midpage
331 Ga. App. 139
Ga. Ct. App.
2015
Read the full case

Background

  • On Nov. 15, 2012, Hall County MANS officers, relying on a Gwinnett officer's tip, went to Kevin New’s residence seeking to search him and nearby structures.
  • Officers believed New was on probation and had a court-ordered Fourth Amendment waiver; probation records shown initially to officers indicated an active waiver.
  • New told officers repeatedly his probation had been terminated early; officers separately checked NCIC/GCIC and contacted probation to confirm he was on probation before searching.
  • In the warrantless searches (no consent, no warrant, no exigency, no arrest), officers found methamphetamine residue on New, drugs in a hide-away can, a butane lighter, cash, and a stolen GPS.
  • Uncontroverted proof at the suppression hearing established New’s probation had been terminated eight months earlier and the Fourth Amendment waiver was no longer valid.
  • The trial court granted New’s motion to suppress; the State appealed arguing the searches were reasonable, officers acted in good faith, and suppression was not required to serve deterrence.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether the warrantless searches were lawful under the totality of the circumstances / OCGA § 17-5-30 New: searches unlawful because he was not a probationer and no warrant, consent, exigency, or valid waiver existed State: searches reasonable because officers reasonably believed New was on probation and thus subject to waiver Held: Searches unlawful — New was not on probation; no exceptions to warrant requirement applied
Whether Georgia recognizes a good-faith exception to exclusionary rule New: exclusionary rule applies despite officers’ beliefs; evidence must be suppressed State: officers acted in objective good faith in relying on probation records, so suppression improper Held: No good-faith exception in Georgia; Gary controls, so evidence suppressed despite officers’ good faith
Whether an intermediate validated act (e.g., arrest) could salvage the search State: argues Harvey supports considering officers’ reasonable belief at the moment of action New: no valid intermediate act here to validate the search Held: Harvey is distinguishable — no intermediate valid arrest or lawful act here; cannot use Harvey to avoid Gary’s rule
Whether suppression would defeat the exclusionary rule’s deterrent purpose in light of officers’ conduct State: exclusion serves little deterrent value when officers act in good faith New: officers or agencies may have been negligent updating records; suppression can deter misconduct Held: Policy arguments noted but decision controlled by OCGA § 17-5-30 and Gary; suppression required

Key Cases Cited

  • Gary v. State, 262 Ga. 573 (Georgia Supreme Court decision holding Georgia does not recognize a Leon good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule)
  • Leon v. United States, 468 U.S. 897 (U.S. Supreme Court decision recognizing a judicially created good-faith exception to the federal exclusionary rule)
  • Harvey v. State, 266 Ga. 671 (Georgia Supreme Court — arrest-based probable cause measured by officer's current knowledge; distinguishable here)
  • Harper v. State, 283 Ga. 102 (Georgia Supreme Court — suppression required where officers relied on invalid warrant; no good-faith exception)
  • State v. Gallup, 236 Ga. App. 321 (Court of Appeals — warrantless search exceeded lawful scope; cited Gary to reject good-faith defense)
  • Brown v. State, 293 Ga. 787 (Georgia Supreme Court — standards for appellate review of suppression rulings)
  • Davis v. State, 262 Ga. 578 (Georgia Supreme Court — recognizes per se unreasonableness of searches outside judicial process)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: The State v. New
Court Name: Court of Appeals of Georgia
Date Published: Mar 12, 2015
Citations: 331 Ga. App. 139; 770 S.E.2d 239; A14A1876
Docket Number: A14A1876
Court Abbreviation: Ga. Ct. App.
Log In