History
  • No items yet
midpage
17 N.W.3d 170
Neb.
2025
Read the full case

Background

  • Charmayne R. Strong was involved in a minor traffic accident and was suspected of driving under the influence by law enforcement.
  • Strong refused to take a preliminary breath test, was arrested, and then police obtained a search warrant for a chemical blood test.
  • She initially agreed to the blood test but subsequently refused after being transported to a hospital.
  • Strong was charged in county court with refusal to submit to a chemical test under Nebraska law (Neb. Rev. Stat. § 60-6,197).
  • Both the county court and the district court rejected Strong's arguments that refusal to submit when a warrant is present isn't criminalized by statute, and affirmed her conviction; the Nebraska Supreme Court granted direct review.

Issues

Issue Strong's Argument State's Argument Held
Whether refusing a chemical blood test sought by search warrant is a crime under § 60-6,197 The statute is only an "implied consent" law and doesn’t apply when police seek a blood test pursuant to a search warrant The statute broadly criminalizes refusing any lawfully required blood test, including those sought by warrant Refusal is a crime under § 60-6,197 even when the test is sought pursuant to a warrant
Whether there is a constitutional barrier to conviction for refusing a test sought by warrant Birchfield prohibits criminalizing refusal of warrantless blood tests, and she points to language allegedly allowing refusal to a warrant-backed test Birchfield only bars punishment for refusing warrantless, not warrant-backed, blood tests; a warrant makes the test lawful No constitutional barrier; refusal of a lawful search pursuant to warrant can be criminalized

Key Cases Cited

  • State v. Rothenberger, 294 Neb. 810 (Neb. 2016) (sets out elements of the offense of refusal to submit to chemical test)
  • State v. McCumber, 295 Neb. 941 (Neb. 2017) (applies Birchfield to Nebraska law; conviction vacated if blood test sought without warrant or exigency)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Strong
Court Name: Nebraska Supreme Court
Date Published: Feb 28, 2025
Citations: 17 N.W.3d 170; 318 Neb. 525; S-24-296
Docket Number: S-24-296
Court Abbreviation: Neb.
Log In
    State v. Strong, 17 N.W.3d 170