318 Neb. 613
Neb.2025Background
- Officer Coon stopped Detron L. Perry after observing his vehicle’s rear turn signal was dim and blinking irregularly; Perry’s license was found to be suspended.
- Perry fled the scene when asked to exit the vehicle, leading to felony charges for operating a vehicle to avoid arrest and a misdemeanor driving under suspension.
- Perry moved to suppress evidence from the stop, arguing the turn signal was functioning and the stop was therefore unconstitutional.
- The trial court denied Perry’s motion to suppress and admitted evidence of his DMV suspension notifications, which Perry argued were sent to the wrong address.
- Perry was convicted on both counts and sentenced to probation; the district court did not impose a 2-year license revocation, despite statutory language suggesting it was mandatory for his felony conviction.
- On appeal, Perry challenged the traffic stop, sufficiency of notice evidence, and the sufficiency for the avoid-arrest charge; the State cross-appealed on the sentencing error.
Issues
| Issue | Perry's Argument | State's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Constitutionality of the traffic stop | Stop lacked probable cause as the turn signal was functioning, even if dim | Officer’s belief was reasonable under the circumstances, creating probable cause | Probable cause existed; motion to suppress was properly denied |
| Sufficiency of evidence—DMV notice | Notices sent to an outdated address, lacking proof Perry knew of suspension | Law requires notice be sent to DMV’s last-known address, not actual notice/receipt | Sufficient evidence to support conviction |
| Sufficiency—avoid arrest conviction | He was not told he was under arrest or would be cited before fleeing | Crime occurs by fleeing before arrest occurs; specific announcement unnecessary | Sufficient evidence; conviction affirmed |
| Mandatory license revocation | Language allows discretion on whether to revoke/impound license | Statute’s use of “shall” makes 2-year revocation mandatory upon felony conviction | Revocation is mandatory; plain error for not imposing; remanded for resentencing |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Barbeau, 301 Neb. 293 (traffic violations—no matter how minor—create probable cause for a stop)
- State v. Moderow, 226 Neb. 470 (notice of suspension is proper if sent to DMV’s last-known address regardless of receipt)
- State v. Armagost, 291 Neb. 117 (crime of operating a motor vehicle to avoid arrest does not require completion of arrest)
- State v. Collins, 307 Neb. 581 (statutory language requiring license revocation at sentencing)
- State v. Irish, 298 Neb. 61 (usage of "shall" in statute is ordinarily mandatory, not discretionary)
