110 So. 3d 549
La.2013Background
- Defendant was charged by information with two counts of felony theft over $500 from different victims arising from post-Katrina demolition of the TwiRopa Mill in New Orleans.
- Count 1 alleged theft of $6,500 from Lloyd Michell; Count 2 alleged theft of $25,000 from Charles McGowan by fraudulent conduct.
- Terry Kutcher delivered heavy equipment to the site; defendant, owner of Diesel Truck Service, was the general contractor and allegedly misappropriated the equipment.
- Defendant allegedly sold the excavator to McGowan and the bulldozer to Michell after seizing them from the site and asserted ownership via mechanics’ liens and permits.
- Trial resulted in convictions on both counts, but the Fifth Circuit affirmed count 2 and reversed count 1, triggering cross-appeals to this court.
- This court reinstates the count 1 conviction and upholds the count 2 conviction, reversing the appellate court only as to count 1.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sufficiency of evidence to convict on count 1 (Michell) | State contends evidence shows defendant took property without permission and with intent to deprive. | Swanzy and related evidence create reasonable doubt about specific intent to steal. | Guilty verdict on count 1 upheld; evidence supports intent. |
| Sufficiency of evidence to convict on count 2 (McGowan) | State argues the excavator was sold fraudulently with intent to deprive, supported by evidence and witnesses. | Defense argues alternate explanations and disputed intent. | Guilty verdict on count 2 affirmed; no reversal. |
| Whether the court of appeal properly limited its review of intent | State asserts appellate court misapprehended circumstantial evidence and standard of review. | Defendant contends appellate analysis correctly doubted the state’s theory of intent. | Court of appeal reversed in part; this court reverses to reinstate count 1 and affirms count 2. |
| Appropriate standard for circumstantial-evidence sufficiency in this context | State relies on Captville and Jackson v. Virginia to uphold verdicts. | Defendant argues reasonable doubt exists given conflicting evidence. | Circumstantial evidence sufficient; jury could reasonably infer theft intent. |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Swanzy, 96 So.3d 498 (La. App. 5 Cir. 2012) (reversed count 1 for lack of sufficient evidence of specific intent, affirmed count 2)
- Captville v. State, 448 So.2d 676 (La. 1984) (circumstantial evidence standard; rational jurors may conclude guilt beyond reasonable doubt)
- Old Chief v. United States, 519 U.S. 172 (U.S. 1997) (narrative completeness; probative value of related testimony in circumstantial cases)
- Jackson v. Virginia, 443 U.S. 307 (U.S. 1979) (standard for evaluating sufficiency of evidence to sustain a conviction)