331 Ga. App. 139
Ga. Ct. App.2015Background
- On Nov. 15, 2012, Hall County MANS officers, relying on a Gwinnett officer's tip, went to Kevin New’s residence seeking to search him and nearby structures.
- Officers believed New was on probation and had a court-ordered Fourth Amendment waiver; probation records shown initially to officers indicated an active waiver.
- New told officers repeatedly his probation had been terminated early; officers separately checked NCIC/GCIC and contacted probation to confirm he was on probation before searching.
- In the warrantless searches (no consent, no warrant, no exigency, no arrest), officers found methamphetamine residue on New, drugs in a hide-away can, a butane lighter, cash, and a stolen GPS.
- Uncontroverted proof at the suppression hearing established New’s probation had been terminated eight months earlier and the Fourth Amendment waiver was no longer valid.
- The trial court granted New’s motion to suppress; the State appealed arguing the searches were reasonable, officers acted in good faith, and suppression was not required to serve deterrence.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether the warrantless searches were lawful under the totality of the circumstances / OCGA § 17-5-30 | New: searches unlawful because he was not a probationer and no warrant, consent, exigency, or valid waiver existed | State: searches reasonable because officers reasonably believed New was on probation and thus subject to waiver | Held: Searches unlawful — New was not on probation; no exceptions to warrant requirement applied |
| Whether Georgia recognizes a good-faith exception to exclusionary rule | New: exclusionary rule applies despite officers’ beliefs; evidence must be suppressed | State: officers acted in objective good faith in relying on probation records, so suppression improper | Held: No good-faith exception in Georgia; Gary controls, so evidence suppressed despite officers’ good faith |
| Whether an intermediate validated act (e.g., arrest) could salvage the search | State: argues Harvey supports considering officers’ reasonable belief at the moment of action | New: no valid intermediate act here to validate the search | Held: Harvey is distinguishable — no intermediate valid arrest or lawful act here; cannot use Harvey to avoid Gary’s rule |
| Whether suppression would defeat the exclusionary rule’s deterrent purpose in light of officers’ conduct | State: exclusion serves little deterrent value when officers act in good faith | New: officers or agencies may have been negligent updating records; suppression can deter misconduct | Held: Policy arguments noted but decision controlled by OCGA § 17-5-30 and Gary; suppression required |
Key Cases Cited
- Gary v. State, 262 Ga. 573 (Georgia Supreme Court decision holding Georgia does not recognize a Leon good-faith exception to the exclusionary rule)
- Leon v. United States, 468 U.S. 897 (U.S. Supreme Court decision recognizing a judicially created good-faith exception to the federal exclusionary rule)
- Harvey v. State, 266 Ga. 671 (Georgia Supreme Court — arrest-based probable cause measured by officer's current knowledge; distinguishable here)
- Harper v. State, 283 Ga. 102 (Georgia Supreme Court — suppression required where officers relied on invalid warrant; no good-faith exception)
- State v. Gallup, 236 Ga. App. 321 (Court of Appeals — warrantless search exceeded lawful scope; cited Gary to reject good-faith defense)
- Brown v. State, 293 Ga. 787 (Georgia Supreme Court — standards for appellate review of suppression rulings)
- Davis v. State, 262 Ga. 578 (Georgia Supreme Court — recognizes per se unreasonableness of searches outside judicial process)