Swift v. Norwest Bank-Omaha West
828 N.W.2d 755
Neb.2013Background
- Swift filed 2009 suit against Norwest/N Wells Fargo seeking CD balance and interest from a 1984 CD.
- CD issued July 19, 1984, for $15,000, with 10.5% interest and auto-renewal unless notified otherwise.
- Decker (Swift’s mother) and Swift were joint depositors with survivorship; Decker died in 1991.
- CD matured April 19, 1985; Swift did not sue within 7 years after maturity, and had no renewal notices within 7 years before suit.
- Wells Fargo argued the action was time-barred under Neb. Rev. Stat. § 25-227, governing payment of CDs.
- District court granted summary judgment; Swift appealed challenging the statute and ownership arguments.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Swift’s claim is time-barred under § 25-227. | Swift argues renewal/extension revived the claim. | Wells Fargo contends § 25-227 bars action. | Yes; claim barred by § 25-227(3) as to automatically renewing CD. |
| Whether the CD is a negotiable instrument under UCC Article 3. | Swift treated the CD as a negotiable instrument. | CD not negotiable because not payable to bearer and nontransferable. | CD not negotiable; UCC Article 3 not applicable. |
| When the action must be commenced for an automatically renewing CD after 2008. | Swift could rely on last renewal/obligation communications. | Dispute governed by § 25-227(3) with later of maturity or July 1, 2008 dates. | Action must be commenced by the later of: 7 years after maturity or 1 year after July 1, 2008; Swift filed in 2009, barred. |
| Whether the § 25-227 challenge is governed by constitutional considerations. | Swift challenged constitutionality of § 25-227. | Constitutional issue not raised below; not reviewable on appeal. | Not decided; waived for failure to raise below (Shepherd rule). |
Key Cases Cited
- Professional Mgmt. Midwest v. Lund Co., 284 Neb. 777 (2012) (summary judgment standard; appellate review admissible evidence viewed in light for verdict)
- Shepherd v. Chambers, 281 Neb. 57 (2011) (constitutional issues not raised below not reviewable on appeal)
