Varner-Mort, D. v. Kapfhammer, B.
109 A.3d 244
Pa. Super. Ct.2015Background
- May 6, 2009 car crash involving Varner-Mort and Kapfhammer.
- June 27, 2011, Varner-Mort and Mort sue Kapfhammer for negligence and loss of consortium.
- Appellants chose limited tort under MVFRL; non-economic damages require a serious injury.
- Kapfhammer argues two-year statute of limitations under 42 Pa.C.S. § 5524(2) bars the action.
- Trial court granted summary judgment relying on records showing a May 9, 2009 treatment epoch.
- Appellants argued Walls v. Scheckler dictates a discovery rule for when a serious injury is known or should be known; trial court denied; judgment entered against Appellants; appellate court reverses and remands.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| When does the two-year period begin for limited-tort MVFRL actions? | Discovery of serious injury delays accrual (Walls rule). | Accrual starts at accident under standard rule. | Genuine issue of material fact remains; summary judgment improper. |
| Does the Bailey affidavit establish a definite discovery timeline for serious impairment? | Affidavit supports later discovery date (June 8, 2010). | Record shows earlier notice; not dispositive; jury should resolve. | Fact issue for determination by factfinder; cannot decide on summary judgment. |
Key Cases Cited
- Walls v. Scheckler, 700 A.2d 532 (Pa. Super. 1997) (discovery rule for when a limited-tort plaintiff learns of a serious injury)
- Haines v. Jones, 830 A.2d 579 (Pa. Super. 2003) (discusses general accrual timing in car accident cases)
- Gleason v. Borough of Moosic, 609 Pa. 353, 15 A.3d 479 (Pa. 2011) (fact-intensive inquiry on when awareness of injury arises)
- Walls v. Scheckler, 700 A.2d 532 (Pa. Super. 1997) (long-form discussion of discovery-based accrual under MVFRL)
- Borough of Moosic, 15 A.3d 485 (Pa. 2011) (recognizes factual questions on discovery timing for serious injury)
- Swords v. Harleysville Ins. Companies, 584 Pa. 382, 883 A.2d 562 (Pa. 2005) (summary judgment standards and standard of review)
