apr 27, 2011
Citations: 19 A.3d 393; 419 Md. 306; 32 I.E.R. Cas. (BNA) 808; 2011 Md. LEXIS 225; 43, September Term, 2010
Docket Number: 43, September Term, 2010
Court Abbreviation: Md.
Log In