State v. Primack
2014 Ohio 1771
Ohio Ct. App.2014Background
- Jonathan Primack was indicted in Washington County for trafficking (Oxycodone); warrant issued June 2012.
- In December 2012 he pled guilty in Tuscarawas County to other drug offenses and began serving a 24‑month prison term on December 11, 2012.
- While serving the Tuscarawas sentence, Primack sought disposition of the Washington County charge and later pled guilty there pursuant to a plea agreement.
- At sentencing in Washington County the court imposed a 30‑month term to run concurrently with the Tuscarawas sentence and awarded only two days of jail‑time credit.
- Primack appealed, arguing he was entitled to credit for the days he spent incarcerated on the Tuscarawas sentence while awaiting disposition of the Washington County charge (about 157 days).
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Whether Primack is entitled to jail‑time credit for time incarcerated on an unrelated (Tuscarawas) sentence while awaiting disposition in Washington County | State: trial court correctly calculated credit (implicit) | Primack: should receive credit for pretrial confinement in Washington County while an arrest warrant was active and he could not post bail because he was serving the Tuscarawas sentence | Court: No. R.C. 2967.191 does not allow credit for time served on unrelated offenses even if sentences run concurrently; trial court did not err |
Key Cases Cited
- Fugate v. Welbaum, 117 Ohio St.3d 261 (Ohio 2008) (holds jail‑time credit must be applied to all concurrent prison terms imposed for charges on which the offender was held; but does not permit credit for time served on unrelated offenses)
