United States v. Powell
2:18-cr-00111
| E.D. Wis. | Apr 24, 2024Background
- In 2019, Antonio Jamerson pled guilty to armed robbery and use of a firearm in relation to a crime of violence, resulting in a 124-month prison sentence (40 months for robbery, 84 months mandatory for firearm offense).
- Probation calculated his offense level at 22 with a Criminal History Category III, making him eligible for guideline ranges of 51-63 months (armed robbery) and a consecutive 84-month minimum (firearm count).
- Amendment 821 to the Sentencing Guidelines, effective November 1, 2023, retroactively reduces some offenders' "status points" in criminal history calculations, potentially lowering sentencing ranges.
- Jamerson moved for a sentence reduction and appointment of counsel under Amendment 821, claiming applicability due to his criminal history status points.
- The court denied both the motions for sentence reduction and appointment of counsel in April 2024, finding statutory limitations and the facts of Jamerson's case precluded relief.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Applicability of Amendment 821 to Jamerson | Government: Sentence not lowered by amendment due to mandatory minimum and original sentence structure | Jamerson: Status point reduction should lower his sentence under new guidelines | Court held Amendment 821 does not lower his guideline range because of mandatory minimum and original sentence below minimum of amended range |
| Eligibility for sentence reduction | Not eligible due to mandatory minimum | Eligible since he received status points | Not eligible due to statutory mandatory minimum and original sentence structure |
| Appointment of counsel for resentencing | Moot issue due to merits outcome | Sought counsel for resentencing process | Denied as moot, given denial of sentence reduction |
| Application of § 3553(a) factors | Reduction not warranted | Sought leniency under §3553(a) | Even if eligible, reduction not warranted by §3553(a) factors |
Key Cases Cited
None cited with official reporter citations.
