Town & Country Hospital, LP v. Reginald Davis
64 Va. App. 658
| Va. Ct. App. | 2015Background
- claimant Reginald Davis sustained a compensable right knee injury in Nov 2011 and medical benefits were awarded against the employer and insurer.
- In Feb 2013, while pending, Davis underwent right total knee arthroplasty revision at a Tampa, FL hospital; the hospital billed $119,496.33; an agreed order authorized the surgery and insurer paid $80,217.45.
- On Sept 5, 2013, Davis’s attorney sought attorney’s fees under Code § 65.2-714 for services related to the medical treatment.
- The deputy commissioner granted the fee on Nov 26, 2013; Davis’s employer/insurer objected in Jan 2014 asserting lack of jurisdiction and due process concerns.
- Appellant argued the commission lacked jurisdiction because it is located in Florida; the issue later centered on whether accepting payment of medical bills constituted consent to the commission’s jurisdiction.
- The full commission held the request for review was untimely but found the commission had jurisdiction to award fees because accepting payment consents to jurisdiction; the appeal followed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Timeliness of review request | Davis’s objection timely under Rule 3.1 and § 65.2-705. | Appellant’s request was untimely; no jurisdiction absent fraud/mistake. | Untimely; no jurisdiction to review absent fraud or mistake. |
| Jurisdiction to award attorney’s fees | Appellant allegedly consented to jurisdiction by accepting payment. | No consent; Florida address rendered lack of notice an issue. | Appellant consented by accepting payment; Commission had jurisdiction to award fees. |
| Due process concerns and notice | Notice defects violated due process. | No improper notice; documents were not undeliverable and evidence supported review. | No due process violation; notice adequate for review as to jurisdiction. |
Key Cases Cited
- McCarthy Electric Co., Inc. v. Foster, 17 Va. App. 344 (1993) (timeliness and jurisdiction for review when 30-day period expired)
