midpage
266 P.3d 1122
Haw.
2011

Try one of our plugins.

Chat with this case or research any legal issue with our plugins for Claude, ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Harvey.

ClaudeChatGPTPerplexity
Read the full case

Background

  • Tominiko was charged in an August 13, 2008 complaint with OVUII, Operating a Vehicle After License Suspension/Revocation for OVUII, and Driving Without Motor Vehicle Insurance; Counts II and III were later dismissed.
  • The district court denied suppression of evidence, and a stipulated-facts trial led to OVUII conviction but acquittal as a highly intoxicated driver; trial referenced a police report locating the offense on Ahonui St./N. School St. in Honolulu.
  • Tominiko moved to suppress on December 1, 2008, arguing no reasonable suspicion to stop; Officer Stuart testified to investigating a reported gathering with drinking near an intersection.
  • District court found reasonable suspicion existed and denied suppression; a breath test showed .160 BAC and OVUII conviction followed trial with Counts II and III dismissed.
  • The Hawai`i ICA issued three opinions; the lead opinion held the OVUII charge was not fatally defective under liberal construction and affirmed suppression was proper, while a concurrence and a dissent framed the issues differently.
  • This Court vacated the ICA judgment, vacated the district court judgment, and remanded for a new trial, holding (a) the OVUII charge was not sufficient under liberal construction and (b) Officer Stuart’s seizure was unconstitutional and tainted the evidence.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether OVUII was properly charged under liberal construction. Tominiko claims the OVUII count failed to allege operation on a public road. State argues liberal construction permits reading Counts I and III together to supply the missing public-road element. OVUII charge not defective under liberal construction.
Whether Officer Stuart’s stop violated the Hawai`i Constitution and tainted evidence admissibility. Stuart lacked reasonable suspicion; stop was unlawful and fruits tainted. The stop was supported by totality of circumstances and any taint was not applicable to the evidence. Seizure unconstitutional; evidence tainted; remand for new trial.

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Wheeler, 121 Hawai`i 383 (2009) (requires public-road element in OVUII when timely objection is raised)
  • State v. Motta, 66 Haw. 89 (1983) (liberal construction of charges when objection raised post-trial)
  • State v. Elliott, 77 Hawai`i 309 (1994) (illustrates saving defects by examining charge as a whole under liberal construction)
  • State v. Schroeder, 76 Hawai`i 517 (1994) (treatment of separate counts when construing charges as a whole)
  • State v. Sprattling, 99 Hawai`i 312 (2002) (instructions on interpreting charges as a whole)
  • Cummings, 101 Hawai`i 139 (2003) (jurisdictional defect when an oral charge does not state an offense)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Tominiko
Court Name: Hawaii Supreme Court
Date Published: Aug 26, 2011
Citations: 266 P.3d 1122; 126 Haw. 68; 2011 Haw. LEXIS 184; SCWC-29535
Docket Number: SCWC-29535
Court Abbreviation: Haw.
Log In