History
  • No items yet
midpage
State v. Preston
272 P.3d 1275
| Kan. | 2012
Read the full case

Background

  • Police stopped Preston on a pretextual traffic stop after a stabbing incident; drugs found in the car during the later search.
  • Preston claimed the drugs were not his and sought suppression of the drug and money evidence.
  • A prior conspiracy-to Possess cocaine with intent to distribute conviction was admitted under K.S.A. 60-455 to prove knowledge/intent.
  • Trial admitted and trial evidence included the prior conviction referenced in opening, affidavit, and detective testimony.
  • The Court of Appeals affirmed; the Kansas Supreme Court granted review to address admissibility of the prior conviction.
  • Court reverses on the 60-455 issue and remands for a new trial on that issue, limiting consideration of other errors.

Issues

Issue Plaintiff's Argument Defendant's Argument Held
Whether prior drug conviction admissible under 60-455 Preston: inadmissible under Boggs; not disputed State: intent disputed due to constructive possession Not admissible; error reversible; remand for new trial
Is admission harmless error Error affected substantial rights Harmless given other evidence Not harmless; remand for new trial on 60-455 issue
Impact of prior conviction on fairness of trial Propensity evidence prejudiced jury Limited relevance to intent Requires reversal and remand on 60-455 issue

Key Cases Cited

  • Boggs, 287 Kan. 298 (2008) (prior drug use inadmissible to prove intent when defendant denies possessing drugs)
  • Faulkner, 220 Kan. 153 (1976) (prior conviction admissible to prove intent when of disputed possession)
  • Wells, 289 Kan. 1219 (2009) (tests for admissibility of prior crimes under 60-455)
  • Gunby, 282 Kan. 39 (2006) (requirement of limiting instruction; probative vs prejudicial balance)
  • Reid, 286 Kan. 494 (2008) (materiality and relevancy standards for 60-455 evidence)
  • Garcia, 285 Kan. 1 (2007) (limiting purpose and reliance on 60-455 evidence)
  • McCullough, 293 Kan. _, 270 P.3d 1142 (2012) (nonconstitutional error review for evidentiary issues)
Read the full case

Case Details

Case Name: State v. Preston
Court Name: Supreme Court of Kansas
Date Published: Mar 23, 2012
Citation: 272 P.3d 1275
Docket Number: 98,629
Court Abbreviation: Kan.