300 Ga. 442
Ga.2017Background
- On December 7, 1996, Joanne Walton was shot in the head; her body was found roadside that night. The killing remained a cold case until reopened in 2007.
- Jerome Upshaw was indicted in 2011 and tried in 2012 for malice murder, felony murder, and unlawful possession of a firearm during the commission of a felony; one firearms charge was nolle prossed prior to trial.
- Evidence at trial placed Upshaw in the car with Walton and two others; Upshaw allegedly exited the vehicle, shot Walton with a .38 revolver, hid the gun at his mother’s house, and threatened a witness. The recovered revolver was later traced to Upshaw.
- The jury convicted Upshaw of malice murder and unlawful possession during the commission of a felony; the trial court also (erroneously) sentenced him for felony murder and merged aggravated assault into felony murder rather than malice murder.
- Posttrial, Upshaw moved for a new trial raising: (1) limits on cross-examination of a State witness (Franks); (2) denial of mistrial after witness Mark Price refused to testify; and (3) allowing the lead detective to remain in the courtroom. The trial court denied relief and the convictions were appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Upshaw's Argument | State's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether trial court erred in limiting cross-examination of State witness Franks about facts underlying his prior aggravated-assault conviction | Upshaw argued he should impeach Franks by probing facts of the prior offense | State argued specifics were irrelevant because Franks did not attempt to rehabilitate or explain the conviction | Court held exclusion was proper; specific facts irrelevant absent rehabilitative testimony |
| Whether denial of mistrial after Mark Price refused to answer on cross violated Confrontation Clause | Upshaw argued refusal prevented confrontation of testimony referenced by State and prejudiced defense | State argued curative measures (jury instruction/offer to strike) remedied any harm and Price’s limited testimony favored Upshaw | Court held no Sixth Amendment violation; curative instruction and offer to strike were adequate; mistrial not required |
| Whether trial court erred by excepting lead detective from sequestration rule | Upshaw argued exception was improper and prejudicial | State argued exception was necessary for orderly presentation given case complexity and detective’s role | Court held exception was within trial court’s discretion and permissible |
| Whether conviction and sentence for both malice murder and felony murder were permissible | Upshaw argued he could not be punished for both where only one killing occurred | State convicted on both theories at trial | Court held sentencing for both was erroneous; felony murder conviction/victim merged and vacated as surplusage (malice murder remains) |
Key Cases Cited
- Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307 (establishes legal-sufficiency standard for evidence)
- Hendrix v. State, 298 Ga. 60 (vacating redundant homicide convictions as surplusage)
- Malcolm v. State, 263 Ga. 369 (aggravated assault merges with malice murder when based on single shooting)
- Brown v. State, 276 Ga. 192 (prior-conviction details irrelevant on cross unless witness attempts rehabilitation)
- Soto v. State, 285 Ga. 367 (remedy for witness refusing to answer: striking testimony on same subject matter)
- Miller v. State, 289 Ga. 854 (trial court discretion: mistrial vs curative instruction)
- Moore v. State, 297 Ga. 773 (permitting investigator to remain for orderly presentation is within discretion)