midpage
675 F. App'x 40
2d Cir.
2017
Read the full case

Background

  • Plaintiff-appellant Aaron Tyk (pro se) sued NYPD Officer Eric Surat and the City under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (malicious prosecution, selective enforcement under Equal Protection, and excessive force) and asserted related state-law claims.
  • Surat arrested Tyk at a hospital, issued a desk appearance ticket (DAT), and reported interviews with three hospital security staff (one had red marks on his nose); security reported repeated requests that Tyk leave the premises.
  • Tyk was prosecuted but the criminal proceeding terminated in his favor; he later sued in federal court.
  • The district court granted summary judgment for defendants; Tyk appealed.
  • The Second Circuit reviewed the grant of summary judgment de novo and affirmed, finding no genuine disputes of material fact supporting Tyk’s federal or state claims.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Malicious prosecution (§ 1983) Surat initiated prosecution via arrest/DAT but lacked probable cause and acted maliciously Surat had probable cause based on victim/eyewitness accounts and security reports Dismissed: Surat issued DAT (initiated prosecution) but had probable cause; no malicious-prosecution claim survives
Selective enforcement (Equal Protection) Tyk was singled out and prevented from filing cross-criminal complaints; suggests discriminatory motive (mentions "orthodoxy") No evidence of discrimination on protected grounds; no constitutional right to compel prosecution Dismissed: No similarly situated comparator or impermissible motive shown; religious bias not raised below
Excessive force (Fourth Amendment) Tyk says force used in handcuffing caused injury Surat’s force was reasonable for arrest; excluded medical report left no admissible proof of injury Dismissed: No admissible evidence of more-than-reasonable force or injury
Municipal liability / State notice-of-claim City liable if underlying constitutional wrong established; state claims timely or not prejudicial No underlying constitutional violation; plaintiff failed to file a timely notice of claim or seek leave to file late notice Dismissed: § 1983 municipal claims fail absent underlying violation; state claims barred for failure to timely file notice of claim

Key Cases Cited

  • Rohman v. New York City Transit Auth., 215 F.3d 208 (2d Cir.) (elements of malicious prosecution under § 1983)
  • Stampf v. Long Island R.R., 761 F.3d 192 (2d Cir.) (issuing a DAT initiates a prosecution)
  • Ricciuti v. New York City Transit Auth., 124 F.3d 123 (2d Cir.) (officer need not eliminate every theoretical innocence once probable cause exists)
  • Martinez v. Simonetti, 202 F.3d 625 (2d Cir.) (information from victim/eyewitness can supply probable cause)
  • Freedom Holdings, Inc. v. Spitzer, 357 F.3d 205 (2d Cir.) (elements required for selective enforcement/equal protection claim)
  • Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (U.S.) (objective-reasonableness standard for excessive-force claims)
  • Segal v. City of New York, 459 F.3d 207 (2d Cir.) (municipal liability under § 1983 depends on underlying constitutional violation)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: Tyk v. Surat
Court Name: Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
Date Published: Jan 12, 2017
Citations: 675 F. App'x 40; 2017 WL 129145; 15-3813-cv
Docket Number: 15-3813-cv
Court Abbreviation: 2d Cir.
Log In