675 F. App'x 40
2d Cir.2017Background
- Plaintiff-appellant Aaron Tyk (pro se) sued NYPD Officer Eric Surat and the City under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 (malicious prosecution, selective enforcement under Equal Protection, and excessive force) and asserted related state-law claims.
- Surat arrested Tyk at a hospital, issued a desk appearance ticket (DAT), and reported interviews with three hospital security staff (one had red marks on his nose); security reported repeated requests that Tyk leave the premises.
- Tyk was prosecuted but the criminal proceeding terminated in his favor; he later sued in federal court.
- The district court granted summary judgment for defendants; Tyk appealed.
- The Second Circuit reviewed the grant of summary judgment de novo and affirmed, finding no genuine disputes of material fact supporting Tyk’s federal or state claims.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Malicious prosecution (§ 1983) | Surat initiated prosecution via arrest/DAT but lacked probable cause and acted maliciously | Surat had probable cause based on victim/eyewitness accounts and security reports | Dismissed: Surat issued DAT (initiated prosecution) but had probable cause; no malicious-prosecution claim survives |
| Selective enforcement (Equal Protection) | Tyk was singled out and prevented from filing cross-criminal complaints; suggests discriminatory motive (mentions "orthodoxy") | No evidence of discrimination on protected grounds; no constitutional right to compel prosecution | Dismissed: No similarly situated comparator or impermissible motive shown; religious bias not raised below |
| Excessive force (Fourth Amendment) | Tyk says force used in handcuffing caused injury | Surat’s force was reasonable for arrest; excluded medical report left no admissible proof of injury | Dismissed: No admissible evidence of more-than-reasonable force or injury |
| Municipal liability / State notice-of-claim | City liable if underlying constitutional wrong established; state claims timely or not prejudicial | No underlying constitutional violation; plaintiff failed to file a timely notice of claim or seek leave to file late notice | Dismissed: § 1983 municipal claims fail absent underlying violation; state claims barred for failure to timely file notice of claim |
Key Cases Cited
- Rohman v. New York City Transit Auth., 215 F.3d 208 (2d Cir.) (elements of malicious prosecution under § 1983)
- Stampf v. Long Island R.R., 761 F.3d 192 (2d Cir.) (issuing a DAT initiates a prosecution)
- Ricciuti v. New York City Transit Auth., 124 F.3d 123 (2d Cir.) (officer need not eliminate every theoretical innocence once probable cause exists)
- Martinez v. Simonetti, 202 F.3d 625 (2d Cir.) (information from victim/eyewitness can supply probable cause)
- Freedom Holdings, Inc. v. Spitzer, 357 F.3d 205 (2d Cir.) (elements required for selective enforcement/equal protection claim)
- Graham v. Connor, 490 U.S. 386 (U.S.) (objective-reasonableness standard for excessive-force claims)
- Segal v. City of New York, 459 F.3d 207 (2d Cir.) (municipal liability under § 1983 depends on underlying constitutional violation)