State v. Perkins
2019 Ohio 2288
Ohio Ct. App.2019Background
- Perkins was arrested after a car crash (Aug 2016), posted bond, later indicted in two separate Lake County cases: 16-CR-000846 (drug charges) and 16-CR-000928 (vehicular assault/DUI related to the crash).
- He was jailed on multiple occasions (Aug 1–23, 2016; Oct 5–7, 2016; Jan 20–Apr 13, 2017; Apr 13–May 30, 2017) after bond revocations and pending proceedings.
- Sentences: in 16-CR-000846, two consecutive 10-month terms (total 20 months) with 86 days credit; in 16-CR-000928, five years + six months concurrent with the 16-CR-000846 sentence with 138 days credit.
- Perkins moved pro se for additional jail-time credit (claimed 224 days), arguing the aggregate days should be applied to each concurrent term; trial court denied the motion.
- He appealed the denial, challenging the calculation and relying on Fugate and Caccamo principles concerning credit for days served while detained on pending charges.
Issues
| Issue | Plaintiff's Argument | Defendant's Argument | Held |
|---|---|---|---|
| Proper calculation and allocation of jail-time credit for overlapping periods and concurrent sentences | Perkins: aggregate days (224) should be credited across concurrent sentences; trial court erred in denying additional credit | State/Trial court: credit must be tied to confinement "arising out of" each offense; overlapping period credited to both cases but some periods related only to a single case; later incarceration while serving an earlier-imposed sentence is not creditable to the earlier sentence | Court affirmed: trial court's allocation (86 days in 16-CR-000846; 138 days in 16-CR-000928) was correct; Perkins not entitled to additional credit; some contested principles (crediting days after an earlier sentence begins) noted but not raised on cross-appeal |
Key Cases Cited
- State v. Fugate, 117 Ohio St.3d 261 (2008) (Equal Protection requires jail-time credit be applied to each concurrent term for confinement arising from pending charges)
- State v. Marcum, 146 Ohio St.3d 516 (2016) (standards governing appellate review of criminal-sentencing matters)
