507 P.3d 1152
Mont.2022Background
- While driving in Golden Valley County, Grussing rolled his truck; trooper observed open alcohol containers and signs of intoxication.
- Trooper Boots conducted field sobriety tests and a preliminary breath test (BAC 0.056%); Grussing was arrested and taken to Wheatland Memorial Hospital in Wheatland County.
- At the hospital Grussing refused a requested blood draw; Trooper Boots phoned Wheatland County Justice of the Peace Egebakken, who issued a search warrant for the blood draw.
- Blood test: THC 15 ng/ml (+/- 3 ng/ml) (above statutory limit); BAC 0.0025%.
- State charged Grussing with multiple counts including felony operation under the influence of delta-9-THC and felony criminal endangerment; Grussing moved to suppress the blood evidence.
- Grussing argued the Wheatland JP lacked jurisdiction because the crash and alleged offenses occurred in Golden Valley County; District Court denied suppression, Grussing pleaded guilty, and appealed.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether a Wheatland County justice of the peace had authority to issue a search warrant for a blood draw performed in Wheatland County where the underlying offense occurred in Golden Valley County | The State: jurisdiction depends on location of the search (Wheatland); JP may issue warrant within the judge’s geographic jurisdiction | Grussing: JP lacked authority because criminal jurisdiction is limited to offenses committed in the county where the court is established (Golden Valley) | The court held §46-5-220(2)(a) limits warrant issuance by limited-jurisdiction courts to their geographic jurisdiction (location of the search), not the location of the offense; JP had authority and suppression denial affirmed |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Smith, 407 Mont. 18 (standard of review for suppression rulings)
- State v. Staker, 404 Mont. 307 (standard of review precedent)
- Holms v. Bretz, 405 Mont. 186 (statutory interpretation: plain language controls)
